Withdrawal of care: a 10-year perspective at a Level I trauma center. 2012

Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
Trauma Service, Scripps Mercy Hospital, San Diego, California 92103, USA. sise.mike@scrippshealth.org

BACKGROUND Withdrawal or limitation of care (WLC) in trauma patients has not been well studied. We reviewed 10 years of deaths at our adult Level I trauma center to identify the patients undergoing WLC and to describe the process of trauma surgeon-managed WLC. METHODS This is a retrospective review of WLC. Each patient was assigned to one of three modes of WLC: care withdrawn, limited or no resuscitation, or organ harvest. Frequency, timing, and circumstances of WLC, including family involvement, ethics committee consultation, palliative care, and hospice, were reviewed. RESULTS From 2000 through 2009, 375 patients died with WLC (54% of all deaths; 93% at ≥ 24 hours). For age ≥ 65 years, 80% were WLC. Overall, 15% had advance directive documents. Traumatic brain or high cervical spine injury was the cause of death in 63%. Factors associated with WLC included age, comorbidities, injury mechanism and severity, and nontrauma activation status. At time of death, 316 (84%) WLC were under trauma surgeon management. In this group, mode of WLC was care withdrawn in 74%, organ harvest in 20%, and limited or no resuscitation in 6%. Rationale for WLC in non-organ harvest patients was poor neurologic prognosis in 86% and futility in 76%. When family was identified, end-of-life discussions with physicians occurred in 100%. Conflicts over WLC occurred in 6.6% and were not associated with any demographic group. Ethics committee was involved in 2.8%. For care-withdrawn patients, median time to death from first WLC order was 6.6 hours. Palliative care and hospice consults (6% and 9%) increased yearly. CONCLUSIONS WLC occurred in over 50% of all trauma deaths and exceeded 90% at ≥ 24 hours. Hospice and palliative care were increasingly important adjuncts to WLC. Guidelines for WLC should be developed to ensure quality end-of-life care for trauma patients in whom further care is futile. METHODS III, therapeutic study.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D002140 California State bounded on the east by Nevada and Arizona, on the south by Mexico and the Pacific Ocean on the south and west, and on the north by Oregon.
D004992 Ethics, Medical The principles of professional conduct concerning the rights and duties of the physician, relations with patients and fellow practitioners, as well as actions of the physician in patient care and interpersonal relations with patient families. Medical Ethics
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D012189 Retrospective Studies Studies used to test etiologic hypotheses in which inferences about an exposure to putative causal factors are derived from data relating to characteristics of persons under study or to events or experiences in their past. The essential feature is that some of the persons under study have the disease or outcome of interest and their characteristics are compared with those of unaffected persons. Retrospective Study,Studies, Retrospective,Study, Retrospective
D013997 Time Factors Elements of limited time intervals, contributing to particular results or situations. Time Series,Factor, Time,Time Factor
D014193 Trauma Centers Specialized hospital facilities which provide diagnostic and therapeutic services for trauma patients. Trauma Units,Center, Trauma,Centers, Trauma,Trauma Center,Trauma Unit,Unit, Trauma,Units, Trauma

Related Publications

Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
April 2016, Journal of pediatric surgery,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
October 2016, The journal of trauma and acute care surgery,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
April 2012, Annals of plastic surgery,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
August 2015, Journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery : official journal of the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
June 2005, Journal of the American College of Surgeons,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
March 2018, The American surgeon,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
January 2006, Journal of agromedicine,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
September 1997, The American surgeon,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
November 2020, Radiology,
Michael J Sise, and C Beth Sise, and Jonathan F Thorndike, and Jessica E Kahl, and Richard Y Calvo, and Steven R Shackford
June 2017, American journal of surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!