Intraluminal traumatic neuromas are an unusual cause of bile duct obstruction. These benign collections of disorganized nerve fibers arise from a bile duct injury during cholecystectomy. Symptoms associated with obstruction or cholangitis may develop decades after the operation. Our patient's neuroma imitated a malignant neoplasm, but the patient has been returned to good health by resection of the right hepatic duct and the atrophic right hepatic lobe.