Acetone carboxylase catalyzes the carboxylation of acetone to acetoacetate with concomitant hydrolysis of ATP to AMP and two inorganic phosphates. The biochemical, molecular, and genetic properties of acetone carboxylase suggest it represents a fundamentally new class of carboxylase. As the initial step in catalysis, an alpha-proton from an inherently basic (pK(a) = 20) methyl group is abstracted to generate the requisite carbanion for attack on CO(2). In the present study alpha-proton abstraction from acetone has been investigated by using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry to follow proton-deuteron exchange between D(6)-acetone and water. Acetone carboxylase-catalyzed proton-deuteron exchange was dependent upon the presence of ATP, Mg(2+), and a monovalent cation (K(+), Rb(+), NH(4)(+)), and produced mixtures of isotopomers, ranging from singly exchanged H(1)D(5)- to fully exchanged H(6)-acetone. The initial rate of isotopic exchange was higher than k(cat) for acetone carboxylation. The time course of isotopic exchange showed that multiple exchange events occur for each acetone-binding event, and there was a 1:1 stoichiometric relationship between molecules of ATP hydrolyzed and the sum of new acetone isotopomers formed. ADP rather than AMP was formed as the predominant product of ATP hydrolysis during isotopic exchange. The stimulation of H(+)(-)D(+) exchange and ATP hydrolysis by K(+) followed saturation kinetics, with apparent K(m) values of 13.6 and 14.2 mM for the two activities, respectively. The rate of H(+) exchange into D(6)-acetone was greater than the rate of D(+) exchange into H(6)-acetone. There was an observable solvent (H(2)O vs D(2)O) isotope effect (1.7) for acetone carboxylation but no discernible substrate (H(6)- vs D(6)-acetone) isotope effect. It is proposed that alpha-proton abstraction from acetone occurs in concert with transfer of the gamma-phosphoryl group of ATP to the carbonyl oxygen, generating phosphoenol acetone as the activated nucleophile for attack on CO(2).