A biological evaluation of six gene set analysis methods for identification of differentially expressed pathways in microarray data. 2008

Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, 13-106 Clinical Sciences Building, Edmonton, AB, Canada.

Gene-set analysis of microarray data evaluates biological pathways, or gene sets, for their differential expression by a phenotype of interest. In contrast to the analysis of individual genes, gene-set analysis utilizes existing biological knowledge of genes and their pathways in assessing differential expression. This paper evaluates the biological performance of five gene-set analysis methods testing "self-contained null hypotheses" via subject sampling, along with the most popular gene-set analysis method, Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA). We use three real microarray analyses in which differentially expressed gene sets are predictable biologically from the phenotype. Two types of gene sets are considered for this empirical evaluation: one type contains "truly positive" sets that should be identified as differentially expressed; and the other type contains "truly negative" sets that should not be identified as differentially expressed. Our evaluation suggests advantages of SAM-GS, Global, and ANCOVA Global methods over GSEA and the other two methods.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
July 2006, BMC bioinformatics,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
February 2012, Statistical applications in genetics and molecular biology,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
September 2018, Experimental and therapeutic medicine,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
November 2002, Bioinformatics (Oxford, England),
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
January 2017, Studies in health technology and informatics,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
October 2009, Bioinformation,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
January 2014, Gene,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
January 2022, Neuroscience letters,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
July 2009, BMC proceedings,
Irina Dinu, and Qi Liu, and John D Potter, and Adeniyi J Adewale, and Gian S Jhangri, and Thomas Mueller, and Gunilla Einecke, and Konrad Famulsky, and Philip Halloran, and Yutaka Yasui
June 2007, The pharmacogenomics journal,
Copied contents to your clipboard!