Rear seat safety: Variation in protection by occupant, crash and vehicle characteristics. 2015

Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
The Department of Pediatrics, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, United States; The Center for Injury Research and Prevention, The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Research Institute, United States; The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, United States. Electronic address: durbind@email.chop.edu.

OBJECTIVE Current information on the safety of rear row occupants of all ages is needed to inform further advances in rear seat restraint system design and testing. The objectives of this study were to describe characteristics of occupants in the front and rear rows of model year 2000 and newer vehicles involved in crashes and determine the risk of serious injury for restrained crash-involved rear row occupants and the relative risk of fatal injury for restrained rear row vs. front passenger seat occupants by age group, impact direction, and vehicle model year. METHODS Data from the National Automotive Sampling System Crashworthiness Data System (NASS-CDS) and Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) were queried for all crashes during 2007-2012 involving model year 2000 and newer passenger vehicles. Data from NASS-CDS were used to describe characteristics of occupants in the front and rear rows and to determine the risk of serious injury (AIS 3+) for restrained rear row occupants by occupant age, vehicle model year, and impact direction. Using a combined data set containing data on fatalities from FARS and estimates of the total population of occupants in crashes from NASS-CDS, logistic regression modeling was used to compute the relative risk (RR) of death for restrained occupants in the rear vs. front passenger seat by occupant age, impact direction, and vehicle model year. RESULTS Among all vehicle occupants in tow-away crashes during 2007-2012, 12.3% were in the rear row where the overall risk of serious injury was 1.3%. Among restrained rear row occupants, the risk of serious injury varied by occupant age, with older adults at the highest risk of serious injury (2.9%); by impact direction, with rollover crashes associated with the highest risk (1.5%); and by vehicle model year, with model year 2007 and newer vehicles having the lowest risk of serious injury (0.3%). Relative risk of death was lower for restrained children up to age 8 in the rear compared with passengers in the right front seat (RR=0.27, 95% CI 0.12-0.58 for 0-3 years, RR=0.55, 95% CI 0.30-0.98 for 4-8 years) but was higher for restrained 9-12-year-old children (RR=1.83, 95% CI 1.18-2.84). There was no evidence for a difference in risk of death in the rear vs. front seat for occupants ages 13-54, but there was some evidence for an increased relative risk of death for adults age 55 and older in the rear vs. passengers in the right front seat (RR=1.41, 95% CI 0.94-2.13), though we could not exclude the possibility of no difference. After controlling for occupant age and gender, the relative risk of death for restrained rear row occupants was significantly higher than that of front seat occupants in model year 2007 and newer vehicles and significantly higher in rear and right side impact crashes. CONCLUSIONS Results of this study extend prior research on the relative safety of the rear seat compared with the front by examining a more contemporary fleet of vehicles. The rear row is primarily occupied by children and adolescents, but the variable relative risk of death in the rear compared with the front seat for occupants of different age groups highlights the challenges in providing optimal protection to a wide range of rear seat occupants. Findings of an elevated risk of death for rear row occupants, as compared with front row passengers, in the newest model year vehicles provides further evidence that rear seat safety is not keeping pace with advances in the front seat.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007223 Infant A child between 1 and 23 months of age. Infants
D007231 Infant, Newborn An infant during the first 28 days after birth. Neonate,Newborns,Infants, Newborn,Neonates,Newborn,Newborn Infant,Newborn Infants
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D008962 Models, Theoretical Theoretical representations that simulate the behavior or activity of systems, processes, or phenomena. They include the use of mathematical equations, computers, and other electronic equipment. Experimental Model,Experimental Models,Mathematical Model,Model, Experimental,Models (Theoretical),Models, Experimental,Models, Theoretic,Theoretical Study,Mathematical Models,Model (Theoretical),Model, Mathematical,Model, Theoretical,Models, Mathematical,Studies, Theoretical,Study, Theoretical,Theoretical Model,Theoretical Models,Theoretical Studies
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D002675 Child, Preschool A child between the ages of 2 and 5. Children, Preschool,Preschool Child,Preschool Children
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000063 Accidents, Traffic Accidents on streets, roads, and highways involving drivers, passengers, pedestrians, or vehicles. Traffic accidents refer to AUTOMOBILES (passenger cars, buses, and trucks), BICYCLING, and MOTORCYCLES but not OFF-ROAD MOTOR VEHICLES; RAILROADS nor snowmobiles. Traffic Collisions,Traffic Crashes,Traffic Accidents,Accident, Traffic,Collision, Traffic,Collisions, Traffic,Crashes, Traffic,Traffic Accident,Traffic Collision

Related Publications

Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
November 2009, Stapp car crash journal,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
January 2024, Traffic injury prevention,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
August 2023, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
September 1976, American journal of public health,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
October 2009, Annals of advances in automotive medicine. Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine. Annual Scientific Conference,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
April 2024, Stapp car crash journal,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
November 2017, Stapp car crash journal,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
December 2010, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
January 2023, Traffic injury prevention,
Dennis R Durbin, and Jessica S Jermakian, and Michael J Kallan, and Anne T McCartt, and Kristy B Arbogast, and Mark R Zonfrillo, and Rachel K Myers
January 2014, Traffic injury prevention,
Copied contents to your clipboard!