[Prospective trial comparing shock wave lithotripsy and ureteroscopy for management of distal ureteral calculi]. 2009

Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
Servicio de Urología, Unidad de Litiasis, Hospital Clínico de la Universidad de Chile José Joaquín Aguirre, Santiago, Chile. fmarchantg@hotmail.com

OBJECTIVE To compare the efficacy of ureteroscopy and extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) in treating distal ureteral calculi and evaluate the best treatment alternative for this disease. METHODS A total of 104 patients with distal ureteral calculi requiring surgical intervention were enrolled and observed in a prospective follow-up. For ESWL, a Modulix SLX Storz lithotriptor was used and for ureteroscopy, a Storz 33 cm semi-rigid ureteroscope with a diameter of 7,5 to 9,5 french and a 6-degree optic. Out of the patient total, 54 patients underwent ESWL and 50 underwent ureteroscopy. 62 patients were men and 42 women; mean age in the ESWL group was 49.72, and in the ureteroscopy group, 52,16. Mean calculus size for ESWL was 8.29 mm and 8,96 mm for ureteroscopy. A P< .05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS Mean procedure time for ESWL was 55 minutes in men and 45 minutes in women. For ureteroscopy, procedure time was 80 minutes for men and 55 minutes for women. For ESWL, the mean hospital stay was 4.8 hours (same-day discharge for all patients). Mean hospital stay for ureteroscopy patients was 22 hours. 7% of ESWL patients experienced complications compared with 7.9% of those undergoing ureteroscopy. At the 30-day follow up, 74.3% of ESWL patients were stone free, while 92,3% of the ureteroscopy patients were stone free (P< .05). CONCLUSIONS Based on the results of this study, ureteroscopy is a better method for treating distal ureteral calculi because of its stone free rates and because the difference in complication rates was not significant.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008096 Lithotripsy The destruction of a calculus of the kidney, ureter, bladder, or gallbladder by physical forces, including crushing with a lithotriptor through a catheter. Focused percutaneous ultrasound and focused hydraulic shock waves may be used without surgery. Lithotripsy does not include the dissolving of stones by acids or litholysis. Lithotripsy by laser is LITHOTRIPSY, LASER. ESWL (Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsy),Electrohydraulic Shockwave Lithotripsy,Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsy,Litholapaxy,Noninvasive Litholapaxy,Percutaneous Ultrasonic Lithotripsy,Ultrasonic Lithotripsy,ESWLs (Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsy),Electrohydraulic Shockwave Lithotripsies,Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsies,Litholapaxies,Litholapaxies, Noninvasive,Litholapaxy, Noninvasive,Lithotripsies,Lithotripsies, Electrohydraulic Shockwave,Lithotripsies, Extracorporeal Shockwave,Lithotripsies, Percutaneous Ultrasonic,Lithotripsies, Ultrasonic,Lithotripsy, Electrohydraulic Shockwave,Lithotripsy, Extracorporeal Shockwave,Lithotripsy, Percutaneous Ultrasonic,Lithotripsy, Ultrasonic,Noninvasive Litholapaxies,Percutaneous Ultrasonic Lithotripsies,Shockwave Lithotripsies, Electrohydraulic,Shockwave Lithotripsies, Extracorporeal,Shockwave Lithotripsy, Electrohydraulic,Shockwave Lithotripsy, Extracorporeal,Ultrasonic Lithotripsies,Ultrasonic Lithotripsies, Percutaneous,Ultrasonic Lithotripsy, Percutaneous
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011446 Prospective Studies Observation of a population for a sufficient number of persons over a sufficient number of years to generate incidence or mortality rates subsequent to the selection of the study group. Prospective Study,Studies, Prospective,Study, Prospective
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D014514 Ureteral Calculi Stones in the URETER that are formed in the KIDNEY. They are rarely more than 5 mm in diameter for larger renal stones cannot enter ureters. They are often lodged at the ureteral narrowing and can cause excruciating renal colic. Ureteral Calculus,Calculi, Ureteral,Calculus, Ureteral
D018666 Ureteroscopy Endoscopic examination, therapy or surgery of the ureter. Surgical Procedures, Ureteroscopic,Ureteroscopic Surgical Procedures,Surgery, Ureteroscopic,Ureteroscopic Surgery,Procedure, Ureteroscopic Surgical,Procedures, Ureteroscopic Surgical,Surgeries, Ureteroscopic,Surgical Procedure, Ureteroscopic,Ureteroscopic Surgeries,Ureteroscopic Surgical Procedure,Ureteroscopies

Related Publications

Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
October 2001, The Journal of urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
June 2006, Urological research,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
January 2003, Reviews in urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
December 1999, The Journal of urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
December 2009, Urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
January 1988, European urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
June 2023, Urolithiasis,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
December 2013, World journal of urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
June 2005, The Journal of urology,
Fernando Marchant, and Oscar Storme, and Francisco Osorio, and Javiera Benavides, and Cristian Palma, and Enrique Ossandón
May 2008, The Journal of urology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!