Teaching Medical Students, what do Consultants think? 2015

Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
Speciality Trainee Year 7, Department of General Surgery The Ulster Hospital, Upper Newtownards Road, Belfast, BT16 1RH.

BACKGROUND The approach to and delivery of medical student education has undergone significant change within the last decade. There has been a shift away from didactic lectures to small group tutorials, facilitated by clinicians. Anecdotally there is an impression that enthusiasm for teaching is waning. The aim of this qualitative study is to assess the current attitudes of consultants, across all specialities, to teaching medical students in small group settings. METHODS A Likert scale questionnaire, relating to teaching medical students in small group tutorials, was distributed via email to all consultants working in one region. Questions considered the categories: attitudes to teaching, financial considerations, time constraints and attitudes to students. RESULTS 367 responses were received. 72% of responders were actively involved in teaching. 72% of respondents indicated that medical students should be taught by consultants and 80% felt that teaching medical students was enjoyable. 60% felt they were not financially remunerated for teaching and 50% indicated teaching was not included in job plans; despite this a significant proportion of these respondents remain involved in teaching (68%). Non-teachers were more likely to indicate that teaching was not paid for (p=0.003). 78% indicated consultants do not have adequate time to teach medical students. 82% felt that medical students appreciate consultant led teaching but only 55% felt students had an appropriate level of enthusiasm for learning. CONCLUSIONS Consultants in this Deanery are actively involved in medical student teaching and enjoy it. Consultants perceive that they are not adequately financially rewarded but for the most part this is not a deterrent. Time constraints are an issue and there is a desire to have teaching included in job plans to counteract this. Most consultants are complimentary about student attitudes but there is a perception that medical students need to contribute more to their own learning.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010820 Physicians Individuals licensed to practice medicine. Physician
D004501 Education, Medical Use for general articles concerning medical education. Medical Education
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001291 Attitude of Health Personnel Attitudes of personnel toward their patients, other professionals, toward the medical care system, etc. Staff Attitude,Attitude, Staff,Attitudes, Staff,Health Personnel Attitude,Health Personnel Attitudes,Staff Attitudes
D013337 Students, Medical Individuals enrolled in a school of medicine or a formal educational program in medicine. Medical Student,Medical Students,Student, Medical
D013663 Teaching A formal and organized process of transmitting knowledge to a person or group. Teaching Method,Training Activity,Training Technique,Academic Training,Educational Technics,Educational Techniques,Pedagogy,Teaching Methods,Technics, Educational,Techniques, Educational,Training Activities,Training Technics,Training Techniques,Activities, Training,Activity, Training,Educational Technic,Educational Technique,Method, Teaching,Methods, Teaching,Pedagogies,Technic, Educational,Technic, Training,Technics, Training,Technique, Educational,Technique, Training,Techniques, Training,Training Technic,Training, Academic
D013997 Time Factors Elements of limited time intervals, contributing to particular results or situations. Time Series,Factor, Time,Time Factor
D036301 Qualitative Research Any type of research that employs nonnumeric information to explore individual or group characteristics, producing findings not arrived at by statistical procedures or other quantitative means. (Qualitative Inquiry: A Dictionary of Terms Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 1997) Research, Qualitative

Related Publications

Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
April 1980, The Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
March 2004, Education for health (Abingdon, England),
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
January 2023, Journal of medical education and curricular development,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
April 2023, Revista de neurologia,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
January 2018, Education for health (Abingdon, England),
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
June 2020, Psychology, health & medicine,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
January 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
March 2023, Actas dermo-sifiliograficas,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
March 2019, Future healthcare journal,
Lynn Darragh, and Robin Baker, and Stephen Kirk
August 2012, The Linacre quarterly,
Copied contents to your clipboard!