[Meta-analysis of stable carbon and nitrogen isotopic enrichment factors for aquatic animals]. 2016

Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen

Isotopic enrichment factor (Δ, the difference between the δ value of food and a consumer tissue) is an important parameter in using stable isotope analysis (SIA) to reconstruct diets, characterize trophic relationships, elucidate patterns of resource allocation, and construct food webs. Isotopic enrichment factor has been considered as a constancy value across a broad range of animals. However, recent studies showed that the isotopic enrichment factor differed among various types of animals although the magnitude of variation was not clear. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis to synthesize and compare Δ13C and Δ15N among four types of aquatic animals (teleosts, crustaceans, reptiles and molluscs). We searched for papers published before 2014 on Web of Science and CNKI using the key words "stable isotope or isotopic fractionation or fractionation factor or isotopic enrichment or trophic enrichment". Forty-two publications that contain 140 studies on Δ13C and 159 studies on Δ15N were obtained. We conducted three parallel meta-analyses by using three types of weights (the reciprocal of variance as weights, the sample size as weights, and equal weights). The results showed that no significant difference in Δ13C among different animal types (teleosts 1.0 per thousand, crustaceans 1.3 per thousand, reptiles 0.5 per thousand, and molluscs 1.5 per thousand), while Δ15N values were significantly different (teleosts 2.4 per thousand, crustaceans 3.6 per thousand, reptiles 1.0 per thousand and molluscs 2.5 per thousand). Our results suggested that the overall mean of Δ13C could be used as a general enrichment factor, but Δ15N should be chosen according to the type of aquatic animals in using SIA to analyze trophic relationships, patterns of resource allocation and food webs.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008974 Mollusca A phylum of the kingdom Metazoa. Mollusca have soft, unsegmented bodies with an anterior head, a dorsal visceral mass, and a ventral foot. Most are encased in a protective calcareous shell. It includes the classes GASTROPODA; BIVALVIA; CEPHALOPODA; Aplacophora; Scaphopoda; Polyplacophora; and Monoplacophora. Molluscs,Mollusks,Mollusc,Molluscas,Mollusk
D009587 Nitrogen Isotopes Stable nitrogen atoms that have the same atomic number as the element nitrogen but differ in atomic weight. N-15 is a stable nitrogen isotope. Nitrogen Isotope,Isotope, Nitrogen,Isotopes, Nitrogen
D012104 Reptiles Cold-blooded, air-breathing VERTEBRATES belonging to the class Reptilia, usually covered with external scales or bony plates. Reptilia,Reptile
D002247 Carbon Isotopes Stable carbon atoms that have the same atomic number as the element carbon but differ in atomic weight. C-13 is a stable carbon isotope. Carbon Isotope,Isotope, Carbon,Isotopes, Carbon
D003445 Crustacea A large subphylum of mostly marine ARTHROPODS containing over 42,000 species. They include familiar arthropods such as lobsters (NEPHROPIDAE), crabs (BRACHYURA), shrimp (PENAEIDAE), and barnacles (THORACICA). Ostracoda,Ostracods,Crustaceas,Ostracod,Ostracodas
D004032 Diet Regular course of eating and drinking adopted by a person or animal. Diets
D005399 Fishes A group of cold-blooded, aquatic vertebrates having gills, fins, a cartilaginous or bony endoskeleton, and elongated bodies covered with scales.
D000818 Animals Unicellular or multicellular, heterotrophic organisms, that have sensation and the power of voluntary movement. Under the older five kingdom paradigm, Animalia was one of the kingdoms. Under the modern three domain model, Animalia represents one of the many groups in the domain EUKARYOTA. Animal,Metazoa,Animalia
D020387 Food Chain The sequence of transfers of matter and energy from organism to organism in the form of FOOD. Food chains intertwine locally into a food web because most organisms consume more than one type of animal or plant. PLANTS, which convert SOLAR ENERGY to food by PHOTOSYNTHESIS, are the primary food source. In a predator chain, a plant-eating animal is eaten by a larger animal. In a parasite chain, a smaller organism consumes part of a larger host and may itself be parasitized by smaller organisms. In a saprophytic chain, microorganisms live on dead organic matter. Food Web,Parasite Chain,Predator Chain,Saprophytic Chain,Chain, Food,Chain, Parasite,Chain, Predator,Chain, Saprophytic,Chains, Food,Chains, Parasite,Chains, Predator,Chains, Saprophytic,Food Chains,Food Webs,Parasite Chains,Predator Chains,Saprophytic Chains,Web, Food,Webs, Food

Related Publications

Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
January 2016, PloS one,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
May 2015, The veterinary clinics of North America. Exotic animal practice,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
January 2021, Frontiers in microbiology,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
November 2010, Oecologia,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
August 2017, Royal Society open science,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
June 2009, Analytica chimica acta,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
November 2017, Royal Society open science,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
January 2000, Rapid communications in mass spectrometry : RCM,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
May 1996, American journal of physical anthropology,
Liang Guo, and Cui-ping Sun, and Wei-zheng Ren, and Jian Zhang, and Jian-iun Tang, and Liana-liang Hu, and Xin Chen
November 2015, Ecology and evolution,
Copied contents to your clipboard!