Pediatric radiology malpractice claims - characteristics and comparison to adult radiology claims. 2017

Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
Department of Radiology, Boston Children's Hospital, 300 Longwood Ave., Boston, MA, 02446, USA. micheal.breen@childrens.harvard.edu.

Medical malpractice is the primary method by which people who believe they have suffered an injury in the course of medical care seek compensation in the United States and Canada. An increasing body of research demonstrates that failure to correctly diagnose is the most common allegation made in malpractice claims against radiologists. Since the 1994 survey by the Society of Chairmen of Radiology in Children's Hospitals (SCORCH), no other published studies have specifically examined the frequency or clinical context of malpractice claims against pediatric radiologists or arising from pediatric imaging interpretation. We hypothesize that the frequency, character and outcome of malpractice claims made against pediatric radiologists differ from those seen in general radiology practice. We searched the Controlled Risk Insurance Co. (CRICO) Strategies' Comparative Benchmarking System (CBS), a private repository of approximately 350,000 open and closed medical malpractice claims in the United States, for claims related to pediatric radiology. We further queried these cases for the major allegation, the clinical environment in which the claim arose, the clinical severity of the alleged injury, indemnity paid (if payment was made), primary imaging modality involved (if applicable) and primary International Classification of Diseases, 9th revision (ICD-9) diagnosis underlying the claim. There were a total of 27,056 fully coded claims of medical malpractice in the CBS database in the 5-year period between Jan. 1, 2010, and Dec. 31, 2014. Of these, 1,472 cases (5.4%) involved patients younger than 18 years. Radiology was the primary service responsible for 71/1,472 (4.8%) pediatric cases. There were statistically significant differences in average payout for pediatric radiology claims ($314,671) compared to adult radiology claims ($174,033). The allegations were primarily diagnosis-related in 70% of pediatric radiology claims. The most common imaging modality implicated in pediatric radiology claims was radiography. The highest payouts in pediatric radiology pertained to missed congenital and developmental anomalies (average $1,222,932) such as developmental dysplasia of the hip and congenital central nervous system anomalies. More than half of pediatric radiology claims arose in the ambulatory setting. Pediatric radiology is not immune from claims of medical malpractice and these claims result in high monetary payouts, particularly for missed diagnoses of congenital and developmental anomalies. Our data suggest that efforts to reduce diagnostic error in the outpatient radiology setting, in the interpretation of radiographs, and in the improved diagnosis of fractures and congenital and developmental anomalies would be of particular benefit to the pediatric radiology community.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008318 Malpractice Failure of a professional person, a physician or lawyer, to render proper services through reprehensible ignorance or negligence or through criminal intent, especially when injury or loss follows. (Random House Unabridged Dictionary, 2d ed) Professional Negligence,Negligence,Negligence, Professional,Professional Negligences
D010372 Pediatrics A medical specialty concerned with maintaining health and providing medical care to children from birth to adolescence.
D011872 Radiology Department, Hospital Hospital department which is responsible for the administration and provision of x-ray diagnostic and therapeutic services. Hospital Radiology Department,X-Ray Departments,Department, Hospital Radiology,Department, X-Ray,Departments, Hospital Radiology,Departments, X-Ray,Radiology Departments, Hospital,X-Ray Department,Department, X Ray,Departments, X Ray,Hospital Radiology Departments,X Ray Department,X Ray Departments
D003951 Diagnostic Errors Incorrect or incomplete diagnoses following clinical or technical diagnostic procedures. Diagnostic Blind Spots,Errors, Diagnostic,Misdiagnosis,Blind Spot, Diagnostic,Blind Spots, Diagnostic,Diagnostic Blind Spot,Diagnostic Error,Error, Diagnostic,Misdiagnoses
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D014481 United States A country in NORTH AMERICA between CANADA and MEXICO.
D016365 Liability, Legal Accountability and responsibility to another, enforceable by civil or criminal sanctions. Institutional Liability,Personal Liability,Professional Liability,Legal Liability,Medical Liability,Torts,Institutional Liabilities,Legal Liabilities,Liabilities, Institutional,Liabilities, Legal,Liabilities, Medical,Liabilities, Personal,Liabilities, Professional,Liability, Institutional,Liability, Medical,Liability, Personal,Liability, Professional,Medical Liabilities,Personal Liabilities,Professional Liabilities,Tort
D035881 Compensation and Redress Payment, or other means of making amends, for a wrong or injury. Compensation,Redress and Compensation

Related Publications

Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
March 1993, Anesthesiology,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
April 2013, La Radiologia medica,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
March 2016, Journal of pediatric orthopedics,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
February 2016, Journal of the American College of Radiology : JACR,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
January 1989, Radiology,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
June 1997, Hospitals & health networks,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
January 2016, The New England journal of medicine,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
February 2019, Child's nervous system : ChNS : official journal of the International Society for Pediatric Neurosurgery,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
July 1987, Radiology,
Micheál A Breen, and Kathy Dwyer, and Winnie Yu-Moe, and George A Taylor
March 2008, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!