BACKGROUND Myeloid sarcoma (MS) is a malignant tumor that usually occurs concomitantly with or following acute myeloid leukemia (AML). Cavernomas are benign congenital malformations that are unusual in the spine and exceedingly rare in pure extradural locations. METHODS We report a 73-year-old female with a previous medical history of AML in remission for 3 years who presented with symptoms of low back pain and right lower extremity radiculopathy. A magnetic resonance scan showed an extradural, foraminal lesion centered at the L2 level involving the right L2 nerve root. In view of the history of AML, this lesion was potentially considered MS, a form of AML relapse. Surgery consisting of a right L1 and L2 hemilaminectomy facilitated gross total resection of the purely extradural lesion the proved histologically to be a cavernoma. CONCLUSIONS In patients with a history of leukemia, MS must be considered in the differential diagnosis for any epidural or nerve root lesion that appears following treatment. Although rare, cavernomas must be considered among the differential diagnoses for epidural nerve root lesions in the setting of AML.