Racial Differences in Parental Responses to Children's Chronic Pain. 2017

Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
*Department of Clinical Psychology, UT Southwestern Medical Center †Center for Cancer and Blood Disorders, Children's Medical Center, Dallas, TX ‡Institute for Applied Research in Youth Development, Tufts University, Medford §Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine, Division of Pain Medicine, Children's Hospital ∥Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.

Parental responses to children's pain are related to how youth cope with chronic pain. However, little research has explored cultural differences in the 4 major pain response categories (ie, protect, minimize, distract, and monitor). This study compared parental responses to children's pain between minority parents (ie, black, Hispanic, multiracial) and parents of white children. Participants included 234 patients, ages 8 to 17, with chronic pain (73.5% female; age M [SD]=13.91 [2.38]; 50% white, 15.39% black, 20.90% Hispanic, 13.68% multiracial). Patients' parents completed the Adult Responses to Children's Symptoms. Parental responses included: protect, monitor, minimize, and distrct. For between-group comparisons, white participants (N=117) were matched on age and sex with black (N=36), Hispanic (N=49), and multiracial (N=32) participants. Paired-samples t tests revealed that protectiveness was higher for parents of black children (t48=-3.84, P<0.001, black M [SD]=1.93 [0.69], white M [SD]=0.94 [0.77], Cohen d=1.09) and parents of Hispanic children (t71=-7.10, P<0.001, Hispanic M [SD]=1.65 [0.76], white M [SD]=0.94 [0.77], Cohen d=1.52) compared with parents of white children. In addition, parents of black children (t40=-2.90, P=0.006, black M [SD]=3.55 [0.49], white M [SD]=2.89 [0.93], Cohen d=0.80) and parents of Hispanic children (t71=-3.62, P<0.001, Hispanic M [SD]=3.35 [0.69], white M [SD]=2.89 [0.93], Cohen d=0.81) were significantly more monitoring their children than were parents of white children. Parents of Hispanic children were also significantly more minimizing than parents of white children (t71=-3.68, P<0.001, Hispanic M [SD]=0.88 [0.75], white M [SD]=0.51 [0.58], Cohen d=0.80). No other significant differences were found. Results highlight the need to adapt pediatric chronic pain interventions to family culture and context. Further research is needed to understand pediatric chronic pain from a cross-cultural perspective.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008425 Maternal Behavior The behavior patterns associated with or characteristic of a mother. Maternal Patterns of Care,Maternal Care Patterns,Behavior, Maternal,Behaviors, Maternal,Care Pattern, Maternal,Care Patterns, Maternal,Maternal Behaviors,Maternal Care Pattern,Pattern, Maternal Care,Patterns, Maternal Care
D008913 Minority Groups A subgroup having special characteristics within a larger group, often bound together by special ties which distinguish it from the larger group. Group, Minority,Groups, Minority,Minority Group
D010290 Parents Persons functioning as natural, adoptive, or substitute parents. The heading includes the concept of parenthood as well as preparation for becoming a parent. Step-Parents,Parental Age,Parenthood Status,Stepparent,Age, Parental,Ages, Parental,Parent,Parental Ages,Status, Parenthood,Step Parents,Step-Parent,Stepparents
D010332 Paternal Behavior The behavior patterns associated with or characteristic of a father. Behavior, Paternal,Behaviors, Paternal,Paternal Behaviors
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D003431 Cross-Cultural Comparison Comparison of various psychological, sociological, or cultural factors in order to assess the similarities or diversities occurring in two or more different cultures or societies. Transcultural Studies,Comparison, Cross-Cultural,Comparisons, Cross-Cultural,Cross Cultural Comparison,Cross-Cultural Comparisons,Studies, Transcultural,Study, Transcultural,Transcultural Study
D005006 Ethnicity A group of people with a common cultural heritage that sets them apart from others in a variety of social relationships. Ethnic Groups,Nationality,Ethnic Group,Nationalities
D005163 Factor Analysis, Statistical A set of statistical methods for analyzing the correlations among several variables in order to estimate the number of fundamental dimensions that underlie the observed data and to describe and measure those dimensions. It is used frequently in the development of scoring systems for rating scales and questionnaires. Analysis, Factor,Analysis, Statistical Factor,Factor Analysis,Statistical Factor Analysis,Analyses, Factor,Analyses, Statistical Factor,Factor Analyses,Factor Analyses, Statistical,Statistical Factor Analyses
D005260 Female Females

Related Publications

Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
May 2023, Cureus,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
October 2018, Pain,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
December 2018, Schmerz (Berlin, Germany),
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
June 1989, American journal of diseases of children (1960),
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
February 1991, Pediatrics,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
November 2000, American journal of public health,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
May 2005, The journal of pain,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
August 1972, Journal of psychosomatic research,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
September 2017, Pain management,
Ana F El-Behadli, and Patricia Gansert, and Deirdre E Logan
January 2011, Pain research & management,
Copied contents to your clipboard!