Comparison of dual-energy subtraction and electronic bone suppression combined with computer-aided detection on chest radiographs: effect on human observers' performance in nodule detection. 2013

Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
University Hospital and University of Bern, Berne, Switzerland. zsolt.szuecs@szb-chb.ch

OBJECTIVE The objective of our study was to compare the effect of dual-energy subtraction and bone suppression software alone and in combination with computer-aided detection (CAD) on the performance of human observers in lung nodule detection. METHODS One hundred one patients with from one to five lung nodules measuring 5-29 mm and 42 subjects with no nodules were retrospectively selected and randomized. Three independent radiologists marked suspicious-appearing lesions on the original chest radiographs, dual-energy subtraction images, and bone-suppressed images before and after postprocessing with CAD. Marks of the observers and CAD marks were compared with CT as the reference standard. Data were analyzed using nonparametric tests and the jackknife alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic (JAFROC) method. RESULTS Using dual-energy subtraction alone (p = 0.0198) or CAD alone (p = 0.0095) improved the detection rate compared with using the original conventional chest radiograph. The combination of bone suppression and CAD provided the highest sensitivity (51.6%) and the original nonenhanced conventional chest radiograph alone provided the lowest (46.9%; p = 0.0049). Dual-energy subtraction and bone suppression provided the same false-positive (p = 0.2702) and true-positive (p = 0.8451) rates. Up to 22.9% of lesions were found only by the CAD program and were missed by the readers. JAFROC showed no difference in the performance between modalities (p = 0.2742-0.5442). CONCLUSIONS Dual-energy subtraction and the electronic bone suppression program used in this study provided similar detection rates for pulmonary nodules. Additionally, CAD alone or combined with bone suppression can significantly improve the sensitivity of human observers for pulmonary nodule detection.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011361 Professional Competence The capability to perform the duties of one's profession generally, or to perform a particular professional task, with skill of an acceptable quality. Competence, Professional,Generalization of Expertise,Technical Expertise,Expertise Generalization,Expertise, Technical
D011856 Radiographic Image Enhancement Improvement in the quality of an x-ray image by use of an intensifying screen, tube, or filter and by optimum exposure techniques. Digital processing methods are often employed. Digital Radiography,Image Enhancement, Radiographic,Radiography, Digital,Enhancement, Radiographic Image,Enhancements, Radiographic Image,Image Enhancements, Radiographic,Radiographic Image Enhancements
D011857 Radiographic Image Interpretation, Computer-Assisted Computer systems or networks designed to provide radiographic interpretive information. Computer Assisted Radiographic Image Interpretation,Computer-Assisted Radiographic Image Interpretation,Radiographic Image Interpretation, Computer Assisted
D001842 Bone and Bones A specialized CONNECTIVE TISSUE that is the main constituent of the SKELETON. The principal cellular component of bone is comprised of OSTEOBLASTS; OSTEOCYTES; and OSTEOCLASTS, while FIBRILLAR COLLAGENS and hydroxyapatite crystals form the BONE MATRIX. Bone Tissue,Bone and Bone,Bone,Bones,Bones and Bone,Bones and Bone Tissue,Bony Apophyses,Bony Apophysis,Condyle,Apophyses, Bony,Apophysis, Bony,Bone Tissues,Condyles,Tissue, Bone,Tissues, Bone
D003074 Solitary Pulmonary Nodule A single lung lesion that is characterized by a small round mass of tissue, usually less than 1 cm in diameter, and can be detected by chest radiography. A solitary pulmonary nodule can be associated with neoplasm, tuberculosis, cyst, or other anomalies in the lung, the CHEST WALL, or the PLEURA. Coin Lesion, Pulmonary,Pulmonary Coin Lesion,Pulmonary Nodule, Solitary,Solitary Lung Nodule,Coin Lesions, Pulmonary,Nodule, Solitary Pulmonary,Nodules, Solitary Pulmonary,Pulmonary Coin Lesions,Pulmonary Nodules, Solitary,Solitary Pulmonary Nodules,Lesion, Pulmonary Coin,Lung Nodule, Solitary,Nodule, Solitary Lung,Solitary Lung Nodules
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012680 Sensitivity and Specificity Binary classification measures to assess test results. Sensitivity or recall rate is the proportion of true positives. Specificity is the probability of correctly determining the absence of a condition. (From Last, Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2d ed) Specificity,Sensitivity,Specificity and Sensitivity

Related Publications

Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
January 2022, Korean journal of radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
January 2012, Korean journal of radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
June 2010, European radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
August 2013, Journal of digital imaging,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
November 2010, Radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
June 2006, Medical physics,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
December 2011, Radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
April 2015, Academic radiology,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
February 2010, Journal of thoracic imaging,
Zsolt Szucs-Farkas, and Alexander Schick, and Jennifer L Cullmann, and Lukas Ebner, and Boglarka Megyeri, and Peter Vock, and Andreas Christe
August 2022, Academic radiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!