Financial, nonfinancial and editors' conflicts of interest in high-impact biomedical journals. 2013

Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
Department of Internal Medicine, Institut d'Investigacions Biomèdiques August Pi i Sunyer (IDIBAPS), Hospital Clínic, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain. xavbosch@clinic.ub.es

OBJECTIVE To assess financial, nonfinancial and editors' conflicts of interest (COI) disclosure policies among the most influential biomedical journals publishing original research. METHODS We conducted a cross-sectional study of 399 high-impact biomedical journals in 27 biomedical categories of the Journal Citation Reports (JCR) in December 2011. Information relevant to COI and requirements for disclosures that was publicly available on journal websites was collected. RESULTS While financial COI disclosures were required by 358 (89.7%) and nonfinancial by 280 (70.2%) journals, 155 (38.8%) required editors' disclosures. Journals in the first decile of the JCR classification scored significantly higher than those in the second decile for all disclosure policies. Ninety (22.6%) journals were published by Elsevier and 59 (14.8%) by Wiley-Blackwell, with Elsevier scoring significantly better in financial disclosure policies (P = 0.022). Clinical journals scored significantly higher than basic journals for all disclosure policies. No differences were observed between open-access (n = 25) and nonopen-access (n = 374) journals for any type of disclosure. Somewhat incoherently, authors' disclosure statements were included in some published manuscript in 57.1% of journals without any COI disclosure policies. CONCLUSIONS Authors' financial COI disclosures were required by about 90% of high-impact clinical and basic journals publishing original research. Unlike recent studies showing a significantly lower prevalence of nonfinancial compared with financial disclosures, the former were required by about 70% of journals, suggesting that editors are increasingly concerned about nonfinancial competing interests. Only 40% of journals required disclosure of editors' COI, in conflict with the recommendations of the most influential editors' associations.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D003430 Cross-Sectional Studies Studies in which the presence or absence of disease or other health-related variables are determined in each member of the study population or in a representative sample at one particular time. This contrasts with LONGITUDINAL STUDIES which are followed over a period of time. Disease Frequency Surveys,Prevalence Studies,Analysis, Cross-Sectional,Cross Sectional Analysis,Cross-Sectional Survey,Surveys, Disease Frequency,Analyses, Cross Sectional,Analyses, Cross-Sectional,Analysis, Cross Sectional,Cross Sectional Analyses,Cross Sectional Studies,Cross Sectional Survey,Cross-Sectional Analyses,Cross-Sectional Analysis,Cross-Sectional Study,Cross-Sectional Surveys,Disease Frequency Survey,Prevalence Study,Studies, Cross-Sectional,Studies, Prevalence,Study, Cross-Sectional,Study, Prevalence,Survey, Cross-Sectional,Survey, Disease Frequency,Surveys, Cross-Sectional
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012693 Serial Publications Publications in any medium issued in successive parts bearing numerical or chronological designations and intended to be continued indefinitely. (ALA Glossary of Library and Information Science, 1983, p203) Publication, Serial,Publications, Serial,Serial Publication
D016265 Conflict of Interest A situation in which an individual might benefit personally from official or professional actions. It includes a conflict between a person's private interests and official responsibilities in a position of trust. The term is not restricted to government officials. The concept refers both to actual conflict of interest and the appearance or perception of conflict. Interest Conflict,Interest Conflicts
D055811 Journal Impact Factor A quantitative measure of the frequency on average with which articles in a journal have been cited in a given period of time. Factor, Journal Impact,Factors, Journal Impact,Impact Factor, Journal,Impact Factors, Journal,Journal Impact Factors
D018156 Journalism, Medical The collection, writing, and editing of current interest material on topics related to biomedicine for presentation through the mass media, including newspapers, magazines, radio, or television, usually for a public audience such as health care consumers. Medical Journalism
D030881 Disclosure Revealing of information, by oral or written communication. Financial Disclosure,Information Disclosure,Disclosure, Financial,Disclosure, Information,Disclosures, Financial,Financial Disclosures
D035081 Editorial Policies The guidelines and policy statements set forth by the editor(s) or editorial board of a publication. Editorial Policy,Policies, Editorial,Policy, Editorial
D035843 Biomedical Research Research that involves the application of the natural sciences, especially biology and physiology, to medicine. Medical Research,Experimental Medicine,Investigational Medicine,Investigative Medicine,Research, Biomedical,Research, Medical,Medicine, Experimental,Medicine, Investigational,Medicine, Investigative

Related Publications

Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
September 2017, Blood cancer journal,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
January 2010, American journal of therapeutics,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
January 2016, The Journal of foot and ankle surgery : official publication of the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
February 2018, Archivos argentinos de pediatria,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
June 2018, Emergencias : revista de la Sociedad Espanola de Medicina de Emergencias,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
January 2018, PloS one,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
July 2003, The virtual mentor : VM,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
August 1993, The New England journal of medicine,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
November 2002, Annals of emergency medicine,
Xavier Bosch, and Juan M Pericas, and Cristina Hernández, and Pamela Doti
September 2002, The New England journal of medicine,
Copied contents to your clipboard!