Knee MR-arthrography in assessment of meniscal and chondral lesions. 2009

L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
Orthopaedics and Traumatology Department, Bégin Military Academic Hospital, 69, avenue de Paris, 94160 Saint-Mandé, France. laurent_tom2@yahoo.fr

BACKGROUND No study, so far in France, has investigated the diagnosis value of knee MR-arthrography since the recent approval of intra-articular gadolinium use, by this country's healthcare authorities. This study objective is to verify the MR-arthrography superiority on conventional knee MRI, in meniscus and cartilage knee lesions diagnosing accuracy both in regard to sensitivity and specificity. OBJECTIVE MR-arthrography, represents in some pathologic situations, a more accurate source of information than conventional MRI. METHODS Over a 27 months period, 25 patients, scheduled to undergo a knee arthroscopy volunteered, after having been fully informed of the possible interest and risk of the MR-arthrography examination, to participate in this study. Twenty-one of them were finally included since in four cases the surgical indication was not confirmed. The group consisted of 15 males and six females with an average age of 35.7 years. All of them consecutively underwent conventional MRI, MR-arthrography finally followed by arthroscopy. The MRI and MR-arthrograms results were compared to the arthroscopy findings using the nonparametric Kappa test. RESULTS To diagnose meniscal tears, statistical agreement measure for MRI with arthroscopy was good (K=0.69) but not as good as the MR-arthrography/arthroscopy agreement which, by itself was excellent (K=0.84). As a diagnosis tool, the sensitivity and specificity of MR-arthrography (respectively 100 and 89.6%) were much higher than the corresponding values observed in conventional MRI (92.3 and 82.8%, respectively) which nonetheless remain satisfactory. The meniscal tears characterization seemed to be better interpreted using MR-arthrography. As far as the chondral lesions in this series, they were predominantly located on the patellar surface and in the medial femorotibial compartment. For diagnosing the latter, the MRI/arthroscopy agreement was good (K=0.70) but not as good as the MR-arthrography/arthroscopy agreement (K=0.805) which can be rated excellent. The detection sensitivity thus increased by 10% with gadolinium intra-articular injection. However, assessment accuracy of the lesions depth was mediocre, with frequent errors for the intermediary stages. CONCLUSIONS Intra-articular gadolinium injection improved MRI performances for numerous reasons: filling the joint, reinforcing the synovial fluid signal, and enhancing anatomic structures contrast on the T1-weighted sequences images. In this study, MR-arthrography appeared to be superior to conventional MRI in meniscal and cartilaginous lesions diagnosis, confirming the results previously obtained in other countries. In light of these results and other data from the literature, MR-arthrography can be indicated as an alternative to CT-arthrography in various clinical situations: detection of recurrent tears on operated menisci, search for cartilaginous lesions or foreign bodies in the joint space, and preoperative assessment before chondral repair procedures. However, conventional MRI remains the reference examination for studying cartilage, because the low resolution of MR-arthrography limits its performances in quantitative assessment of lesions depth.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008279 Magnetic Resonance Imaging Non-invasive method of demonstrating internal anatomy based on the principle that atomic nuclei in a strong magnetic field absorb pulses of radiofrequency energy and emit them as radiowaves which can be reconstructed into computerized images. The concept includes proton spin tomographic techniques. Chemical Shift Imaging,MR Tomography,MRI Scans,MRI, Functional,Magnetic Resonance Image,Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Functional,Magnetization Transfer Contrast Imaging,NMR Imaging,NMR Tomography,Tomography, NMR,Tomography, Proton Spin,fMRI,Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging,Imaging, Chemical Shift,Proton Spin Tomography,Spin Echo Imaging,Steady-State Free Precession MRI,Tomography, MR,Zeugmatography,Chemical Shift Imagings,Echo Imaging, Spin,Echo Imagings, Spin,Functional MRI,Functional MRIs,Image, Magnetic Resonance,Imaging, Magnetic Resonance,Imaging, NMR,Imaging, Spin Echo,Imagings, Chemical Shift,Imagings, Spin Echo,MRI Scan,MRIs, Functional,Magnetic Resonance Images,Resonance Image, Magnetic,Scan, MRI,Scans, MRI,Shift Imaging, Chemical,Shift Imagings, Chemical,Spin Echo Imagings,Steady State Free Precession MRI
D008297 Male Males
D008592 Menisci, Tibial The interarticular fibrocartilages of the superior surface of the tibia. Lateral Menisci,Medial Menisci,Menisci, Lateral,Menisci, Medial,Semilunar Cartilages,Tibial Menisci,Meniscus, Medial,Meniscus, Tibial,Tibial Meniscus,Cartilage, Semilunar,Cartilages, Semilunar,Lateral Meniscus,Medial Meniscus,Meniscus, Lateral,Semilunar Cartilage
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D010329 Patella The flat, triangular bone situated at the anterior part of the KNEE. Knee Cap,Kneecap,Knee Caps,Kneecaps,Patellas
D002357 Cartilage Diseases Pathological processes involving the chondral tissue (CARTILAGE). Chondromalacia,Cartilage Disease,Chondromalacias
D005188 False Negative Reactions Negative test results in subjects who possess the attribute for which the test is conducted. The labeling of diseased persons as healthy when screening in the detection of disease. (Last, A Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2d ed) False Negative Reaction,Reaction, False Negative,Reactions, False Negative
D005189 False Positive Reactions Positive test results in subjects who do not possess the attribute for which the test is conducted. The labeling of healthy persons as diseased when screening in the detection of disease. (Last, A Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2d ed) False Positive Reaction,Positive Reaction, False,Positive Reactions, False,Reaction, False Positive,Reactions, False Positive
D005260 Female Females
D005682 Gadolinium An element of the rare earth family of metals. It has the atomic symbol Gd, atomic number 64, and atomic weight 157.25. Its oxide is used in the control rods of some nuclear reactors.

Related Publications

L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1964, Rivista degli infortuni e delle malattie professionali,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
August 1961, Revue medicale de Liege,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1960, Journal de radiologie, d'electrologie, et de medecine nucleaire,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1980, L'Ateneo parmense. Acta bio-medica : organo della Societa di medicina e scienze naturali di Parma,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
September 1953, Concours medical,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1986, Rays,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 2015, Knee surgery, sports traumatology, arthroscopy : official journal of the ESSKA,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1959, Tip Fakultesi mecmuasi,
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
January 1954, Memoires. Academie de chirurgie (France),
L Mathieu, and A Bouchard, and J-P Marchaland, and J Potet, and B Fraboulet, and M Danguy-des-Deserts, and G Versier
June 1981, Radiologic clinics of North America,
Copied contents to your clipboard!