Monitoring quality indicators in laboratory medicine does not automatically result in quality improvement. 2011

Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
Department of Laboratory Medicine, University-Hospital, Padua, Italy.

BACKGROUND Data on quality indicators (QIs) should be collected over time in order to identify and continuously monitor clinical laboratory performance and to improve patient safety by identifying and implementing effective interventions. The aim of the present study was to ascertain whether the utilization of a set of quality indicators over a 3-year period resulted in an improvement in the efficiency and effectiveness of an individual laboratory. METHODS Over a 3-year time interval (2009-2011), a series of 38 QIs covering all stages of the total testing process (21 in the pre-analytic, nine in the analytic and eight in the post-analytic phase) was monitored. RESULTS On the basis of their patterns, QIs have been grouped into the following categories: [1] seven QIs of the pre-analytical phase and three of the intra-analytical phase with a significant trend and a significant linearity demonstrating an improvement over time; [2] 10 QIs of the pre-analytical and two of the intra-analytical phase with a significant trend and a non-significant linearity demonstrating that changes were not constant; [3] two QIs of the pre-analytical and one of the intra-analytical phase with a non-significant trend and significant linearity showing neither improvement nor worsening; and [4] two QIs of the pre-analytical and three of the intra-analytical phase with a non-significant trend and non-significant linearity. CONCLUSIONS Data on a set of QIs collected over a 3-year time-frame demonstrate that processes and indicators under the control of the clinical laboratory had improved much more than processes requiring close co-operation between the laboratory and care teams.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D013997 Time Factors Elements of limited time intervals, contributing to particular results or situations. Time Series,Factor, Time,Time Factor
D058996 Quality Improvement The attainment or process of attaining a new level of performance or quality. Improvement, Quality,Improvements, Quality,Quality Improvements
D019411 Clinical Laboratory Techniques Techniques used to carry out clinical investigative procedures in the diagnosis and therapy of disease. Clinical Laboratory Test,Clinical Laboratory Testing,Clinical Laboratory Diagnoses,Clinical Laboratory Testings,Clinical Laboratory Tests,Diagnoses and Laboratory Examinations,Diagnosis, Laboratory,Laboratory Diagnosis,Laboratory Examinations and Diagnoses,Laboratory Techniques, Clinical,Clinical Laboratory Technique,Diagnose, Clinical Laboratory,Laboratory Diagnoses,Laboratory Technique, Clinical,Laboratory Test, Clinical,Laboratory Testing, Clinical,Technique, Clinical Laboratory,Test, Clinical Laboratory,Testing, Clinical Laboratory
D019984 Quality Indicators, Health Care Norms, criteria, standards, and other direct qualitative and quantitative measures used in determining the quality of health care. Global Trigger Tool, Healthcare,Health Metrics,Healthcare Global Trigger Tool,Quality Indicators, Healthcare,Health Metric,Healthcare Quality Indicator,Healthcare Quality Indicators,Indicator, Healthcare Quality,Indicators, Healthcare Quality,Metrics, Health,Quality Indicator, Healthcare

Related Publications

Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
January 2012, Annals of clinical biochemistry,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
May 2012, Annals of clinical biochemistry,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
December 2003, Reproductive biomedicine online,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
January 2013, Clinical chemistry and laboratory medicine,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
February 2007, Primary care diabetes,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
January 2006, Clinical laboratory,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
January 2002, The Southeast Asian journal of tropical medicine and public health,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
June 2008, Clinics in laboratory medicine,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
July 2011, Clinica chimica acta; international journal of clinical chemistry,
Laura Sciacovelli, and Oswald Sonntag, and Andrea Padoan, and Carlo Federico Zambon, and Paolo Carraro, and Mario Plebani
January 2024, Journal of cytology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!