Head and neck cancer patients with cervical disease involving the glossopharyngeal or vagus nerves can experience dangerous cardiovascular phenomena, including carotid sinus syncope (CSS). Medical and minimally invasive interventions, including pacemaker placement, incompletely address the etiologies of syncopal episodes and therefore often provide limited benefit. The objectives of this report are to highlight the difficulties of managing cancer-related CSS, to present a highly effective surgical intervention, and to review the literature regarding the pathophysiology and treatment options for patients with cancer-related CSS. Two patients with cancer-related CSS continued to experience syncopal episodes despite medical and pacemaker therapy. Consequently, these patients underwent a suboccipital craniotomy for glossopharyngeal and limited vagal neurectomy. After surgery, both patients had uncomplicated postoperative courses with resolution of syncope.