The widely used food additives butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) and butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) react with oxyhemoglobin, thereby forming methemoglobin. The reaction rates were measured using visible spectroscopy, and second order rate constants were established for BHA and compared with p-hydroxyanisole. Using ESR we investigated the involvement of free radical reaction intermediates. The expected one-electron oxidation product of BHA and BHT, the phenoxyl radical, could only be detected with pure 3-t-butyl-4-hydroxyanisole and oxyhemoglobin. With the commercial mixture of 2- and 3-t-butyl-4-hydroxyanisole a very strong ESR signal of a secondary free radical species was observed, similar to the one observed earlier with p-hydroxyanisole and dependent on the presence of free thiol groups, so that we assumed the intermediate existence of a perferryl species, the MetHb-H2O2 adduct. In a second series of experiments we investigated the reactivity of this postulated intermediate with BHA and BHT, starting with a pure MetHb/H2O2-phenol mixture in a stopped-flow apparatus linked to the ESR spectrometer, detecting the expected phenoxyl radicals from BHA and p-hydroxyanisole. Due to the low solubility and decreased reactivity of BHT only traces of phenoxyl type radical were found together with a high concentration of unreacted perferryl species. The reactivity of BHA, BHT and p-hydroxyanisole with free thiol groups is demonstrated by an increased reaction rate in the presence of the thiol group blocking substance NEM.