Genetic counselors' views and experiences with the clinical integration of genome sequencing. 2014

Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
Genetic Counseling Program, Brandeis University, MS008 415 South St., Waltham, MA, 02454-9110, USA, kmachini@brandeis.edu.

In recent years, new sequencing technologies known as next generation sequencing (NGS) have provided scientists the ability to rapidly sequence all known coding as well as non-coding sequences in the human genome. As the two emerging approaches, whole exome (WES) and whole genome (WGS) sequencing, have started to be integrated in the clinical arena, we sought to survey health care professionals who are likely to be involved in the implementation process now and/or in the future (e.g., genetic counselors, geneticists and nurse practitioners). Two hundred twenty-one genetic counselors- one third of whom currently offer WES/WGS-participated in an anonymous online survey. The aims of the survey were first, to identify barriers to the implementation of WES/WGS, as perceived by survey participants; second, to provide the first systematic report of current practices regarding the integration of WES/WGS in clinic and/or research across the US and Canada and to illuminate the roles and challenges of genetic counselors participating in this process; and third to evaluate the impact of WES/WGS on patient care. Our results showed that genetic counseling practices with respect to WES/WGS are consistent with the criteria set forth in the ACMG 2012 policy statement, which highlights indications for testing, reporting, and pre/post test considerations. Our respondents described challenges related to offering WES/WGS, which included billing issues, the duration and content of the consent process, result interpretation and disclosure of incidental findings and variants of unknown significance. In addition, respondents indicated that specialty area (i.e., prenatal and cancer), lack of clinical utility of WES/WGS and concerns about interpretation of test results were factors that prevented them from offering this technology to patients. Finally, study participants identified the aspects of their professional training which have been most beneficial in aiding with the integration of WES/WGS into the clinical setting (molecular/clinical genetics, counseling and bioethics) and suggested that counseling aids (to assist them when explaining aspects of these tests to patients) and webinars focused on WES/WGS (for genetic counselors and other health care professionals) would be useful educational tools. Future research should permit us to further enhance our knowledge of pitfalls and benefits associated with the introduction of these powerful technologies in patient care and to further explore the roles and opportunities for genetic counselors in this rapidly evolving field.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D005817 Genetic Counseling An educational process that provides information and advice to individuals or families about a genetic condition that may affect them. The purpose is to help individuals make informed decisions about marriage, reproduction, and other health management issues based on information about the genetic disease, the available diagnostic tests, and management programs. Psychosocial support is usually offered. Counseling, Genetic,Genetic Counseling, Prenatal,Prenatal Genetic Counseling
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001291 Attitude of Health Personnel Attitudes of personnel toward their patients, other professionals, toward the medical care system, etc. Staff Attitude,Attitude, Staff,Attitudes, Staff,Health Personnel Attitude,Health Personnel Attitudes,Staff Attitudes
D015894 Genome, Human The complete genetic complement contained in the DNA of a set of CHROMOSOMES in a HUMAN. The length of the human genome is about 3 billion base pairs. Human Genome,Genomes, Human,Human Genomes

Related Publications

Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
August 2014, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
February 2024, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
October 2008, Patient education and counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
October 2017, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
April 2011, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
November 2020, European journal of human genetics : EJHG,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
October 2021, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
June 2022, Journal of genetic counseling,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
January 1983, Community mental health journal,
Kalotina Machini, and Jessica Douglas, and Alicia Braxton, and Judith Tsipis, and Kate Kramer
February 2018, Journal of genetic counseling,
Copied contents to your clipboard!