Proton beams to replace photon beams in radical dose treatments. 2003

Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA. hsuit@partners.org

With proton beam radiation therapy a smaller volume of normal tissues is irradiated at high dose levels for most anatomic sites than is feasible with any photon technique. This is due to the Laws of Physics, which determine the absorption of energy from photons and protons. In other words, the dose from a photon beam decreases exponentially with depth in the irradiated material. In contrast, protons have a finite range and that range is energy dependent. Accordingly, by appropriate distribution of proton energies, the dose can be uniform across the target and essentially zero deep to the target and the atomic composition of the irradiated material. The dose proximal to the target is lower compared with that in photon techniques, for all except superficial targets This resultant closer approximation of the planning treatment volume (PTV) to the CTV/GTV (grossly evident tumor volume/subclinical tumor extensions) constitutes a clinical gain by definition; i.e. a smaller treatment volume that covers the target three dimensionally for the entirety of each treatment session provides a clinical advantage. Several illustrative clinical dose distributions are presented and the clinical outcome results are reviewed briefly. An important technical advance will be the use of intensity modulated proton radiation therapy, which achieves contouring of the proximal edge of the SOBP (spread out Bragg peak) as well as the distal edge. This technique uses pencil beam scanning. To permit further progressive reductions of the PTV, 4-D treatment planning and delivery is required. The fourth dimension is time, as the position and contours of the tumor and the adjacent critical normal tissues are not constant. A potentially valuable new method for assessing the clinical merits of each of a large number of treatment plans is the evaluation of multidimensional plots of the complication probabilities for each of 'n' critical normal tissues/ structures for a specified tumor control probability. The cost of proton therapy compared with that of very high technology photon therapy is estimated and evaluated. The differential is estimated to be approximately 1.5 provided there were to be no charge for the original facility and that there were sufficient patients for operating on an extended schedule (6-7 days of 14-16 h) with > or = two gantries and one fixed horizontal beam.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D009369 Neoplasms New abnormal growth of tissue. Malignant neoplasms show a greater degree of anaplasia and have the properties of invasion and metastasis, compared to benign neoplasms. Benign Neoplasm,Cancer,Malignant Neoplasm,Tumor,Tumors,Benign Neoplasms,Malignancy,Malignant Neoplasms,Neoplasia,Neoplasm,Neoplasms, Benign,Cancers,Malignancies,Neoplasias,Neoplasm, Benign,Neoplasm, Malignant,Neoplasms, Malignant
D011878 Radiotherapy The use of IONIZING RADIATION to treat malignant NEOPLASMS and some benign conditions. Radiotherapy, Targeted,Targeted Radiotherapy,Radiation Therapy,Radiation Therapy, Targeted,Radiation Treatment,Targeted Radiation Therapy,Radiation Therapies,Radiation Therapies, Targeted,Radiation Treatments,Radiotherapies,Radiotherapies, Targeted,Targeted Radiation Therapies,Targeted Radiotherapies,Therapies, Radiation,Therapies, Targeted Radiation,Therapy, Radiation,Therapy, Targeted Radiation,Treatment, Radiation
D011879 Radiotherapy Dosage The total amount of radiation absorbed by tissues as a result of radiotherapy. Dosage, Radiotherapy,Dosages, Radiotherapy,Radiotherapy Dosages
D011880 Radiotherapy Planning, Computer-Assisted Computer-assisted mathematical calculations of beam angles, intensities of radiation, and duration of irradiation in radiotherapy. Computer-Assisted Radiotherapy Planning,Dosimetry Calculations, Computer-Assisted,Planning, Computer-Assisted Radiotherapy,Calculation, Computer-Assisted Dosimetry,Calculations, Computer-Assisted Dosimetry,Computer Assisted Radiotherapy Planning,Computer-Assisted Dosimetry Calculation,Computer-Assisted Dosimetry Calculations,Dosimetry Calculation, Computer-Assisted,Dosimetry Calculations, Computer Assisted,Planning, Computer Assisted Radiotherapy,Radiotherapy Planning, Computer Assisted
D004307 Dose-Response Relationship, Radiation The relationship between the dose of administered radiation and the response of the organism or tissue to the radiation. Dose Response Relationship, Radiation,Dose-Response Relationships, Radiation,Radiation Dose-Response Relationship,Radiation Dose-Response Relationships,Relationship, Radiation Dose-Response,Relationships, Radiation Dose-Response
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D016896 Treatment Outcome Evaluation undertaken to assess the results or consequences of management and procedures used in combating disease in order to determine the efficacy, effectiveness, safety, and practicability of these interventions in individual cases or series. Rehabilitation Outcome,Treatment Effectiveness,Clinical Effectiveness,Clinical Efficacy,Patient-Relevant Outcome,Treatment Efficacy,Effectiveness, Clinical,Effectiveness, Treatment,Efficacy, Clinical,Efficacy, Treatment,Outcome, Patient-Relevant,Outcome, Rehabilitation,Outcome, Treatment,Outcomes, Patient-Relevant,Patient Relevant Outcome,Patient-Relevant Outcomes
D017785 Photons Discrete concentrations of energy, apparently massless elementary particles, that move at the speed of light. They are the unit or quantum of electromagnetic radiation. Photons are emitted when electrons move from one energy state to another. (From Hawley's Condensed Chemical Dictionary, 11th ed)
D061766 Proton Therapy The use of an external beam of PROTONS as radiotherapy. Proton Beam Radiation Therapy,Proton Beam Therapy,Proton Beam Therapies,Proton Therapies,Therapies, Proton,Therapies, Proton Beam,Therapy, Proton,Therapy, Proton Beam
D018787 Radiation Oncology A subspecialty of medical oncology and radiology concerned with the radiotherapy of cancer. Oncology, Radiation,Radiology, Therapeutic,Therapeutic Radiology

Related Publications

Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
November 2004, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
February 2016, Cancer treatment reviews,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
August 2020, Physics in medicine and biology,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
January 2001, Medical dosimetry : official journal of the American Association of Medical Dosimetrists,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
January 1989, Acta oncologica (Stockholm, Sweden),
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
January 1987, Medical physics,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
July 2018, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
January 1994, Physical review. D, Particles and fields,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
September 2022, Medical physics,
Herman Suit, and Saveli Goldberg, and Andrzej Niemierko, and Alexei Trofimov, and Judith Adams, and Harald Paganetti, and George T Y Chen, and Thomas Bortfeld, and Stanley Rosenthal, and Jay Loeffler, and Thomas Delaney
January 1987, Medical physics,
Copied contents to your clipboard!