Family medicine graduates' perceptions of intimidation, harassment, and discrimination during residency training. 2011

Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
Department of Family Medicine, University of Calgary, NW, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. crutcher@ucalgary.ca

BACKGROUND Despite there being considerable literature documenting learner distress and perceptions of mistreatment in medical education settings, these concerns have not been explored in-depth in Canadian family medicine residency programs. The purpose of the study was to examine intimidation, harassment and/or discrimination (IHD) as reported by Alberta family medicine graduates during their two-year residency program. METHODS A retrospective questionnaire survey was conducted of all (n = 377) family medicine graduates from the University of Alberta and University of Calgary who completed residency training during 2001-2005. The frequency, type, source, and perceived basis of IHD were examined by gender, age, and Canadian vs international medical graduate. Descriptive data analysis (frequency, crosstabs), Chi-square, Fisher's Exact test, analysis of variance, and logistic regression were used as appropriate. RESULTS Of 377 graduates, 242 (64.2%) responded to the survey, with 44.7% reporting they had experienced IHD while a resident. The most frequent type of IHD experienced was in the form of inappropriate verbal comments (94.3%), followed by work as punishment (27.6%). The main sources of IHD were specialist physicians (77.1%), hospital nurses (54.3%), specialty residents (45.7%), and patients (35.2%). The primary basis for IHD was perceived to be gender (26.7%), followed by ethnicity (16.2%), and culture (9.5%). A significantly greater proportion of males (38.6%) than females (20.0%) experienced IHD in the form of work as punishment. While a similar proportion of Canadian (46.1%) and international medical graduates (IMGs) (41.0%) experienced IHD, a significantly greater proportion of IMGs perceived ethnicity, culture, or language to be the basis of IHD. CONCLUSIONS Perceptions of IHD are prevalent among family medicine graduates. Residency programs should explicitly recognize and robustly address all IHD concerns.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007396 Internship and Residency Programs of EDUCATION, MEDICAL, GRADUATE training to meet the requirements established by accrediting authorities. House Staff,Internship, Dental,Residency, Dental,Residency, Medical,Dental Internship,Dental Internships,Dental Residencies,Dental Residency,Internship,Internship, Medical,Internships, Dental,Medical Residencies,Medical Residency,Residencies, Dental,Residencies, Medical,Residency,Residency and Internship,Internships, Medical,Medical Internship,Medical Internships,Residencies,Staff, House
D008297 Male Males
D010865 Pilot Projects Small-scale tests of methods and procedures to be used on a larger scale if the pilot study demonstrates that these methods and procedures can work. Pilot Studies,Pilot Study,Pilot Project,Project, Pilot,Projects, Pilot,Studies, Pilot,Study, Pilot
D011287 Prejudice A preconceived judgment made without factual basis. Anti-Semitism,Islamophobia,Anti Semitism,Anti-Semitisms,Islamophobias,Prejudices
D011795 Surveys and Questionnaires Collections of data obtained from voluntary subjects. The information usually takes the form of answers to questions, or suggestions. Community Survey,Nonrespondent,Questionnaire,Questionnaires,Respondent,Survey,Survey Method,Survey Methods,Surveys,Baseline Survey,Community Surveys,Methodology, Survey,Nonrespondents,Questionnaire Design,Randomized Response Technique,Repeated Rounds of Survey,Respondents,Survey Methodology,Baseline Surveys,Design, Questionnaire,Designs, Questionnaire,Methods, Survey,Questionnaire Designs,Questionnaires and Surveys,Randomized Response Techniques,Response Technique, Randomized,Response Techniques, Randomized,Survey, Baseline,Survey, Community,Surveys, Baseline,Surveys, Community,Techniques, Randomized Response
D003625 Data Collection Systematic gathering of data for a particular purpose from various sources, including questionnaires, interviews, observation, existing records, and electronic devices. The process is usually preliminary to statistical analysis of the data. Data Collection Methods,Dual Data Collection,Collection Method, Data,Collection Methods, Data,Collection, Data,Collection, Dual Data,Data Collection Method,Method, Data Collection,Methods, Data Collection
D004503 Education, Medical, Graduate Educational programs for medical graduates entering a specialty. They include formal specialty training as well as academic work in the clinical and basic medical sciences, and may lead to board certification or an advanced medical degree. Medical Education, Graduate,Education, Graduate Medical,Graduate Medical Education
D005194 Family Practice A medical specialty concerned with the provision of continuing, comprehensive primary health care for the entire family. Family Practices,Practice, Family,Practices, Family
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man

Related Publications

Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
March 2021, BMC medical education,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
January 2020, Journal of allied health,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
June 1996, CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l'Association medicale canadienne,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
March 2013, Journal of graduate medical education,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
June 1989, Annals of emergency medicine,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
August 2021, JAMA network open,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
October 2019, The New England journal of medicine,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
July 2022, World journal of surgery,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
July 2022, World journal of surgery,
Rodney A Crutcher, and Olga Szafran, and Wayne Woloschuk, and Fatima Chatur, and Chantal Hansen
May 2020, The Journal of urology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!