Routine Chest Computed Tomography and Patient Outcome in Blunt Trauma. 2015

Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
Trauma Research Center, Kashan University of Medical Sciences, Kashan, IR Iran.

BACKGROUND Computerized Tomography (CT) scan is gaining more importance in the initial evaluation of patients with multiple trauma, but its effect on the outcome is still unclear. Until now, no prospective randomized trial has been performed to define the role of routine chest CT in patients with blunt trauma. OBJECTIVE In view of the considerable radiation exposure and the high costs of CT scan, the aim of this study was to assess the effects of performing the routine chest CT on the outcome as well as complications in patients with blunt trauma. METHODS After approval by the ethics board committee, 100 hemodynamically stable patients with high-energy blunt trauma were randomly divided into two groups. For group one (control group), only chest X-ray was requested and further diagnostic work-up was performed by the decision of the trauma team. For group two, a chest X-ray was ordered followed by a chest CT, even if the chest X-ray was normal. Injury severity, total hospitalization time, Intensive Care Unit (ICU) admission time, duration of mechanical ventilation and complications were recorded. Data were evaluated using t-test, Man-Whitney and chi-squared test. RESULTS No significant differences were found regarding the demographic data such as age, injury severity and Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS). Thirty-eight percent additional findings were seen in chest CT in 26% of the patients of the group undergoing routine chest CT, leading to 8% change in management. The mean of in-hospital stay showed no significant difference in both groups with a P value of 0.098. In addition, the mean ICU stay and ventilation time revealed no significant differences (P values = 0.102 and 0.576, respectively). Mortality rate and complications were similar in both groups. CONCLUSIONS Performing the routine chest CT in high-energy blunt trauma patients (with a mean injury severity of 9), although leading to the diagnosis of some occult injuries, has no impact on the outcome and does not decrease the in-hospital stay and ICU admission time. It seems that performing the routine chest CT in these patients may lead to overtreatment of nonsignificant injuries. The decision about performing routine CT scan in a trauma center should be made cautiously, considering the detriments and benefits.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
September 1991, Chest,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
July 1987, Journal of thoracic imaging,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
January 2009, The Indian journal of chest diseases & allied sciences,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
May 2015, Injury,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
March 2008, European journal of radiology,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
January 2014, The Journal of surgical research,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
November 2009, The Journal of trauma,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
August 2018, JAMA surgery,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
August 2013, Vojnosanitetski pregled,
Nushin Moussavi, and Abdol Hossein Davoodabadi, and Fatemeh Atoof, and Seyed Ebrahim Razi, and Mehdi Behnampour, and Hamid Reza Talari
May 2021, Journal of pediatric surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!