Subjective report versus objective measurement of activities of daily living in Parkinson's disease. 2006

Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
Department of Neurology, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland 21201, USA. lshulman@som.umaryland.edu

We compared subjective self-reports with objective performance ratings of activities of daily living (ADLs) and instrumental ADLs (IADLs) in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) and identified variables associated with discordance of ratings between these two methods. Seventy-six PD patients completed a modified Older Americans Resources and Services scale, assessing ADLs and IADLs. These results were compared with structured performance tests of walking, eating, dressing, money, and medicine management administered in the clinic. Patient performance was rated on a five-point Likert-type scale, ranging from 1 = no difficulty to 5 = completely unable to perform task. Significant differences were found between patients and clinicians' ratings on all tasks except walking. On the other four tasks, paired group t tests showed that patients reported better function compared with the clinician rating of medication management (1.33 vs. 2.80), eating (1.53 vs. 1.76), dressing (1.64 vs. 1.86), and managing money (1.44 vs. 2.06). A discrepancy was found between patients subjective reporting of ADL and IADL function and objective ratings. Patients overestimated their function on four of five tasks. Further study is necessary to identify whether subjective or objective performance ratings are more reflective of actual daily function.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008609 Mental Status Schedule Standardized clinical interview used to assess current psychopathology by scaling patient responses to the questions.
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D009043 Motor Activity Body movements of a human or an animal as a behavioral phenomenon. Activities, Motor,Activity, Motor,Motor Activities
D010300 Parkinson Disease A progressive, degenerative neurologic disease characterized by a TREMOR that is maximal at rest, retropulsion (i.e. a tendency to fall backwards), rigidity, stooped posture, slowness of voluntary movements, and a masklike facial expression. Pathologic features include loss of melanin containing neurons in the substantia nigra and other pigmented nuclei of the brainstem. LEWY BODIES are present in the substantia nigra and locus coeruleus but may also be found in a related condition (LEWY BODY DISEASE, DIFFUSE) characterized by dementia in combination with varying degrees of parkinsonism. (Adams et al., Principles of Neurology, 6th ed, p1059, pp1067-75) Idiopathic Parkinson Disease,Lewy Body Parkinson Disease,Paralysis Agitans,Primary Parkinsonism,Idiopathic Parkinson's Disease,Lewy Body Parkinson's Disease,Parkinson Disease, Idiopathic,Parkinson's Disease,Parkinson's Disease, Idiopathic,Parkinson's Disease, Lewy Body,Parkinsonism, Primary
D004185 Disability Evaluation Determination of the degree of a physical, mental, or emotional handicap. The diagnosis is applied to legal qualification for benefits and income under disability insurance and to eligibility for Social Security and workmen's compensation benefits. Disability Evaluations,Evaluation, Disability,Evaluations, Disability
D004435 Eating The consumption of edible substances. Dietary Intake,Feed Intake,Food Intake,Macronutrient Intake,Micronutrient Intake,Nutrient Intake,Nutritional Intake,Ingestion,Dietary Intakes,Feed Intakes,Intake, Dietary,Intake, Feed,Intake, Food,Intake, Macronutrient,Intake, Micronutrient,Intake, Nutrient,Intake, Nutritional,Macronutrient Intakes,Micronutrient Intakes,Nutrient Intakes,Nutritional Intakes
D004651 Employment The state of being engaged in an activity or service for wages or salary. Employment Termination,Employment Status,Labor Force,Occupational Status,Status, Occupational,Underemployment,Labor Forces,Status, Employment,Termination, Employment
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man

Related Publications

Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
June 2001, Clinical rehabilitation,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 1994, Journal of neural transmission. Parkinson's disease and dementia section,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
February 2020, Acta neurologica Scandinavica,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2022, Frontiers in neurology,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2022, Frontiers in neuroscience,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2023, Expert review of neurotherapeutics,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2013, PloS one,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2011, Parkinson's disease,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
May 2019, British journal of community nursing,
Lisa M Shulman, and Ingrid Pretzer-Aboff, and Karen E Anderson, and Rashida Stevenson, and Christopher G Vaughan, and Ann L Gruber-Baldini, and Stephen G Reich, and William J Weiner
January 2022, Frontiers in aging neuroscience,
Copied contents to your clipboard!