Parental limited English proficiency and health outcomes for children with special health care needs: a systematic review. 2014

Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
Division of General Pediatrics, Lucile Packard Children's Hospital, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, Calif. Electronic address: meneriz@stanford.edu.

BACKGROUND One in 10 US adults of childbearing age has limited English proficiency (LEP). Parental LEP is associated with worse health outcomes among healthy children. The relationship of parental LEP to health outcomes for children with special health care needs (CSHCN) has not been systematically reviewed. OBJECTIVE To conduct a systematic review of peer-reviewed literature examining relationships between parental LEP and health outcomes for CSHCN. METHODS PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Social Science Abstracts, bibliographies of included studies. Key search term categories: language, child, special health care needs, and health outcomes. METHODS US studies published between 1964 and 2012 were included if: 1) subjects were CSHCN; 2) studies included some measure of parental LEP; 3) at least 1 outcome measure of child health status, access, utilization, costs, or quality; and 4) primary or secondary data analysis. METHODS Three trained reviewers independently screened studies and extracted data. Two separate reviewers appraised studies for methodological rigor and quality. RESULTS From 2765 titles and abstracts, 31 studies met eligibility criteria. Five studies assessed child health status, 12 assessed access, 8 assessed utilization, 2 assessed costs, and 14 assessed quality. Nearly all (29 of 31) studies used only parent- or child-reported outcome measures, rather than objective measures. LEP parents were substantially more likely than English-proficient parents to report that their CSHCN were uninsured and had no usual source of care or medical home. LEP parents were also less likely to report family-centered care and satisfaction with care. Disparities persisted for children with LEP parents after adjustment for ethnicity and socioeconomic status. CONCLUSIONS Parental LEP is independently associated with worse health care access and quality for CSHCN. Health care providers should recognize LEP as an independent risk factor for poor health outcomes among CSHCN. Emerging models of chronic disease care should integrate and evaluate interventions that target access and quality disparities for LEP families.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007802 Language A verbal or nonverbal means of communicating ideas or feelings. Dialect,Dialects,Languages
D010290 Parents Persons functioning as natural, adoptive, or substitute parents. The heading includes the concept of parenthood as well as preparation for becoming a parent. Step-Parents,Parental Age,Parenthood Status,Stepparent,Age, Parental,Ages, Parental,Parent,Parental Ages,Status, Parenthood,Step Parents,Step-Parent,Stepparents
D011787 Quality of Health Care The levels of excellence which characterize the health service or health care provided based on accepted standards of quality. Pharmacy Audit,Quality of Care,Quality of Healthcare,Audit, Pharmacy,Care Quality,Health Care Quality,Healthcare Quality,Pharmacy Audits
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D002662 Child Health Services Organized services to provide health care for children. Infant Health Services,Child Services, Health,Health Services, Child,Health Services, Infant,Infant Services, Health,Services, Child Health,Services, Infant Health,Child Health Service,Health Service, Child,Health Service, Infant,Infant Health Service,Service, Child Health,Service, Infant Health
D003144 Communication Barriers Those factors, such as language or sociocultural relationships, which interfere in the meaningful interpretation and transmission of ideas between individuals or groups. Language Barriers,Barrier, Communication,Barrier, Language,Barriers, Communication,Barriers, Language,Communication Barrier,Language Barrier
D006297 Health Services Accessibility The degree to which individuals are inhibited or facilitated in their ability to gain entry to and to receive care and services from the health care system. Factors influencing this ability include geographic, architectural, transportational, and financial considerations, among others. Access To Care, Health,Access to Care,Access to Contraception,Access to Health Care,Access to Health Services,Access to Medications,Access to Medicines,Access to Therapy,Access to Treatment,Accessibility of Health Services,Availability of Health Services,Contraception Access,Contraceptive Access,Medication Access,Accessibility, Health Services,Contraceptive Availability,Health Services Geographic Accessibility,Program Accessibility,Access to Cares,Access to Contraceptions,Access to Medication,Access to Medicine,Access to Therapies,Access to Treatments,Access, Contraception,Access, Contraceptive,Access, Medication,Accessibilities, Health Services,Accessibility, Program,Availability, Contraceptive,Care, Access to,Cares, Access to,Contraception, Access to,Contraceptive Accesses,Health Services Availability,Medication Accesses,Medication, Access to,Medicine, Access to,Medicines, Access to,Therapy, Access to,Treatment, Access to
D006301 Health Services Needs and Demand Health services required by a population or community as well as the health services that the population or community is able and willing to pay for. Health Services Needs,Needs,Needs and Demand, Health Services,Target Population,Health Services Need,Need, Health Services,Needs, Health Services,Population, Target,Populations, Target,Target Populations
D006302 Health Services Research The integration of epidemiologic, sociological, economic, and other analytic sciences in the study of health services. Health services research is usually concerned with relationships between need, demand, supply, use, and outcome of health services. The aim of the research is evaluation, particularly in terms of structure, process, output, and outcome. (From Last, Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2d ed) Health Care Research,Medical Care Research,Research, Health Services,Action Research,Health Services Evaluation,Healthcare Research,Research, Medical Care,Evaluation, Health Services,Evaluations, Health Services,Health Services Evaluations,Research, Action,Research, Health Care,Research, Healthcare
D006304 Health Status The level of health of the individual, group, or population as subjectively assessed by the individual or by more objective measures. General Health,General Health Level,General Health Status,Level of Health,Overall Health,Overall Health Status,General Health Levels,Health Level,Health Level, General,Health Levels,Health Status, General,Health Status, Overall,Health, General,Health, Overall,Level, General Health,Levels, General Health,Status, General Health,Status, Health,Status, Overall Health

Related Publications

Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
June 2023, Anesthesia and analgesia,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
March 2018, Journal of general internal medicine,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
June 2022, Journal of general internal medicine,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
June 2019, Joint Commission journal on quality and patient safety,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
April 2024, Pain management nursing : official journal of the American Society of Pain Management Nurses,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
January 2024, Academic pediatrics,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
January 2011, Academic pediatrics,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
May 2018, Child: care, health and development,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
July 2020, JBI evidence synthesis,
Monica Eneriz-Wiemer, and Lee M Sanders, and Donald A Barr, and Fernando S Mendoza
June 2016, Journal of clinical nursing,
Copied contents to your clipboard!