Comparison of subgaleal and subdural closed drainage system in the surgical treatment of chronic subdural hematoma. 2015

Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
Department of Neurosurgery, Kayseri Training and Research Hospital, Kayseri, Turkey.

OBJECTIVE One or two burr-hole craniostomies with subgaleal or subdural drainage system and irrigation are the most common methods for surgical treatment of CSDH. The aim of this study is to compare the advantages or disadvantages of these techniques used for CSDH. METHODS Seventy patients were treated by burr-hole subdural drainage or subgaleal drainage system with irrigation. Our patients were classified into two groups according to the operative procedure as follows: Group I, one or two burr-hole craniostomy with subgaleal closed system drainage and irrigation (n=36), Group II, one or two burr-hole craniostomies with subdural closed drainage system and irrigation (n=38). We compared male and female ratios, complication rates, and age distribution between groups. RESULTS There was no remarkable difference between recurrence rates of the two groups. Recurrence rate was 6.25% in Group I and 7.8% in Group II. Subdural empyema occurred in one of the patients in Group II. Symptomatic pneumocephalus did not develop in patients. Four patients were reoperated for recurrence at an average of 12-20 days after the operation with the same methods. CONCLUSIONS Both of the techniques have a higher cure rate and a lower risk of recurrence. However, subgaleal drainage system is relatively less invasive, safe, and technically easy. So it is applicable for aged and higher risk patients.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
March 2024, World neurosurgery,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
April 1999, Rozhledy v chirurgii : mesicnik Ceskoslovenske chirurgicke spolecnosti,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
January 1987, Nihon geka hokan. Archiv fur japanische Chirurgie,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
January 1989, Acta chirurgica Iugoslavica,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
September 1998, Surgical neurology,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
July 2000, Neurosurgery clinics of North America,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
January 2022, Turkish neurosurgery,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
April 2005, Journal of clinical neuroscience : official journal of the Neurosurgical Society of Australasia,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
March 2020, World neurosurgery,
Sukru Oral, and Resul Emin Borklu, and Ahmet Kucuk, and Halil Ulutabanca, and Ahmet Selcuklu
October 2023, Medicine,
Copied contents to your clipboard!