Comparative studies were made of the metabolism of plasma high density lipoprotein (HDL) and low density lipoprotein (LDL) by cultured normal human fibroblasts. On a molar basis, the surface binding of (125)I-HDL was only slightly less than that of (125)I-LDL, whereas the rates of internalization and degradation of (125)I-HDL were very low relative to those of (125)I-LDL. The relationships of internalization and degradation to binding suggested the presence of a saturable uptake mechanism for LDL functionally related to high-affinity binding. This was confirmed by the finding that the total uptake of (125)I-LDL (internalized plus degraded) at 5 micro g LDL protein/ml was 100-fold greater than that attributable to fluid or bulk pinocytosis, quantified with [(14)C]sucrose, and 10-fold greater than that attributable to the sum of fluid endocytosis and adsorptive endocytosis. In contrast, (125)I-HDL uptake could be almost completely accounted for by the uptake of medium during pinocytosis and by invagination of surface membrane (bearing bound lipoprotein) during pinocytosis. These findings imply that, at most, only a small fraction of bound HDL binds to the high-affinity LDL receptor and/or that HDL binding there is internalized very slowly. The rate of (125)I-HDL degradation by cultured fibroblasts (per unit cell mass) exceeded an estimate of the turnover rate of HDL in vivo, suggesting that peripheral tissues may contribute to HDL catabolism. In accordance with their differing rates of uptake and cholesterol content, LDL increased the cholesterol content of fibroblasts and selectively inhibited sterol biosynthesis, whereas HDL had neither effect.