To clean or not to clean: effect on contamination rates in midstream urine collections in toilet-trained children. 2007

Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
Division of Pediatric Emergency Medicine, Montreal Children's Hospital, Place Tourelles, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3H 1P3. suzanne.vaillancourt@mail.mcgill.ca

OBJECTIVE Urinary tract infection is one of the most common bacterial infections among children. Difficulty in specimen collection and interpretation of inadequately collected specimens may contribute to misdiagnosis of urinary tract infection. Our objective was to assess the effect of perineal/genital cleaning on bacterial contamination rates of midstream urine collections in toilet-trained children. METHODS We conducted a randomized trial in toilet-trained children who presented to a tertiary care pediatric emergency department between November 1, 2004, and October 1, 2005. All toilet-trained children who were between the ages of 2 and 18 years and had a midstream urine sample requested were eligible. Those whose parents consented were cluster-randomized by week to either cleaning or not cleaning the perineum with soap. The risk for a contaminated urine culture (defined as growth of < 10(8) colony-forming units per liter [< 10(5) colony-forming units per milliliter] of a single organism or a mix of > or = 2 organisms) and the risk for a positive urinalysis (defined as a positive leukocyte esterase and/or nitrites on dipstick or > or = 5 white blood cells per high-powered field on a standard microscopic examination) were analyzed by intention to treat. RESULTS A total of 350 children were enrolled. The rate of contamination in the cleaning group was 14 (7.8%) of 179 vs 41 (23.9%) of 171 in the noncleaning group. Children who were randomly assigned to cleaning were less likely to have a positive urinalysis (37 of 179 [20.6%]) than those in the noncleaning group (63 of 171 [36.8%]). CONCLUSIONS Urine contamination rates are higher in midstream urine that is collected from toilet-trained children when obtained without perineal/genital cleaning. Cleaning may reduce the risk for returning for repeat cultures and for receiving unnecessary antibiotic treatment and investigations.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D010502 Perineum The body region lying between the genital area and the ANUS on the surface of the trunk, and to the shallow compartment lying deep to this area that is inferior to the PELVIC DIAPHRAGM. The surface area is between the VULVA and the anus in the female, and between the SCROTUM and the anus in the male. Perineums
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D002675 Child, Preschool A child between the ages of 2 and 5. Children, Preschool,Preschool Child,Preschool Children
D003902 Detergents Purifying or cleansing agents, usually salts of long-chain aliphatic bases or acids, that exert cleansing (oil-dissolving) and antimicrobial effects through a surface action that depends on possessing both hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties. Cleansing Agents,Detergent Pods,Laundry Detergent Pods,Laundry Pods,Syndet,Synthetic Detergent,Agent, Cleansing,Agents, Cleansing,Cleansing Agent,Detergent,Detergent Pod,Detergent Pod, Laundry,Detergent Pods, Laundry,Detergent, Synthetic,Detergents, Synthetic,Laundry Detergent Pod,Laundry Pod,Pod, Detergent,Pod, Laundry,Pod, Laundry Detergent,Pods, Detergent,Pods, Laundry,Pods, Laundry Detergent,Synthetic Detergents
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000293 Adolescent A person 13 to 18 years of age. Adolescence,Youth,Adolescents,Adolescents, Female,Adolescents, Male,Teenagers,Teens,Adolescent, Female,Adolescent, Male,Female Adolescent,Female Adolescents,Male Adolescent,Male Adolescents,Teen,Teenager,Youths
D013048 Specimen Handling Procedures for collecting, preserving, and transporting of specimens sufficiently stable to provide accurate and precise results suitable for clinical interpretation. Specimen Collection,Collection, Specimen,Collections, Specimen,Handling, Specimen,Handlings, Specimen,Specimen Collections,Specimen Handlings
D014039 Toilet Training Conditioning to defecate and urinate in culturally acceptable places. Toilet Trainings,Training, Toilet,Trainings, Toilet

Related Publications

Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
October 1986, The Journal of pediatrics,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
January 1989, The Journal of pediatrics,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
January 2018, The American journal of emergency medicine,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
August 2021, Pediatrics,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
August 2005, BJU international,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
January 1989, The Journal of pediatrics,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
April 2014, International emergency nursing,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
March 2006, Emergency medicine journal : EMJ,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
January 2008, Evidence-based nursing,
Suzanne Vaillancourt, and David McGillivray, and Xun Zhang, and Michael S Kramer
December 2007, Evidence-based medicine,
Copied contents to your clipboard!