'Mental retardation' or 'intellectual disability': time for a conceptual change. 2008

Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
WPA Section Psychiatry of Mental Retardation/Intellectual Disability, Jerez, Spain. luis.salvador@telefonica.net

BACKGROUND The term 'mental retardation' (MR) is outdated and has changed to 'intellectual disability' (ID). Unfortunately, this decision did not follow a nosology approach. The aim of this overview is twofold: (1) to provide a conceptual background and framing on the ID/MR field to other psychiatrists, and (2) to provide a nosology-based perspective to the debate on the name and concept of MR/ID. METHODS This conceptual paper is based on a literature review and on an iterative process of debate within the WPA Section 'Psychiatry of Mental Retardation'. RESULTS ID may be regarded not as a disease or as a disability but as a syndrome grouping (metasyndrome) similar to the construct of dementia. It includes a heterogeneous group of clinical conditions, ranging from genetic to nutritional, infectious, metabolic or neurotoxic conditions. The ID metasyndrome is characterized by a deficit in cognitive functioning prior to the acquisition of skills through learning. The intensity of the deficit is such to interfere in a significant way with individual normal functioning as expressed in limitations in activities and restriction in participation (disabilities). CONCLUSIONS The name 'developmental cognitive impairment' is here suggested to coexist with ID for naming the metasyndrome previously called MR following a polysemic-polynomious approach.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008607 Intellectual Disability Subnormal intellectual functioning which originates during the developmental period. This has multiple potential etiologies, including genetic defects and perinatal insults. Intelligence quotient (IQ) scores are commonly used to determine whether an individual has an intellectual disability. IQ scores between 70 and 79 are in the borderline range. Scores below 67 are in the disabled range. (from Joynt, Clinical Neurology, 1992, Ch55, p28) Disability, Intellectual,Idiocy,Mental Retardation,Retardation, Mental,Deficiency, Mental,Intellectual Development Disorder,Mental Deficiency,Mental Retardation, Psychosocial,Deficiencies, Mental,Development Disorder, Intellectual,Development Disorders, Intellectual,Disabilities, Intellectual,Disorder, Intellectual Development,Disorders, Intellectual Development,Intellectual Development Disorders,Intellectual Disabilities,Mental Deficiencies,Mental Retardations, Psychosocial,Psychosocial Mental Retardation,Psychosocial Mental Retardations,Retardation, Psychosocial Mental,Retardations, Psychosocial Mental
D009626 Terminology as Topic Works about the terms, expressions, designations, or symbols used in a particular science, discipline, or specialized subject area. Etymology,Nomenclature as Topic,Etymologies
D010641 Phenotype The outward appearance of the individual. It is the product of interactions between genes, and between the GENOTYPE and the environment. Phenotypes
D011570 Psychiatry The medical science that deals with the origin, diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders.
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man

Related Publications

Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
December 2011, American journal of medical genetics. Part A,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
March 2012, Pediatrics in review,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
August 2013, Federal register,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
April 2007, Intellectual and developmental disabilities,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
April 2000, Journal of intellectual disability research : JIDR,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
June 2007, Primary care,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
October 2008, Pediatric clinics of North America,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
August 2022, Journal of medical ethics,
Luis Salvador-Carulla, and Marco Bertelli
December 1995, Mental retardation,
Copied contents to your clipboard!