Cervico-thoracic or lumbar sympathectomy for neuropathic pain and complex regional pain syndrome. 2010

Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
Department of Occupational and Social Medicine, University of Göttingen, Waldweg 37 B, Göttingen, Germany, D-37073.

BACKGROUND This review is an update on 'Sympathectomy for neuropathic pain' originally published in Issue 2, 2003. The concept that many neuropathic pain syndromes (traditionally this definition would include complex regional pain syndromes (CRPS)) are "sympathetically maintained pains" has historically led to treatments that interrupt the sympathetic nervous system. Chemical sympathectomies use alcohol or phenol injections to destroy ganglia of the sympathetic chain, while surgical ablation is performed by open removal or electrocoagulation of the sympathetic chain, or minimally invasive procedures using thermal or laser interruption. OBJECTIVE To review the evidence from randomised, double blind, controlled trials on the efficacy and safety of chemical and surgical sympathectomy for neuropathic pain. Sympathectomy could be compared with placebo (sham) or other active treatment. METHODS We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE and The Cochrane Library to May 2010. We screened references in the retrieved articles and literature reviews, and contacted experts in the field of neuropathic pain. METHODS Randomised, double blind, placebo or active controlled studies assessing the effects of sympathectomy for neuropathic pain and CRPS. METHODS Two review authors independently assessed trial quality and validity, and extracted data. No pooled analysis of data was possible. RESULTS Only one study satisfied our inclusion criteria, comparing percutaneous radiofrequency thermal lumbar sympathectomy with lumbar sympathetic neurolysis using phenol in 20 participants with CRPS. There was no comparison of sympathectomy versus sham or placebo. No dichotomous pain outcomes were reported. Average baseline scores of 8-9/10 on several pain scales fell to about 4/10 initially (1 day) and remained at 3-5/10 over four months. There were no significant differences between groups, except for "unpleasant sensation", which was higher with radiofrequency ablation. One participant in the phenol group experienced postsympathectomy neuralgia, while two in the radiofrequency group and one in the phenol group complained of paresthaesia during needle positioning. All participants had soreness at the injection site. CONCLUSIONS The practice of surgical and chemical sympathectomy for neuropathic pain and CRPS is based on very little high quality evidence. Sympathectomy should be used cautiously in clinical practice, in carefully selected patients, and probably only after failure of other treatment options.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007866 Leg The inferior part of the lower extremity between the KNEE and the ANKLE. Legs
D009333 Neck The part of a human or animal body connecting the HEAD to the rest of the body. Necks
D009437 Neuralgia Intense or aching pain that occurs along the course or distribution of a peripheral or cranial nerve. Nerve Pain,Neurodynia,Paroxysmal Nerve Pain,Neuralgia, Atypical,Neuralgia, Iliohypogastric Nerve,Neuralgia, Ilioinguinal,Neuralgia, Perineal,Neuralgia, Stump,Neuralgia, Supraorbital,Neuralgia, Vidian,Neuropathic Pain,Atypical Neuralgia,Atypical Neuralgias,Iliohypogastric Nerve Neuralgia,Iliohypogastric Nerve Neuralgias,Ilioinguinal Neuralgia,Ilioinguinal Neuralgias,Nerve Neuralgia, Iliohypogastric,Nerve Neuralgias, Iliohypogastric,Nerve Pain, Paroxysmal,Nerve Pains,Nerve Pains, Paroxysmal,Neuralgias,Neuralgias, Atypical,Neuralgias, Iliohypogastric Nerve,Neuralgias, Ilioinguinal,Neuralgias, Perineal,Neuralgias, Stump,Neuralgias, Supraorbital,Neuralgias, Vidian,Neurodynias,Neuropathic Pains,Pain, Nerve,Pain, Neuropathic,Pain, Paroxysmal Nerve,Pains, Nerve,Pains, Neuropathic,Pains, Paroxysmal Nerve,Paroxysmal Nerve Pains,Perineal Neuralgia,Perineal Neuralgias,Stump Neuralgia,Stump Neuralgias,Supraorbital Neuralgia,Supraorbital Neuralgias,Vidian Neuralgia,Vidian Neuralgias
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D013562 Sympathectomy The removal or interruption of some part of the sympathetic nervous system for therapeutic or research purposes. Denervation, Sympathetic,Sympathetic Denervation,Denervations, Sympathetic,Sympathectomies,Sympathetic Denervations
D013563 Sympathectomy, Chemical Sympathectomy using chemicals (e.g., 6-hydroxydopamine or guanethidine) which selectively and reversibly destroy adrenergic nerve endings while leaving cholinergic nerve endings intact. Chemosympathectomy,Denervation, Sympathetic, Chemical,Chemical Sympathectomy,Chemical Sympathetic Denervation,Sympathetic Denervation, Chemical,Chemical Sympathectomies,Chemical Sympathetic Denervations,Chemosympathectomies,Denervation, Chemical Sympathetic,Denervations, Chemical Sympathetic,Sympathectomies, Chemical,Sympathetic Denervations, Chemical
D013565 Sympatholytics Drugs that inhibit the actions of the sympathetic nervous system by any mechanism. The most common of these are the ADRENERGIC ANTAGONISTS and drugs that deplete norepinephrine or reduce the release of transmitters from adrenergic postganglionic terminals (see ADRENERGIC AGENTS). Drugs that act in the central nervous system to reduce sympathetic activity (e.g., centrally acting alpha-2 adrenergic agonists, see ADRENERGIC ALPHA-AGONISTS) are included here. Sympathetic-Blocking Agents,Sympatholytic,Sympatholytic Agent,Sympatholytic Drug,Sympatholytic Agents,Sympatholytic Drugs,Sympatholytic Effect,Sympatholytic Effects,Agent, Sympatholytic,Agents, Sympathetic-Blocking,Agents, Sympatholytic,Drug, Sympatholytic,Drugs, Sympatholytic,Effect, Sympatholytic,Effects, Sympatholytic,Sympathetic Blocking Agents
D013909 Thorax The upper part of the trunk between the NECK and the ABDOMEN. It contains the chief organs of the circulatory and respiratory systems. (From Stedman, 25th ed) Chest,Thoraces,Chests,Thorace
D016032 Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic Works about clinical trials that involve at least one test treatment and one control treatment, concurrent enrollment and follow-up of the test- and control-treated groups, and in which the treatments to be administered are selected by a random process, such as the use of a random-numbers table. Clinical Trials, Randomized,Controlled Clinical Trials, Randomized,Trials, Randomized Clinical
D017115 Catheter Ablation Removal of tissue with electrical current delivered via electrodes positioned at the distal end of a catheter. Energy sources are commonly direct current (DC-shock) or alternating current at radiofrequencies (usually 750 kHz). The technique is used most often to ablate the AV junction and/or accessory pathways in order to interrupt AV conduction and produce AV block in the treatment of various tachyarrhythmias. Ablation, Transvenous Electric,Catheter Ablation, Electric,Catheter Ablation, Percutaneous,Catheter Ablation, Radiofrequency,Catheter Ablation, Transvenous,Ablation, Catheter,Ablation, Transvenous Electrical,Catheter Ablation, Electrical,Electric Catheter Ablation,Electrical Catheter Ablation,Percutaneous Catheter Ablation,Radiofrequency Catheter Ablation,Transvenous Catheter Ablation,Ablation, Electric Catheter,Ablation, Electrical Catheter,Ablation, Percutaneous Catheter,Ablation, Radiofrequency Catheter,Ablation, Transvenous Catheter,Electric Ablation, Transvenous,Electrical Ablation, Transvenous,Transvenous Electric Ablation,Transvenous Electrical Ablation

Related Publications

Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
December 2011, European journal of trauma and emergency surgery : official publication of the European Trauma Society,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
March 2003, Journal of vascular surgery,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
September 2012, Journal of the Indian Medical Association,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
June 2010, Current pain and headache reports,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
November 1969, Prensa medica argentina,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
September 2002, Pain practice : the official journal of World Institute of Pain,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
January 2003, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
June 2004, British journal of sports medicine,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
July 2005, Pain physician,
Sebastian Straube, and Sheena Derry, and R Andrew Moore, and Henry J McQuay
August 2009, Schmerz (Berlin, Germany),
Copied contents to your clipboard!