Effectiveness of 1:1 speech and language therapy for older children with (developmental) language disorder. 2017

Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
Moor House School & College, Oxted, UK.

Evidence of the effectiveness of therapy for older children with (developmental) language disorder (DLD), and particularly those with receptive language impairments, is very limited. The few existing studies have focused on particular target areas, but none has looked at a whole area of a service. To establish whether for students with (developmental) language disorder attending a specialist school, 1:1 intervention with an SLT during one school term improves performance on targeted areas, compared with untreated control areas. Also, to investigate whether gender, receptive language status, autism spectrum disorder (ASD) status, or educational Key Stage affected their response to this intervention. Seventy-two students (aged 9-17 years, 88% of whom had receptive language impairments) and all speech and language therapists (SLTs) in our specialist school for children with Language Disorder, most of whom have DLD participated in this study over one school term. During this term, the SLTs devised pre- and post-therapy measures for every student for each target they planned to treat 1:1. In addition, for each target area, a control measure was devised. The targets covered a wide range of speech, language and communication areas, both receptive and expressive. Post-therapy tests were administered 'blind'. During the term, SLTs and students worked 1:1 on 120 targets, the majority in the areas of expressive and receptive language. Targets and controls did not differ pre-therapy. Significant progress was seen both on targets (d = 1.33) and controls (d = 0.36), but the targeted areas improved significantly more than the controls with a large and clinically significant effect size (d = 1.06). There was no effect of language area targeted (targets improved more than their controls for all areas). Participants with versus those without receptive language difficulties, co-occurring ASD diagnosis or participants in different educational Key Stages did not differ significantly in terms of the progress they made on target areas. Direct 1:1 intervention with an SLT can be effective for all areas of language for older children with (D)LD, regardless of their gender, receptive language or ASD status, or age. This adds to the relatively limited evidence base regarding the effectiveness of direct SLT intervention for school-aged children with (D)LD and for children with receptive language impairments. If direct 1:1 intervention can be effective with this hard-to-treat group, it may well also be effective with younger children with (D)LD. Thus, direct SLT services should be available for school-aged children with (D)LD, including older children and adolescents with pervasive difficulties.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007805 Language Development Disorders Conditions characterized by language abilities (comprehension and expression of speech and writing) that are below the expected level for a given age, generally in the absence of an intellectual impairment. These conditions may be associated with DEAFNESS; BRAIN DISEASES; MENTAL DISORDERS; or environmental factors. Language Delay,Speech Delay,Auditory Processing Disorder, Central,Central Auditory Processing Disorder,Developmental Disorder, Speech or Language,Developmental Language Disorders,Language Disorders, Developmental,Semantic-Pragmatic Disorder,Speech or Language, Developmental Disorder,Delay, Speech,Delays, Speech,Development Disorder, Language,Developmental Language Disorder,Disorder, Language Development,Disorders, Language Development,Language Delays,Language Development Disorder,Language Disorder, Developmental,Semantic Pragmatic Disorder,Semantic-Pragmatic Disorders,Speech Delays
D007808 Language Therapy Rehabilitation of persons with language disorders or training of children with language development disorders. Language Training,Therapy, Language,Language Therapies,Language Trainings,Therapies, Language,Training, Language,Trainings, Language
D008297 Male Males
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D002663 Child Language The language and sounds expressed by a child at a particular maturational stage in development. Child Languages,Language, Child,Languages, Child
D004519 Education, Special Education of the individual who markedly deviates intellectually, physically, socially, or emotionally from those considered to be normal, thus requiring special instruction. Special Education,Educations, Special,Special Educations
D004522 Educational Status Educational attainment or level of education of an individual. Education Level,Educational Achievement,Educational Attainment,Educational Level,Level of Education,Maternal Education Level,Maternal Educational Attainment,Maternal Educational Level,Paternal Education Level,Paternal Educational Attainment,Paternal Educational Level,Achievement, Educational,Educational Status, Maternal,Educational Status, Paternal,Maternal Educational Status,Paternal Educational Status,Status, Educational,Attainment, Educational,Attainment, Maternal Educational,Attainment, Paternal Educational,Education Level, Maternal,Education Level, Paternal,Education Levels,Educational Achievements,Educational Attainment, Maternal,Educational Attainment, Paternal,Educational Attainments,Educational Level, Maternal,Educational Level, Paternal,Educational Levels,Level, Education,Level, Educational,Level, Maternal Education,Level, Maternal Educational,Level, Paternal Education,Level, Paternal Educational,Levels, Maternal Educational,Maternal Education Levels,Maternal Educational Attainments,Maternal Educational Levels,Paternal Education Levels,Paternal Educational Attainments,Paternal Educational Levels,Status, Maternal Educational,Status, Paternal Educational
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000067877 Autism Spectrum Disorder Wide continuum of associated cognitive and neurobehavioral disorders, including, but not limited to, three core-defining features: impairments in socialization, impairments in verbal and nonverbal communication, and restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviors. (from DSM-V) Autistic Spectrum Disorder,Autism Spectrum Disorders,Autistic Spectrum Disorders,Disorder, Autistic Spectrum

Related Publications

Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
January 2003, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
November 2019, International journal of language & communication disorders,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
January 2020, Clinical linguistics & phonetics,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
October 2023, Language, speech, and hearing services in schools,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
November 2020, Clinical linguistics & phonetics,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
May 2024, The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
January 2009, Gaceta medica de Mexico,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
December 2020, Clinical linguistics & phonetics,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
November 2004, Psychiatrische Praxis,
Susan H Ebbels, and Lisa Wright, and Sally Brockbank, and Caroline Godfrey, and Catherine Harris, and Hannah Leniston, and Kate Neary, and Hilary Nicoll, and Lucy Nicoll, and Jackie Scott, and Nataša Marić
November 2018, Developmental psychobiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!