Categorical organization in free recall across culture and age. 2006

Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
Department of Psychology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich., USA. agutchess@wjh.harvard.edu

BACKGROUND Cross-cultural differences in cognition suggest that Westerners use categories more than Easterners, but these differences have only been investigated in young adults. OBJECTIVE The contributions of cognitive resource and the extent of cultural exposure are explored for free recall by investigating cross-cultural differences in categorical organization in younger and older adults. Cultural differences in the use of categories should be larger for elderly than young because categorization is a well-practiced strategy for Westerners, but age-related cognitive resource limitations may make the strategy difficult for elderly Easterners to implement. Therefore, we expect that cultural differences in categorization will be magnified in elderly adults relative to younger adults, with Americans categorizing more than Chinese. METHODS Across two studies, 112 young and 112 elderly drawn from two cultures (American and Chinese) encoded words presented in their native language. One word list contained categorically-unrelated words and the other, categorically-related words; both lists were presented in the participants' native language. In experiment 1, the words were strong category associates, and in experiment 2, the words were weak category associates. Participants recalled all the words they could remember, and the number of words recalled and degree of clustering by category were analyzed. RESULTS As predicted, cultural differences emerged for the elderly, with East-Asians using categories less than Americans during recall of highly-associated category exemplars (experiment 1). For recall of low-associate exemplars, East-Asians overall categorized less than Americans (experiment 2). Surprisingly, these differences in the use of categories did not lead to cultural differences in the number of words recalled. The expected effects of age were apparent with elderly recalling less than young, but in contrast to previous studies, elderly also categorized less than young. CONCLUSIONS These studies provide support for the notion that cultural differences in categorical organization are larger for elderly adults than young, although culture did not impact the amount recalled. These data suggest that culture and age interact to influence cognition.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011939 Mental Recall The process whereby a representation of past experience is elicited. Recall, Mental
D002681 China A country spanning from central Asia to the Pacific Ocean. Inner Mongolia,Manchuria,People's Republic of China,Sinkiang,Mainland China
D003431 Cross-Cultural Comparison Comparison of various psychological, sociological, or cultural factors in order to assess the similarities or diversities occurring in two or more different cultures or societies. Transcultural Studies,Comparison, Cross-Cultural,Comparisons, Cross-Cultural,Cross Cultural Comparison,Cross-Cultural Comparisons,Studies, Transcultural,Study, Transcultural,Transcultural Study
D003469 Culture A collective expression for all behavior patterns acquired and socially transmitted through symbols. Culture includes customs, traditions, and language. Cultural Relativism,Customs,Beliefs,Cultural Background,Background, Cultural,Backgrounds, Cultural,Belief,Cultural Backgrounds,Cultural Relativisms,Cultures,Relativism, Cultural,Relativisms, Cultural
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000293 Adolescent A person 13 to 18 years of age. Adolescence,Youth,Adolescents,Adolescents, Female,Adolescents, Male,Teenagers,Teens,Adolescent, Female,Adolescent, Male,Female Adolescent,Female Adolescents,Male Adolescent,Male Adolescents,Teen,Teenager,Youths
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D000368 Aged A person 65 years of age or older. For a person older than 79 years, AGED, 80 AND OVER is available. Elderly
D000375 Aging The gradual irreversible changes in structure and function of an organism that occur as a result of the passage of time. Senescence,Aging, Biological,Biological Aging

Related Publications

Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
June 1990, Psychology and aging,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
August 1986, Journal of abnormal psychology,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
December 1977, Activitas nervosa superior,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
September 1981, The Journal of genetic psychology,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
September 2009, Neuropsychologia,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
February 1976, Journal of abnormal psychology,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
July 1976, Memory & cognition,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
December 1974, Child development,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
January 2024, Memory & cognition,
Angela H Gutchess, and Carolyn Yoon, and Ting Luo, and Fred Feinberg, and Trey Hedden, and Qicheng Jing, and Richard E Nisbett, and Denise C Park
January 1973, L'annee psychologique,
Copied contents to your clipboard!