Ask versus tell: Potential confusion when child witnesses are questioned about conversations. 2017

Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
School of Criminology & Criminal Justice, Arizona State University.

Children's potential confusion between "ask" and "tell" can lead to misunderstandings when child witnesses are asked to report prior conversations. The verbs distinguish both between interrogating and informing, and between requesting and commanding. Children's understanding was examined using both field (Study 1) and laboratory methods (Studies 2-4). Study 1 examined 100 5- to 12-year-olds' trial testimony in child sexual abuse cases, and found that potentially ambiguous use of ask and tell was common, typically found in yes-no questions that elicited unelaborated answers, and virtually never clarified by attorneys or child witnesses. Studies 2 to 4 examined 345 maltreated 6- to 11-year-olds' understanding of ask and tell. The results suggest that children initially comprehend telling as saying, and thus believed that asking is a form of telling. As such, they often endorsed asking as telling when asked yes-no questions, but distinguished between asking and telling when explicitly asked to choose. Their performance was impaired by movement between different use of the words. Child witnesses' characterization of their conversations can easily be misconstrued by the way in which they are questioned, leading questioners to misinterpret whether they were coached by disclosure recipients or coerced by abuse suspects. (PsycINFO Database Record

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D002648 Child A person 6 to 12 years of age. An individual 2 to 5 years old is CHILD, PRESCHOOL. Children
D002650 Child Abuse, Sexual Sexual maltreatment of the child or minor. Child Molestation,Child Molestation, Sexual,Molestation, Sexual, Child,Sexual Abuse of Child,Sexual Abuse, Child,Abuse, Child Sexual,Child Sexual Abuse,Molestation, Child,Sexual Child Abuse,Sexual Child Molestation
D002657 Child Development The continuous sequential physiological and psychological maturing of an individual from birth up to but not including ADOLESCENCE. Infant Development,Development, Child,Development, Infant
D002675 Child, Preschool A child between the ages of 2 and 5. Children, Preschool,Preschool Child,Preschool Children
D003142 Communication The exchange or transmission of ideas, attitudes, or beliefs between individuals or groups. Miscommunication,Misinformation,Social Communication,Communication Programs,Communications Personnel,Personal Communication,Communication Program,Communication, Personal,Communication, Social,Communications, Social,Miscommunications,Misinformations,Personnel, Communications,Program, Communication,Programs, Communication,Social Communications
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D032882 Comprehension The act or fact of grasping the meaning, nature, or importance of; understanding. (American Heritage Dictionary, 4th ed) Includes understanding by a patient or research subject of information disclosed orally or in writing. Readability,Understanding

Related Publications

Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
July 2022, Journal of interpersonal violence,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
June 1996, JAMA,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
February 2015, Family medicine,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
December 2021, Journal of patient safety,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
November 2012, BMJ (Clinical research ed.),
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
May 2017, Psychology, public policy, and law : an official law review of the University of Arizona College of Law and the University of Miami School of Law,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
February 2021, Archives of disease in childhood,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
August 2017, Archives of disease in childhood. Education and practice edition,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
January 2015, Journal of neonatal surgery,
Stacia N Stolzenberg, and Kelly McWilliams, and Thomas D Lyon
December 2006, Qualitative health research,
Copied contents to your clipboard!