[Analysis of discrepancies between clinical and autopsy diagnoses in 188 cases]. 2009

Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
Department of Pathology, Shanghai Jiaotong University School of Medicine, Shanghai 200025, China.

OBJECTIVE To analyze the discrepancies between clinical and autopsy diagnoses in hospitals of different grades and with respect to duration of hospitalization. METHODS A total of 188 autopsy cases collected from hospitals of different grades were retrospectively reviewed and the discrepancies between clinical and autopsy diagnoses were analyzed. RESULTS The overall rate of misdiagnosis was 48.9% (92/188). The misdiagnosis rate in grade I hospitals (75.8%, 25/33) was significantly higher than that in grade III (39.6%, 38/96; chi(2) = 12.861, P = 0.000) and grade II hospitals (49.2%, 29/59; chi(2) = 6.179, P = 0.016 ). The misdiagnosis rate of patients beyond 24 hours of admission was lower than that admitted within 24 hours (chi(2) = 20.991, P = 0.000). The overall rate of missed diagnosis was 34.6% (65/188). The rate of missed diagnosis in grade I hospitals was remarkably higher than that of the grade III hospitals (chi(2) = 8.241, P = 0.006). There was no difference between grades I and III hospitals on the rate of missed diagnosis within 24 hours of admission, however, this rate was lower in grade III hospitals in comparing with that of grade I hospitals in patients admitted beyond 24 hours (chi(2) = 5.181, P = 0.047). The distribution of disease entities commonly encountered in patients of both misdiagnosis and missed diagnosis were heart problems, infections, arterial diseases and pulmonary embolism. CONCLUSIONS The rate of discrepancies between clinical and autopsy diagnoses is relatively high. The misdiagnosis and missed diagnosis rate in grade I hospitals was significantly higher than that in grade III hospitals and was closely related with the duration of hospitalization. Autopsy study thus still remains an important measure in clinical audit.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007239 Infections Invasion of the host organism by microorganisms or their toxins or by parasites that can cause pathological conditions or diseases. Infection,Infection and Infestation,Infections and Infestations,Infestation and Infection,Infestations and Infections
D007902 Length of Stay The period of confinement of a patient to a hospital or other health facility. Hospital Stay,Hospital Stays,Stay Length,Stay Lengths,Stay, Hospital,Stays, Hospital
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D009203 Myocardial Infarction NECROSIS of the MYOCARDIUM caused by an obstruction of the blood supply to the heart (CORONARY CIRCULATION). Cardiovascular Stroke,Heart Attack,Myocardial Infarct,Cardiovascular Strokes,Heart Attacks,Infarct, Myocardial,Infarction, Myocardial,Infarctions, Myocardial,Infarcts, Myocardial,Myocardial Infarctions,Myocardial Infarcts,Stroke, Cardiovascular,Strokes, Cardiovascular
D009205 Myocarditis Inflammatory processes of the muscular walls of the heart (MYOCARDIUM) which result in injury to the cardiac muscle cells (MYOCYTES, CARDIAC). Manifestations range from subclinical to sudden death (DEATH, SUDDEN). Myocarditis in association with cardiac dysfunction is classified as inflammatory CARDIOMYOPATHY usually caused by INFECTION, autoimmune diseases, or responses to toxic substances. Myocarditis is also a common cause of DILATED CARDIOMYOPATHY and other cardiomyopathies. Carditis,Myocarditides
D011655 Pulmonary Embolism Blocking of the PULMONARY ARTERY or one of its branches by an EMBOLUS. Pulmonary Thromboembolism,Thromboembolism, Pulmonary,Embolism, Pulmonary,Embolisms, Pulmonary,Pulmonary Embolisms,Pulmonary Thromboembolisms,Thromboembolisms, Pulmonary
D002423 Cause of Death Factors which produce cessation of all vital bodily functions. They can be analyzed from an epidemiologic viewpoint. Causes of Death,Death Cause,Death Causes
D003951 Diagnostic Errors Incorrect or incomplete diagnoses following clinical or technical diagnostic procedures. Diagnostic Blind Spots,Errors, Diagnostic,Misdiagnosis,Blind Spot, Diagnostic,Blind Spots, Diagnostic,Diagnostic Blind Spot,Diagnostic Error,Error, Diagnostic,Misdiagnoses
D005260 Female Females

Related Publications

Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
January 2002, Chest,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
January 2011, Medicina,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
March 2003, Brazilian journal of medical and biological research = Revista brasileira de pesquisas medicas e biologicas,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
January 2010, Clinical transplantation,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
January 2008, American journal of clinical pathology,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
October 1979, Klinicheskaia meditsina,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
March 2012, Critical care medicine,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
December 2016, American journal of clinical pathology,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
November 2022, South African medical journal = Suid-Afrikaanse tydskrif vir geneeskunde,
Jun Cai, and Xu-Cheng Jiang, and Guo-Hui Fu, and Xin-Xu DU
January 2021, PloS one,
Copied contents to your clipboard!