[Ethical and social problems posed by organ transplantation]. 1992

C Cabrol
Hôpital de la Pitié, Paris.

Organ transplantation more than a scientific fact is now a social fact. Since the first organ transplantations in France, forty years ago, medicine demonstrated its ability to perform the operation and to obtain (what was more difficult) the tolerance of the graft but medicine so far remains unable to give the material: organs. These organs are given by the donor's relatives when the kidney is concerned and when it is a donation from a living person. But such donation remain strictly limited in our country (less then 5% of the kidney transplantations) due to the risk of moral pressure and commercialization. More often and for the other organs (liver, heart, lung) a the donation is obtained after death, a special and dramatic death: the brain death. The nowadays spectacular results of organ transplantation 70 to 80% survival rate at 10 years with a complete rehabilitation gave a considerable increase on the demand. Unfortunately organ transplantation is the victim of its success, the number of donor's organ being insufficient to satisfy the needs. So in December 1990, 6,055 patients were on the waiting list and only 3,772 (56%) were transplanted. In December 1991, 6,334 patients were on the waiting list and may be only 4,000 could be transplanted. So the difference between the needs and the possibilities is increasing each year with for consequences, the death of 10% of the waiting patients and, for those who could be transplanted, a considerable increase in the waiting period responsible for slow deterioration of their status and less chances of success. The reason of the lack of organs is not due to the lack of brain deaths which are unfortunately too numerous, but to the impossibilities of organ retrieval due to: too advanced age or the presence of a transmissible disease of the donor, lack of medical means in some intensive care units, and family refusal. This refusal is easily understood and due to the very peculiar conditions in which the donation is required: the unexpected death of a loved parent and such a death with some life appearance. To avoid the increasing number of such refusal two actions are possible. One is the modification of the law. The French law is the Caillavet law which requires for organ retrieval, the written permission of the parents for a minor, or for an adult the absence of refusal expressed during his or her life.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D004992 Ethics, Medical The principles of professional conduct concerning the rights and duties of the physician, relations with patients and fellow practitioners, as well as actions of the physician in patient care and interpersonal relations with patient families. Medical Ethics
D005602 France A country in western Europe bordered by the Atlantic Ocean, the English Channel, the Mediterranean Sea, and the countries of Belgium, Germany, Italy, Spain, Switzerland, the principalities of Andorra and Monaco, and by the duchy of Luxembourg. Its capital is Paris. Corsica,Saint Pierre and Miquelon,Miquelon and Saint Pierre,Miquelon and St. Pierre,St. Pierre and Miquelon
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012940 Social Problems Situations affecting a significant number of people, that are believed to be sources of difficulty or threaten the stability of the community, and that require programs of amelioration. Labor Exploitation,Social Exploitation,Exploitation, Labor,Exploitation, Social,Exploitations, Labor,Problem, Social,Problems, Social,Social Problem
D016377 Organ Transplantation Transference of an organ between individuals of the same species or between individuals of different species. Grafting, Organ,Transplantation, Organ,Graftings, Organ,Organ Grafting,Organ Graftings,Organ Transplantations,Transplantations, Organ

Related Publications

C Cabrol
January 1988, Archives francaises de pediatrie,
C Cabrol
February 1964, Techniques hospitalieres, medico-sociales et sanitaires,
C Cabrol
June 1972, Archives belges de medecine sociale, hygiene, medecine du travail et medecine legale. Belgisch archief van sociale geneeskunde, hygiene, arbeidsgeneeskunde en gerechtelijke geneeskunde,
C Cabrol
January 1987, Nouvelle revue francaise d'hematologie,
C Cabrol
June 1964, British medical journal,
C Cabrol
January 1970, Progress in surgery,
C Cabrol
August 2009, Therapeutische Umschau. Revue therapeutique,
C Cabrol
February 1999, Rozhledy v chirurgii : mesicnik Ceskoslovenske chirurgicke spolecnosti,
C Cabrol
January 1982, LARC medical,
C Cabrol
February 1992, Revue medicale de la Suisse romande,
Copied contents to your clipboard!