Evaluation of two serological methods for potency testing of whole cell pertussis vaccines. 2008

C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Centre for the Research and Evaluation of Immunobiological Products, Roma, Italy. christina.vonhunolstein@iss.it

The European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) and the World Health Organization (WHO) require the performance of extensive quality control testing including a potency test before a vaccine batch is released for human use. Whole cell pertussis (wP) vaccine potency is assessed by a mouse protection test (MPT) based on the Kendrick test. This test compares the vaccine dose necessary to protect 50% of mice against the effect of a lethal intracerebral dose of Bordetella pertussis and the dose of a suitable reference vaccine needed to give the same protection level. Due to the large variability in the results of this test and the severe distress which is inflicted on the many animals involved, its replacement by an alternative method is highly desirable. At the initiative of the European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines and HealthCare (EDQM) of the Council of Europe, in collaboration with the WHO and the In-vitro toxicology Unit/European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) of the European Commission (EC) Joint Research Centre-Institute for Health and Consumer Protection (JRC-IHCP), wP vaccine specialists from all over the world were invited to present an overview of candidate alternatives at a symposium organised in Geneva (Switzerland) in March 2005. Although no alternative method was found suitable for immediate implementation of batch potency control, the Pertussis Serological Potency Test (PSPT), initially developed in mice and recently transferred to guinea pigs (gps), was identified as a model of interest. Using the PSPT in gps to test several components of combined vaccines such as Diphtheria-Tetanus-wP vaccines in the same animal series would allow further implementation of the European 3Rs policy to batch potency control, by additional method refinement and reduction of animal use. The present study evaluated 2 features of the serological response to wP vaccination: 1) the overall antibody response as measured by a "whole cell" ELISA (PSPT-wC-ELISA) which uses the B. pertussis 18323 challenge strain prescribed for the MPT to coat the assay plates and 2) the functional neutralising antibodies to pertussis toxin (PT, one of the main virulence factors of B. pertussis), as measured by the Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell assay. The results showed that 1) the gp model can be used for wP vaccine potency testing; 2) despite good repeatability and precision, the CHO cell assay did not generate results comparable to the MPT. Moreover, the CHO cell assay showed significant differences in the ability of wP vaccines to induce neutralising anti-PT antibodies, which did not correlate to the overall antibody response evaluated by PSPT-wC-ELISA; 3) comparable potencies were obtained in the MPT and the PSPT-wC-ELISA. This study, supported by the previous ones correlating the PSPT-wC-ELISA in mice with the MPT, confirms that PSPT-wC-ELISA in gps is a promising approach for batch release potency testing of wP vaccines for which consistency in production has already been demonstrated by the MPT. However, a large scale validation study is required prior to the adoption of PSPT-wC-ELISA as a compendial reference method for wP vaccines batch release control.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007111 Immunity, Cellular Manifestations of the immune response which are mediated by antigen-sensitized T-lymphocytes via lymphokines or direct cytotoxicity. This takes place in the absence of circulating antibody or where antibody plays a subordinate role. Cell-Mediated Immunity,Cellular Immune Response,Cell Mediated Immunity,Cell-Mediated Immunities,Cellular Immune Responses,Cellular Immunities,Cellular Immunity,Immune Response, Cellular,Immune Responses, Cellular,Immunities, Cell-Mediated,Immunities, Cellular,Immunity, Cell-Mediated,Response, Cellular Immune
D008297 Male Males
D010567 Pertussis Vaccine A suspension of killed Bordetella pertussis organisms, used for immunization against pertussis (WHOOPING COUGH). It is generally used in a mixture with diphtheria and tetanus toxoids (DTP). There is an acellular pertussis vaccine prepared from the purified antigenic components of Bordetella pertussis, which causes fewer adverse reactions than whole-cell vaccine and, like the whole-cell vaccine, is generally used in a mixture with diphtheria and tetanus toxoids. (From Dorland, 28th ed) Vaccine, Pertussis
D003412 Cricetulus A genus of the family Muridae consisting of eleven species. C. migratorius, the grey or Armenian hamster, and C. griseus, the Chinese hamster, are the two species used in biomedical research. Hamsters, Armenian,Hamsters, Chinese,Hamsters, Grey,Armenian Hamster,Armenian Hamsters,Chinese Hamster,Chinese Hamsters,Grey Hamster,Grey Hamsters,Hamster, Armenian,Hamster, Chinese,Hamster, Grey
D004797 Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay An immunoassay utilizing an antibody labeled with an enzyme marker such as horseradish peroxidase. While either the enzyme or the antibody is bound to an immunosorbent substrate, they both retain their biologic activity; the change in enzyme activity as a result of the enzyme-antibody-antigen reaction is proportional to the concentration of the antigen and can be measured spectrophotometrically or with the naked eye. Many variations of the method have been developed. ELISA,Assay, Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent,Assays, Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent,Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay,Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assays,Immunosorbent Assay, Enzyme-Linked,Immunosorbent Assays, Enzyme-Linked
D005060 Europe The continent north of AFRICA, west of ASIA and east of the ATLANTIC OCEAN. Northern Europe,Southern Europe,Western Europe
D005260 Female Females
D006168 Guinea Pigs A common name used for the genus Cavia. The most common species is Cavia porcellus which is the domesticated guinea pig used for pets and biomedical research. Cavia,Cavia porcellus,Guinea Pig,Pig, Guinea,Pigs, Guinea
D006224 Cricetinae A subfamily in the family MURIDAE, comprising the hamsters. Four of the more common genera are Cricetus, CRICETULUS; MESOCRICETUS; and PHODOPUS. Cricetus,Hamsters,Hamster
D000818 Animals Unicellular or multicellular, heterotrophic organisms, that have sensation and the power of voluntary movement. Under the older five kingdom paradigm, Animalia was one of the kingdoms. Under the modern three domain model, Animalia represents one of the many groups in the domain EUKARYOTA. Animal,Metazoa,Animalia

Related Publications

C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
October 2014, Expert review of vaccines,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
January 2002, Developments in biologicals,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
January 1992, Vaccine,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
June 2019, Archives of Razi Institute,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
February 2004, Expert review of vaccines,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
January 1996, Developments in biological standardization,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
January 2004, Pharmeuropa bio,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
January 1979, Annales immunologiae Hungaricae,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
June 1999, Biologicals : journal of the International Association of Biological Standardization,
C von Hunolstein, and M J Gomez Miguel, and C Pezzella, and F Scopetti, and M-E Behr-Gross, and M Halder, and S Hoffmann, and L Levels, and J van der Gun, and C Hendriksen
October 2002, Pharmeuropa. Special issue biologicals,
Copied contents to your clipboard!