Patients on chronic hemodialysis with hyperlipidemia were found to respond either with decreased levels (responders) or with a further increase of the plasma triglyceride levels (nonresponders) to a carnitine substitution therapy. The aim of the present study was to find possible predictors to distinguish between responders and nonresponders prior to the initiation of therapy. Since it is suggested that erythrocytes are involved in carnitine transport to tissues, it was of interest to determine plasma and erythrocyte carnitine concentrations in the hemodialyzed patients before and during carnitine substitution therapy and to compare the results with those of healthy controls. Before therapy, comparatively lower plasma levels of both free and total carnitine, but higher portions of short-chain acylcarnitine on total carnitine were found in all patients. In erythrocytes, the nonresponders showed significantly higher total carnitine levels, compared to responders and controls. After the start of carnitine substitution, the increase of total plasma carnitine during the substitution period corresponded with the carnitine dose administered in responders, in nonresponders the highest carnitine values were found in the second week when the lower carnitine dose was administered. The changes of the plasma short-chain acylcarnitine levels with time were very similar to those of plasma triglycerides. All patients showed a time-delayed accumulation of carnitine in erythrocytes and, interestingly, markedly higher concentrations in the second week when the lower carnitine dose was administered. The results of the present study demonstrate that the erythrocyte carnitine content is a reliable predictor to distinguish between responders and nonresponders prior to the start of a carnitine substitution therapy.