Limitations of the various methods for collecting dietary intake data. 1991

S A Bingham
Medical Research Council, Dunn Clinical Nutrition Centre, Cambridge, UK.

The dietary intake of population groups may be assessed using food consumption level estimates on a national basis and household food surveys. These may be useful for monitoring secular trends and geographical differences with stable and well-documented populations, but analytical studies of diet and health require data on individuals. Assessment techniques designed to assess the diet of individuals ranging from records with weights of food to questionnaires and biological markers have been critically reviewed in order to assess the accuracy of each. Quantitative estimates of the errors involved will be given. For example, the co-efficients of variation of differences incurred from asking subjects to estimate the weight of food portions, rather than weighing them, may regularly be in the 50% range for foods and 20% for nutrients. A variety of studies suggests that the co-efficients of differences in nutrient intake estimated over 1 day from the 24-hour recall method when compared with observed intakes ranged from 4 to 400%. These errors are believed to be random, and precision can be improved by increasing the numbers of observations on each individual or by increasing the numbers of individuals within each group. However, a substantial loss of power is incurred with errors of this magnitude. A more serious potential source of error is systematic bias due either to differences between different methods of dietary assessment or from deliberate over- or underreporting by the subjects themselves. Studies with the doubly labelled water technique have suggested that substantial underrecording of food intake can occur both in free-living individuals and in athletes. 24-hour urine nitrogen can be used to validate dietary assessments in individuals in nitrogen balance, and on-going studies in Cambridge show that within a group, underreporting occurs in specific individuals rather than in the group as a whole. Independent methods of validating dietary assessments, such as the doubly labelled water technique or the 24-hour urine nitrogen output, must be included in any study of free-living individuals.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D012107 Research Design A plan for collecting and utilizing data so that desired information can be obtained with sufficient precision or so that an hypothesis can be tested properly. Experimental Design,Data Adjustment,Data Reporting,Design, Experimental,Designs, Experimental,Error Sources,Experimental Designs,Matched Groups,Methodology, Research,Problem Formulation,Research Methodology,Research Proposal,Research Strategy,Research Technics,Research Techniques,Scoring Methods,Adjustment, Data,Adjustments, Data,Data Adjustments,Design, Research,Designs, Research,Error Source,Formulation, Problem,Formulations, Problem,Group, Matched,Groups, Matched,Matched Group,Method, Scoring,Methods, Scoring,Problem Formulations,Proposal, Research,Proposals, Research,Reporting, Data,Research Designs,Research Proposals,Research Strategies,Research Technic,Research Technique,Scoring Method,Source, Error,Sources, Error,Strategies, Research,Strategy, Research,Technic, Research,Technics, Research,Technique, Research,Techniques, Research
D004034 Diet Surveys Systematic collections of factual data pertaining to the diet of a human population within a given geographic area. Diet Survey,Survey, Diet,Surveys, Diet
D005502 Food Substances taken in by the body to provide nourishment. Foods
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man

Related Publications

S A Bingham
January 1984, Progress in food & nutrition science,
S A Bingham
June 1948, Public health reports (Washington, D.C. : 1896),
S A Bingham
November 2012, Nutrition reviews,
S A Bingham
November 1982, Physiotherapy,
S A Bingham
April 1994, Indian pediatrics,
S A Bingham
October 1999, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP,
S A Bingham
October 2007, Journal of the American College of Nutrition,
Copied contents to your clipboard!