A cost-utility and cost-effectiveness analysis of an acute pain service. 2004

Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
Department of Anesthesiology, University Hospital Center, Charleroi, Belgium. michaela.stadler@chu-charleroi.be

OBJECTIVE To analyze, from a societal perspective, the cost-effectiveness and cost-utility of acute pain management after inception of a nurse-based Acute Pain Service (APS) in a general hospital. METHODS Open, observational, interventional study. METHODS Postanesthesia care unit and surgical wards of a university hospital center. METHODS 1975 surgical inpatients who had undergone various types of surgery. METHODS Visual analog scale (VAS) pain scores and all systemic analgesics prescribed by anesthesiologists and administered by ward nurses were recorded before and after APS inception. All costs (drugs, disposal, and working time of nurses) related to the APS were identified. Pain measurements were performed by VAS every 4 hours over 3 consecutive days post-surgery and transformed into a health state scale, with 0 being equivalent to absence of pain and 10 to the worst imaginable pain.Using these data, analgesic effectiveness (cost-utility analysis) was expressed as postoperative pain days averted (PPDA) in the two surveys. To perform the cost-effectiveness analysis, we focused on postoperative complications, duration of hospital stay, and postoperative mortality rate. (Note: At the time of the study, 1 EURO = 0.85 US dollars.) RESULTS VAS pain scores decreased in the post-APS phase (p < 0.001). One the first day, PPDA was 0.075, on the second day PPDA was 0.05, and the third day PPDA was 0.0375. Cost of analgesic drugs and disposal, as well as nursing hours, increased. The incremental cost of pain management after APS inception amounted to 19 EURO per patient per day, resulting in an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of 350.77 EURO per PPDA gained. The cost-effectiveness analysis showed minor improvement (reduction of postoperative complication rate in some surgical specialties). Duration of hospital stay and postoperative mortality rate did not change. CONCLUSIONS A hospital-wide, comprehensive, postoperative pain management program provides an overall positive result for the health care system by improving postoperative pain and morbidity. This service is cost-effective, costing 19 EURO per patient per day. A cost-utility analysis for short-term assessment of quality of life showed no benefit in determining usefulness of such a pain management program.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007902 Length of Stay The period of confinement of a patient to a hospital or other health facility. Hospital Stay,Hospital Stays,Stay Length,Stay Lengths,Stay, Hospital,Stays, Hospital
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D010147 Pain Measurement Scales, questionnaires, tests, and other methods used to assess pain severity and duration in patients or experimental animals to aid in diagnosis, therapy, and physiological studies. Analgesia Tests,Analogue Pain Scale,Formalin Test,McGill Pain Questionnaire,Nociception Tests,Pain Assessment,Pain Intensity,Pain Severity,Tourniquet Pain Test,Visual Analogue Pain Scale,Analog Pain Scale,Assessment, Pain,McGill Pain Scale,Visual Analog Pain Scale,Analgesia Test,Analog Pain Scales,Analogue Pain Scales,Formalin Tests,Intensity, Pain,Measurement, Pain,Nociception Test,Pain Assessments,Pain Intensities,Pain Measurements,Pain Questionnaire, McGill,Pain Scale, Analog,Pain Scale, Analogue,Pain Scale, McGill,Pain Severities,Pain Test, Tourniquet,Questionnaire, McGill Pain,Scale, Analog Pain,Scale, Analogue Pain,Scale, McGill Pain,Severity, Pain,Test, Analgesia,Test, Formalin,Test, Nociception,Test, Tourniquet Pain,Tests, Nociception,Tourniquet Pain Tests
D010149 Pain, Postoperative Pain during the period after surgery. Acute Post-operative Pain,Acute Postoperative Pain,Chronic Post-operative Pain,Chronic Post-surgical Pain,Chronic Postoperative Pain,Chronic Postsurgical Pain,Pain, Post-operative,Persistent Postsurgical Pain,Post-operative Pain,Post-operative Pain, Acute,Post-operative Pain, Chronic,Post-surgical Pain,Postoperative Pain, Acute,Postoperative Pain, Chronic,Postsurgical Pain,Postoperative Pain,Acute Post operative Pain,Chronic Post operative Pain,Chronic Post surgical Pain,Chronic Postsurgical Pains,Pain, Acute Post-operative,Pain, Acute Postoperative,Pain, Chronic Post-operative,Pain, Chronic Post-surgical,Pain, Chronic Postoperative,Pain, Chronic Postsurgical,Pain, Persistent Postsurgical,Pain, Post operative,Pain, Post-surgical,Pain, Postsurgical,Post operative Pain,Post operative Pain, Acute,Post operative Pain, Chronic,Post surgical Pain,Post-operative Pains,Post-surgical Pain, Chronic,Postsurgical Pain, Chronic,Postsurgical Pain, Persistent
D011997 Recovery Room Hospital unit providing continuous monitoring of the patient following anesthesia. Hospital Recovery Room,Hospital Recovery Rooms,Recovery Room, Hospital,Recovery Rooms,Recovery Rooms, Hospital,Room, Hospital Recovery,Room, Recovery,Rooms, Hospital Recovery,Rooms, Recovery
D003362 Cost-Benefit Analysis A method of comparing the cost of a program with its expected benefits in dollars (or other currency). The benefit-to-cost ratio is a measure of total return expected per unit of money spent. This analysis generally excludes consideration of factors that are not measured ultimately in economic terms. In contrast a cost effectiveness in general compares cost with qualitative outcomes. Cost and Benefit,Cost-Benefit Data,Benefits and Costs,Cost Benefit,Cost Benefit Analysis,Cost-Utility Analysis,Costs and Benefits,Economic Evaluation,Marginal Analysis,Analyses, Cost Benefit,Analysis, Cost Benefit,Analysis, Cost-Benefit,Analysis, Cost-Utility,Analysis, Marginal,Benefit and Cost,Cost Benefit Analyses,Cost Benefit Data,Cost Utility Analysis,Cost-Benefit Analyses,Cost-Utility Analyses,Data, Cost-Benefit,Economic Evaluations,Evaluation, Economic,Marginal Analyses
D005260 Female Females
D006785 Hospitals, University Hospitals maintained by a university for the teaching of medical students, postgraduate training programs, and clinical research. University Hospitals
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man

Related Publications

Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
April 2015, Journal of psychiatric research,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
October 2010, Anesthesia and analgesia,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
November 1990, Journal of dental education,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
January 2007, Journal of shoulder and elbow surgery,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
April 2009, Biologicals : journal of the International Association of Biological Standardization,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
February 2023, Annals of surgery,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
January 2012, BMJ open,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
November 1999, Journal of clinical anesthesia,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
October 2021, Journal of comparative effectiveness research,
Michaela Stadler, and Michael Schlander, and Monique Braeckman, and Thanh Nguyen, and Jean G Boogaerts
November 2012, Klinische Monatsblatter fur Augenheilkunde,
Copied contents to your clipboard!