Evaluating cardiac murmurs; are diagnostic tests helpful? 2001

C Macleod
Department of Paediatrics, Antrim Area Hospital, Northern Ireland. cmacleod@doctors.org.uk

The detection of an asymptomatic murmur in a child usually results in a referral to a consultant paediatrician. In most cases a chest radiograph (CXR) and electrocardiograph (ECG) are performed as an aid to diagnosis, however the evidence for this is contradictory. A retrospective chart review of children referred with asymptomatic cardiac murmurs in a one-year period was conducted. We wished to determine whether CXR and ECG are useful diagnostic aids. 81 patient charts were reviewed. Of those patients with a clinical diagnosis of pathological murmur all had normal CXR and ECG. Never the less 2 cases were referred for echocardiogram and were found to have structural heart disease. Of those with a clinical diagnosis of innocent murmur most (81%) had a CXR and ECG and in most cases (96%) these were normal. Those cases with abnormal investigations subsequently were shown to have structurally normal hearts on echocardiogram. We conclude that routine use of CXR and ECG in evaluating asymptomatic cardiac murmurs in children is not useful.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D012017 Referral and Consultation The practice of sending a patient to another program or practitioner for services or advice which the referring source is not prepared to provide. Consultation,Gatekeepers, Health Service,Hospital Referral,Second Opinion,Consultation and Referral,Health Service Gatekeepers,Hospital Referrals,Referral,Referral, Hospital,Referrals, Hospital,Consultations,Gatekeeper, Health Service,Health Service Gatekeeper,Opinion, Second,Opinions, Second,Referrals,Second Opinions
D004562 Electrocardiography Recording of the moment-to-moment electromotive forces of the HEART as projected onto various sites on the body's surface, delineated as a scalar function of time. The recording is monitored by a tracing on slow moving chart paper or by observing it on a cardioscope, which is a CATHODE RAY TUBE DISPLAY. 12-Lead ECG,12-Lead EKG,12-Lead Electrocardiography,Cardiography,ECG,EKG,Electrocardiogram,Electrocardiograph,12 Lead ECG,12 Lead EKG,12 Lead Electrocardiography,12-Lead ECGs,12-Lead EKGs,12-Lead Electrocardiographies,Cardiographies,ECG, 12-Lead,EKG, 12-Lead,Electrocardiograms,Electrocardiographies, 12-Lead,Electrocardiographs,Electrocardiography, 12-Lead
D006337 Heart Murmurs Heart sounds caused by vibrations resulting from the flow of blood through the heart. Heart murmurs can be examined by HEART AUSCULTATION, and analyzed by their intensity (6 grades), duration, timing (systolic, diastolic, or continuous), location, transmission, and quality (musical, vibratory, blowing, etc). Cardiac Murmurs,Diastolic Murmurs,Innocent Murmurs,Cardiac Murmur,Diastolic Murmur,Heart Murmur,Innocent Murmur,Murmur, Cardiac,Murmur, Diastolic,Murmur, Heart,Murmur, Innocent,Murmurs, Cardiac,Murmurs, Diastolic,Murmurs, Heart,Murmurs, Innocent
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012189 Retrospective Studies Studies used to test etiologic hypotheses in which inferences about an exposure to putative causal factors are derived from data relating to characteristics of persons under study or to events or experiences in their past. The essential feature is that some of the persons under study have the disease or outcome of interest and their characteristics are compared with those of unaffected persons. Retrospective Study,Studies, Retrospective,Study, Retrospective
D013902 Radiography, Thoracic X-ray visualization of the chest and organs of the thoracic cavity. It is not restricted to visualization of the lungs. Thoracic Radiography,Radiographies, Thoracic,Thoracic Radiographies

Related Publications

C Macleod
August 1993, Advances in dental research,
C Macleod
August 2016, Journal of evaluation in clinical practice,
C Macleod
March 2008, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
C Macleod
January 1920, Transactions of the American Climatological and Clinical Association. American Climatological and Clinical Association,
C Macleod
March 2008, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
C Macleod
April 1999, The Medical journal of Australia,
C Macleod
January 2005, Lancet (London, England),
Copied contents to your clipboard!