Traction for low-back pain with or without sciatica. 2013

Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
Department of Otorhinolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery; G05.129, University Medical Center Utrecht, Heidelberglaan 100, Utrecht, Netherlands, 3584 CX.

BACKGROUND Traction has been used to treat low-back pain (LBP), often in combination with other treatments. We included both manual and machine-delivered traction in this review. This is an update of a Cochrane review first published in 1995, and previously updated in 2006. OBJECTIVE To assess the effects of traction compared to placebo, sham traction, reference treatments and no treatment in people with LBP. METHODS We searched the Cochrane Back Review Group Specialized Register, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (2012, Issue 8), MEDLINE (January 2006 to August 2012), EMBASE (January 2006 to August 2012), CINAHL (January 2006 to August 2012), and reference lists of articles and personal files. The review authors are not aware of any important new randomized controlled trial (RCTs) on this topic since the date of the last search. METHODS RCTs involving traction to treat acute (less than four weeks' duration), subacute (four to 12 weeks' duration) or chronic (more than 12 weeks' duration) non-specific LBP with or without sciatica. METHODS Two review authors independently performed study selection, risk of bias assessment and data extraction. As there were insufficient data for statistical pooling, we performed a descriptive analysis. We did not find any case series that identified adverse effects, therefore we evaluated adverse effects that were reported in the included studies. RESULTS We included 32 RCTs involving 2762 participants in this review. We considered 16 trials, representing 57% of all participants, to have a low risk of bias based on the Cochrane Back Review Group's 'Risk of bias' tool.For people with mixed symptom patterns (acute, subacute and chronic LBP with and without sciatica), there was low- to moderate-quality evidence that traction may make little or no difference in pain intensity, functional status, global improvement or return to work when compared to placebo, sham traction or no treatment. Similarly, when comparing the combination of physiotherapy plus traction with physiotherapy alone or when comparing traction with other treatments, there was very-low- to moderate-quality evidence that traction may make little or no difference in pain intensity, functional status or global improvement.For people with LBP with sciatica and acute, subacute or chronic pain, there was low- to moderate-quality evidence that traction probably has no impact on pain intensity, functional status or global improvement. This was true when traction was compared with controls and other treatments, as well as when the combination of traction plus physiotherapy was compared with physiotherapy alone. No studies reported the effect of traction on return to work.For chronic LBP without sciatica, there was moderate-quality evidence that traction probably makes little or no difference in pain intensity when compared with sham treatment. No studies reported on the effect of traction on functional status, global improvement or return to work.Adverse effects were reported in seven of the 32 studies. These included increased pain, aggravation of neurological signs and subsequent surgery. Four studies reported that there were no adverse effects. The remaining studies did not mention adverse effects. CONCLUSIONS These findings indicate that traction, either alone or in combination with other treatments, has little or no impact on pain intensity, functional status, global improvement and return to work among people with LBP. There is only limited-quality evidence from studies with small sample sizes and moderate to high risk of bias. The effects shown by these studies are small and are not clinically relevant. Implications for practice To date, the use of traction as treatment for non-specific LBP cannot be motivated by the best available evidence. These conclusions are applicable to both manual and mechanical traction. Implications for research Only new, large, high-quality studies may change the point estimate and its accuracy, but it should be noted that such change may not necessarily favour traction. Therefore, little priority should be given to new studies on the effect of traction treatment alone or as part of a package.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010147 Pain Measurement Scales, questionnaires, tests, and other methods used to assess pain severity and duration in patients or experimental animals to aid in diagnosis, therapy, and physiological studies. Analgesia Tests,Analogue Pain Scale,Formalin Test,McGill Pain Questionnaire,Nociception Tests,Pain Assessment,Pain Intensity,Pain Severity,Tourniquet Pain Test,Visual Analogue Pain Scale,Analog Pain Scale,Assessment, Pain,McGill Pain Scale,Visual Analog Pain Scale,Analgesia Test,Analog Pain Scales,Analogue Pain Scales,Formalin Tests,Intensity, Pain,Measurement, Pain,Nociception Test,Pain Assessments,Pain Intensities,Pain Measurements,Pain Questionnaire, McGill,Pain Scale, Analog,Pain Scale, Analogue,Pain Scale, McGill,Pain Severities,Pain Test, Tourniquet,Questionnaire, McGill Pain,Scale, Analog Pain,Scale, Analogue Pain,Scale, McGill Pain,Severity, Pain,Test, Analgesia,Test, Formalin,Test, Nociception,Test, Tourniquet Pain,Tests, Nociception,Tourniquet Pain Tests
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012585 Sciatica A condition characterized by pain radiating from the back into the buttock and posterior/lateral aspects of the leg. Sciatica may be a manifestation of SCIATIC NEUROPATHY; RADICULOPATHY (involving the SPINAL NERVE ROOTS; L4, L5, S1, or S2, often associated with INTERVERTEBRAL DISK DISPLACEMENT); or lesions of the CAUDA EQUINA. Neuralgia, Sciatic,Sciatic Neuralgia,Sciatica, Bilateral,Bilateral Sciatica,Bilateral Sciaticas,Neuralgias, Sciatic,Sciatic Neuralgias
D014143 Traction The pull on a limb or a part thereof. Skin traction (indirect traction) is applied by using a bandage to pull on the skin and fascia where light traction is required. Skeletal traction (direct traction), however, uses pins or wires inserted through bone and is attached to weights, pulleys, and ropes. (From Blauvelt & Nelson, A Manual of Orthopaedic Terminology, 5th ed) Tractions
D016032 Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic Works about clinical trials that involve at least one test treatment and one control treatment, concurrent enrollment and follow-up of the test- and control-treated groups, and in which the treatments to be administered are selected by a random process, such as the use of a random-numbers table. Clinical Trials, Randomized,Controlled Clinical Trials, Randomized,Trials, Randomized Clinical
D017116 Low Back Pain Acute or chronic pain in the lumbar or sacral regions, which may be associated with musculo-ligamentous SPRAINS AND STRAINS; INTERVERTEBRAL DISK DISPLACEMENT; and other conditions. Lumbago,Low Back Ache,Low Back Pain, Mechanical,Low Back Pain, Posterior Compartment,Low Back Pain, Postural,Low Back Pain, Recurrent,Low Backache,Lower Back Pain,Mechanical Low Back Pain,Postural Low Back Pain,Recurrent Low Back Pain,Ache, Low Back,Aches, Low Back,Back Ache, Low,Back Aches, Low,Back Pain, Low,Back Pain, Lower,Back Pains, Low,Back Pains, Lower,Backache, Low,Backaches, Low,Low Back Aches,Low Back Pains,Low Backaches,Lower Back Pains,Pain, Low Back,Pain, Lower Back,Pains, Low Back,Pains, Lower Back
D059350 Chronic Pain Aching sensation that persists for more than a few months. It may or may not be associated with trauma or disease, and may persist after the initial injury has healed. Its localization, character, and timing are more vague than with acute pain. Chronic Primary Pain,Chronic Secondary Pain,Pain, Chronic,Widespread Chronic Pain,Chronic Pain, Widespread,Pain, Chronic Primary,Pain, Chronic Secondary,Pain, Widespread Chronic,Primary Pain, Chronic,Secondary Pain, Chronic
D059787 Acute Pain Intensely discomforting, distressful, or agonizing sensation associated with trauma or disease, with well-defined location, character, and timing. Acute Pains,Pain, Acute,Pains, Acute

Related Publications

Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
October 2005, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
April 2007, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
May 1946, Laval medical,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
January 2007, Ugeskrift for laeger,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
April 1947, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
July 1948, Christ Hospital medical bulletin,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
June 2006, Spine,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
March 1974, Physiotherapy,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
July 1982, Quarterly medical review,
Inge Wegner, and Indah S Widyahening, and Maurits W van Tulder, and Stefan E I Blomberg, and Henrica Cw de Vet, and Gert Brønfort, and Lex M Bouter, and Geert J van der Heijden
August 1949, American journal of surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!