Speed cameras for the prevention of road traffic injuries and deaths. 2010

Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
Centre of National Research on Disability and Rehabilitation Medicine, Mayne Medical School, The University of Queensland, Herston Road, Herston, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia, 4006.

BACKGROUND It is estimated that by 2020, road traffic crashes will have moved from ninth to third in the world ranking of burden of disease, as measured in disability adjusted life years. The prevention of road traffic injuries is of global public health importance. Measures aimed at reducing traffic speed are considered essential to preventing road injuries; the use of speed cameras is one such measure. OBJECTIVE To assess whether the use of speed cameras reduces the incidence of speeding, road traffic crashes, injuries and deaths. METHODS We searched the following electronic databases covering all available years up to March 2010; the Cochrane Library, MEDLINE (WebSPIRS), EMBASE (WebSPIRS), TRANSPORT, IRRD (International Road Research Documentation), TRANSDOC (European Conference of Ministers of Transport databases), Web of Science (Science and Social Science Citation Index), PsycINFO, CINAHL, EconLit, WHO database, Sociological Abstracts, Dissertation Abstracts, Index to Theses. METHODS Randomised controlled trials, interrupted time series and controlled before-after studies that assessed the impact of speed cameras on speeding, road crashes, crashes causing injury and fatalities were eligible for inclusion. METHODS We independently screened studies for inclusion, extracted data, assessed methodological quality, reported study authors' outcomes and where possible, calculated standardised results based on the information available in each study. Due to considerable heterogeneity between and within included studies, a meta-analysis was not appropriate. RESULTS Thirty five studies met the inclusion criteria. Compared with controls, the relative reduction in average speed ranged from 1% to 15% and the reduction in proportion of vehicles speeding ranged from 14% to 65%. In the vicinity of camera sites, the pre/post reductions ranged from 8% to 49% for all crashes and 11% to 44% for fatal and serious injury crashes. Compared with controls, the relative improvement in pre/post injury crash proportions ranged from 8% to 50%. CONCLUSIONS Despite the methodological limitations and the variability in degree of signal to noise effect, the consistency of reported reductions in speed and crash outcomes across all studies show that speed cameras are a worthwhile intervention for reducing the number of road traffic injuries and deaths. However, whilst the the evidence base clearly demonstrates a positive direction in the effect, an overall magnitude of this effect is currently not deducible due to heterogeneity and lack of methodological rigour. More studies of a scientifically rigorous and homogenous nature are necessary, to provide the answer to the magnitude of effect.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010781 Photography Method of making images on a sensitized surface by exposure to light or other radiant energy. Photographies
D011825 Radar A system using beamed and reflected radio signals to and from an object in such a way that range, bearing, and other characteristics of the object may be determined.
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000056 Accident Prevention Efforts and designs to reduce the incidence of unexpected undesirable events in various environments and situations. Prevention, Accident,Accident Preventions,Preventions, Accident
D000063 Accidents, Traffic Accidents on streets, roads, and highways involving drivers, passengers, pedestrians, or vehicles. Traffic accidents refer to AUTOMOBILES (passenger cars, buses, and trucks), BICYCLING, and MOTORCYCLES but not OFF-ROAD MOTOR VEHICLES; RAILROADS nor snowmobiles. Traffic Collisions,Traffic Crashes,Traffic Accidents,Accident, Traffic,Collision, Traffic,Collisions, Traffic,Crashes, Traffic,Traffic Accident,Traffic Collision
D012449 Safety Freedom from exposure to danger and protection from the occurrence or risk of injury or loss. It suggests optimal precautions in the workplace, on the street, in the home, etc., and includes personal safety as well as the safety of property. Safeties
D018849 Controlled Clinical Trials as Topic Works about clinical trials involving one or more test treatments, at least one control treatment, specified outcome measures for evaluating the studied intervention, and a bias-free method for assigning patients to the test treatment. The treatment may be drugs, devices, or procedures studied for diagnostic, therapeutic, or prophylactic effectiveness. Control measures include placebos, active medicines, no-treatment, dosage forms and regimens, historical comparisons, etc. When randomization using mathematical techniques, such as the use of a random numbers table, is employed to assign patients to test or control treatments, the trials are characterized as RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC. Clinical Trials, Controlled as Topic

Related Publications

Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
September 2007, American journal of public health,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
January 2019, PloS one,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
December 2009, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
April 2005, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
January 1998, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
February 1994, Accident; analysis and prevention,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
August 2022, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
January 2004, The National medical journal of India,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
February 2007, European journal of public health,
Cecilia Wilson, and Charlene Willis, and Joan K Hendrikz, and Robyne Le Brocque, and Nicholas Bellamy
May 2002, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
Copied contents to your clipboard!