The presence of a proton-donating catalytic amino acid side chain in orotidylate decarboxylase (ODCase) was sought by site-directed mutagenesis. Replacement of yeast ODCase Lys93 with a cysteine resulted in a mutant protein (K93C) with no measurable activity, representing a decrease in activity by a factor of, at most, 2 x 10(-8) times the activity of the wild-type enzyme. Treatment of this mutant protein with 2-bromoethylamine, designed to append Cys93 to yield S-(2-aminoethyl)cysteine, restored activity by a factor of at least 5 x 10(5) over the untreated mutant protein. Activity could not be restored by treatment with other brominated reagents designed to replace the epsilon-amino of S-(2-aminoethyl)Cys93 with a different functional group. The overall architecture of the K93C protein was not significantly changed, as judged by the similar dimerization properties (in the absence of ligands) of the mutant enzyme compared to the wild-type enzyme. The binding affinity of the substrate orotidylate was not measurably changed by the mutation, indicating that Lys93 has an essential role in catalysis which is mechanistically distinguishable from substrate binding. Apparently the mutation removes an integral portion of the active site and does not drastically affect the structural or substrate binding properties. However, the affinities of the mutant protein for the competitive inhibitors 6-azauridylate (6-azaUMP) and UMP are significantly altered from the pattern seen with the wild-type enzyme. The K93C protein has an affinity for the neutral ligand UMP which is greater than that for the anionic 6-azaUMP, in clear contrast to the preference for 6-azaUMP displayed by the wild-type enzyme. Lys93 is apparently critical for catalysis of the substrate to product and for the binding of anionic inhibitors; the data are discussed in terms of previously existing models for transition-state analogue inhibitor binding and catalysis.