Quality assessment of clinical practice guidelines for the prescription of antidepressant drugs during pregnancy. 2012

Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
Research Centre CHU Sainte- Justine, Montreal, Canada.

Antidepressant use during the gestational period remains a controversial issue. The objective of this study was to appraise the quality of the available clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) that includes recommendations for antidepressant use during pregnancy. We systematically searched for documents published between January 2000 and September 2010 in MEDLINE / TRIP database and on clearing houses and main scientific societies' websites. Four appraisers evaluated each guideline using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation tool (AGREE II). Intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated as an overall indicator of agreement. Twelve CPGs were included from a total of 539 references. Only two guidelines were specifically addressed to pregnant women. The overall agreement among reviewers was high (ICC: 0.94, 95% CI: 0.86-0.98). The mean scores and standard deviation (SD) for each of the AGREE II domains were: scope and purpose: 84.4% (12); stakeholder involvement: 67.4% (29.8); rigor of development: 68.6% (19.8); clarity and presentation: 83.4% (17.4); applicability: 44% (37.3); and editorial independence: 62.1% (30.4). After standardizing the scores of the 12 guidelines, 5 were considered as being "recommended", 5 as "recommended with modifications, and 2 as "not recommended". Among the five recommended guidelines, two were specifically conceived to the gestational period. CPGs containing recommendations for antidepressant use during pregnancy were of moderate to high quality. Future guidelines should take into account the observed drawbacks in some domains, and specifically focus a more in depth approach of depression during pregnancy.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D011247 Pregnancy The status during which female mammals carry their developing young (EMBRYOS or FETUSES) in utero before birth, beginning from FERTILIZATION to BIRTH. Gestation,Pregnancies
D011248 Pregnancy Complications Conditions or pathological processes associated with pregnancy. They can occur during or after pregnancy, and range from minor discomforts to serious diseases that require medical interventions. They include diseases in pregnant females, and pregnancies in females with diseases. Adverse Birth Outcomes,Complications, Pregnancy,Adverse Birth Outcome,Birth Outcome, Adverse,Complication, Pregnancy,Outcome, Adverse Birth,Pregnancy Complication
D003863 Depression Depressive states usually of moderate intensity in contrast with MAJOR DEPRESSIVE DISORDER present in neurotic and psychotic disorders. Depressive Symptoms,Emotional Depression,Depression, Emotional,Depressive Symptom,Symptom, Depressive
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000928 Antidepressive Agents Mood-stimulating drugs used primarily in the treatment of affective disorders and related conditions. Several MONOAMINE OXIDASE INHIBITORS are useful as antidepressants apparently as a long-term consequence of their modulation of catecholamine levels. The tricyclic compounds useful as antidepressive agents (ANTIDEPRESSIVE AGENTS, TRICYCLIC) also appear to act through brain catecholamine systems. A third group (ANTIDEPRESSIVE AGENTS, SECOND-GENERATION) is a diverse group of drugs including some that act specifically on serotonergic systems. Antidepressant,Antidepressant Drug,Antidepressant Medication,Antidepressants,Antidepressive Agent,Thymoanaleptic,Thymoanaleptics,Thymoleptic,Thymoleptics,Antidepressant Drugs,Agent, Antidepressive,Drug, Antidepressant,Medication, Antidepressant
D017410 Practice Guidelines as Topic Works about directions or principles presenting current or future rules of policy for assisting health care practitioners in patient care decisions regarding diagnosis, therapy, or related clinical circumstances. The guidelines may be developed by government agencies at any level, institutions, professional societies, governing boards, or by the convening of expert panels. The guidelines form a basis for the evaluation of all aspects of health care and delivery. Clinical Guidelines as Topic,Best Practices,Best Practice

Related Publications

Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
February 2006, Expert review of pharmacoeconomics & outcomes research,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
January 2015, Revista da Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
November 2018, Cancer treatment reviews,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
January 2022, Frontiers in oncology,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
July 2007, Expert opinion on drug safety,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
January 2004, Drug safety,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
February 2013, Clinical endocrinology,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
November 2000, International clinical psychopharmacology,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
May 2018, Journal of evidence-based medicine,
Fabiano Santos, and Ivan Sola, and David Rigau, and Ingrid Arevalo-Rodriguez, and Pamela Seron, and Pablo Alonso-Coello, and Anick Berard, and Xavier Bonfill
September 2022, Integrative medicine research,
Copied contents to your clipboard!