Publication misrepresentation among urology residency applicants. 2013

Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
Department of Urology, University of Washington School of Medicine, 1959 NE Pacific Street, Box 356510, Seattle, WA 98195, USA. rshsi@uw.edu

OBJECTIVE To assess the extent and types of publication misrepresentation among medical students applying to the urology residency program at the University of Washington. Research experience and publications are the selection criteria used to judge and rank urology residency applicants. METHODS Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) applications submitted for the incoming class of 2011 for urology residency at the University of Washington were reviewed. All listed publications were verified against PubMed and Google search engines. Misrepresentation was defined as non-authorship of an existing article, authorship claimed of a nonexistent article, or first-authorship listed incorrectly. RESULTS Of the 198 total applications, 124 (63 %) applicants reported 541 publications, including 112 abstracts and 429 journal articles. 347 (65 %) articles and abstracts were verifiable. Misrepresentation of 12 (3.5 %) published articles was found in 9 applicants (7 %), which included self-promotion to first-authorship (6), followed by non-existent articles (5), and a repeated publication listing (1). On univariate analysis, higher age (p = 0.008), higher number of total publications reported (p < 0.001), additional graduate degree (p < 0.001), and foreign medical graduate (FMG) status (p < 0.001) were associated with misrepresentation. Due to the low incidence, the study was not adequately powered to perform a multivariate analysis. CONCLUSIONS Misrepresentation of publications listed in ERAS among urology applicants remains significant. Residency program directors should require applicants to submit copies of all of their publications, whether in print, in-press, or submitted to be placed as part of their application file.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007396 Internship and Residency Programs of EDUCATION, MEDICAL, GRADUATE training to meet the requirements established by accrediting authorities. House Staff,Internship, Dental,Residency, Dental,Residency, Medical,Dental Internship,Dental Internships,Dental Residencies,Dental Residency,Internship,Internship, Medical,Internships, Dental,Medical Residencies,Medical Residency,Residencies, Dental,Residencies, Medical,Residency,Residency and Internship,Internships, Medical,Medical Internship,Medical Internships,Residencies,Staff, House
D007586 Job Application Process of applying for employment. It includes written application for employment or personal appearance. Employment Application,Resume, Job,Application, Employment,Application, Job,Applications, Employment,Applications, Job,Employment Applications,Job Applications,Job Resume,Job Resumes,Resumes, Job
D011642 Publications Copies of a work or document distributed to the public by sale, rental, lease, or lending. (From ALA Glossary of Library and Information Science, 1983, p181) Publication
D004995 Ethics, Professional The principles of proper conduct concerning the rights and duties of the professional, relations with patients or consumers and fellow practitioners, as well as actions of the professional and interpersonal relations with patient or consumer families. (From Stedman, 25th ed) Professional Ethics,Ethic, Professional,Professional Ethic
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D001319 Authorship The profession of writing. Also the identity of the writer as the creator of a literary production. Authorships
D012189 Retrospective Studies Studies used to test etiologic hypotheses in which inferences about an exposure to putative causal factors are derived from data relating to characteristics of persons under study or to events or experiences in their past. The essential feature is that some of the persons under study have the disease or outcome of interest and their characteristics are compared with those of unaffected persons. Retrospective Study,Studies, Retrospective,Study, Retrospective
D014572 Urology A surgical specialty concerned with the study, diagnosis, and treatment of diseases of the urinary tract in both sexes, and the genital tract in the male. Common urological problems include urinary obstruction, URINARY INCONTINENCE, infections, and UROGENITAL NEOPLASMS.
D014861 Washington State bounded by on the north by Canada, on the east by Idaho, on the south by Oregon, and on the west by the Pacific Ocean.

Related Publications

Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
March 2011, Anesthesia and analgesia,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
December 2010, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
August 2019, American journal of surgery,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
December 2017, Journal of graduate medical education,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
January 2016, Journal of neurosurgery,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
January 2017, Urology,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
August 2022, Pediatric neurology,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
January 2016, Journal of neurosurgery,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
June 2015, Medical education,
Ryan S Hsi, and James M Hotaling, and Tarah N Moore, and Byron D Joyner
June 2011, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!