Terlipressin versus other vasoactive drugs for hepatorenal syndrome. 2017

Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Odense University Hospital, Sdr. Boulevard 29, Odense C, Denmark, 5000.

Hepatorenal syndrome is defined as severe renal failure occurring in people with cirrhosis and ascites. Systematic reviews of randomised clinical trials found that, compared with placebo, terlipressin may reduce mortality and improve renal function in people with hepatorenal syndrome, but we need current evidence from systematic reviews on the benefits and harms of terlipressin versus other vasoactive drugs. To evaluate the beneficial and harmful effects of terlipressin versus other vasoactive drugs for people with hepatorenal syndrome. We searched The Cochrane Hepato-Biliary Group Controlled Trials Register, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, and Science Citation Index Expanded; conducted manual searches of references in relevant literature; and wrote to experts and pharmaceutical companies (date of last search November 2016). Randomised clinical trials comparing terlipressin versus any other type of vasoactive drugs for hepatorenal syndrome. We allowed albumin and other cointerventions if provided equally in the comparison groups. Three authors independently extracted data. The primary outcomes were mortality, hepatorenal syndrome (persistent hepatorenal syndrome despite treatment), and serious adverse events. We conducted meta-analyses and present the results as risk ratios (RR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). We performed sensitivity, subgroup, and Trial Sequential Analyses and evaluated bias control based on the Cochrane Hepato-Biliary Group domains. We included 10 randomised clinical trials with 474 participants. The trials compared terlipressin versus noradrenaline (seven trials), octreotide (one trial), midodrine and octreotide (one trial), or dopamine (one trial). All participants in both groups received albumin as cointervention. We classified two trials at low risk of bias and eight trials at high risk of bias in the assessment of mortality and all trials at high risk of bias for remaining outcomes. In five trials, investigators specifically stated that they did not receive funding from for-profit organisations. We had no information about the funding source from the remaining five trials.Terlipressin was not superior or inferior compared with other vasoactive drugs in regard to mortality when including the two trials with a low risk of bias (RR 0.92, 95% CI 0.63 to 1.36; 94 participants, very low quality evidence) or when including all 10 trials (RR 0.96, 95% CI 0.88 to 1.06; 474 participants; I² = 0%; very low quality evidence). One meta-analysis including nine trials suggested a beneficial effect of terlipressin on hepatorenal syndrome (RR 0.79, 95% CI 0.63 to 0.99; 394 participants; I² = 26%; very low quality evidence). Due to the high mortality of hepatorenal syndrome, the registration of other serious adverse events is uncertain, but comparing terlipressin and other vasoactive drugs we found no significant difference (RR 0.96, 95% CI 0.88 to 1.06; 474 participants; I² = 0%; very low quality evidence). Several trials did not report systematically of adverse events, but terlipressin seemed to increase the risks of diarrhoea or abdominal pain, or both (RR 3.50, 95% CI 1.19 to 10.27; 221 participants; 5 trials, I² = 0%). However, Trial Sequential Analyses found insufficient evidence to support or refute any differences between interventions for all outcomes. Considering reversal of hepatorenal syndrome, subgroup analyses on the type of other vasoactive drugs found that terlipressin was superior compared with midodrine and octreotide (RR 0.47, 95% CI 0.30 to 0.72) or octreotide alone (RR 0.56, 95% CI 0.33 to 0.96), but each subgroup only included one small trial. None of the remaining subgroup or sensitivity analyses found differences between terlipressin and other vasoactive drugs. We downgraded the evidence to very low quality because of the high risk of bias, imprecision, and the results of the Trial Sequential Analyses. This review found insufficient evidence to support or refute beneficial or harmful effects of terlipressin and albumin versus other vasoactive drugs and albumin. Additional research is needed to evaluate if clinically meaningful differences exist between interventions.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008236 Lypressin The porcine antidiuretic hormone (VASOPRESSINS). It is a cyclic nonapeptide that differs from ARG-VASOPRESSIN by one amino acid, containing a LYSINE at residue 8 instead of an ARGININE. Lys-vasopressin is used to treat DIABETES INSIPIDUS or to improve vasomotor tone and BLOOD PRESSURE. Lysine Vasopressin,Vasopressin, Lysine,8-Lysine Vasopressin,Diapid,Lys-Vasopressin,Lysyl Vasopressin,Postacton,8 Lysine Vasopressin,Lys Vasopressin,Vasopressin, 8-Lysine,Vasopressin, Lysyl
D008879 Midodrine An ethanolamine derivative that is an adrenergic alpha-1 agonist. It is used as a vasoconstrictor agent in the treatment of HYPOTENSION. Amatine,Gutron,Midodrin,Midodrine Hydrochloride,Midodrine Monohydrochloride,Midon,ProAmatine,ST-1085,Monohydrochloride, Midodrine,ST 1085,ST1085
D009638 Norepinephrine Precursor of epinephrine that is secreted by the ADRENAL MEDULLA and is a widespread central and autonomic neurotransmitter. Norepinephrine is the principal transmitter of most postganglionic sympathetic fibers, and of the diffuse projection system in the brain that arises from the LOCUS CERULEUS. It is also found in plants and is used pharmacologically as a sympathomimetic. Levarterenol,Levonorepinephrine,Noradrenaline,Arterenol,Levonor,Levophed,Levophed Bitartrate,Noradrenaline Bitartrate,Noradrénaline tartrate renaudin,Norepinephrin d-Tartrate (1:1),Norepinephrine Bitartrate,Norepinephrine Hydrochloride,Norepinephrine Hydrochloride, (+)-Isomer,Norepinephrine Hydrochloride, (+,-)-Isomer,Norepinephrine d-Tartrate (1:1),Norepinephrine l-Tartrate (1:1),Norepinephrine l-Tartrate (1:1), (+,-)-Isomer,Norepinephrine l-Tartrate (1:1), Monohydrate,Norepinephrine l-Tartrate (1:1), Monohydrate, (+)-Isomer,Norepinephrine l-Tartrate (1:2),Norepinephrine l-Tartrate, (+)-Isomer,Norepinephrine, (+)-Isomer,Norepinephrine, (+,-)-Isomer
D004298 Dopamine One of the catecholamine NEUROTRANSMITTERS in the brain. It is derived from TYROSINE and is the precursor to NOREPINEPHRINE and EPINEPHRINE. Dopamine is a major transmitter in the extrapyramidal system of the brain, and important in regulating movement. A family of receptors (RECEPTORS, DOPAMINE) mediate its action. Hydroxytyramine,3,4-Dihydroxyphenethylamine,4-(2-Aminoethyl)-1,2-benzenediol,Dopamine Hydrochloride,Intropin,3,4 Dihydroxyphenethylamine,Hydrochloride, Dopamine
D006530 Hepatorenal Syndrome Functional KIDNEY FAILURE in patients with liver disease, usually LIVER CIRRHOSIS or portal hypertension (HYPERTENSION, PORTAL), and in the absence of intrinsic renal disease or kidney abnormality. It is characterized by intense renal vasculature constriction, reduced renal blood flow, OLIGURIA, and sodium retention. Syndrome, Hepatorenal
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000077585 Terlipressin An inactive peptide prodrug that is slowly converted in the body to lypressin. It is used to control bleeding of ESOPHAGEAL VARICES and for the treatment of HEPATORENAL SYNDROME. Glipressin,Gly-Gly-Gly-8-Lys-vasopressin,Glycylpressin,Glypressin,N-(alpha)-glycyl-glycyl-glycyl-8-lysine vasopressin,Remestyp,TGLVP,Terlypressin,Triglycyl Lysine Vasopressin,Triglycyl-(8-lysine)vasopressin,Triglycylvasopressin,Vasopressin, tri-Gly-8-Lys-,Gly Gly Gly 8 Lys vasopressin,tri-Gly-8-Lys- Vasopressin
D000959 Antihypertensive Agents Drugs used in the treatment of acute or chronic vascular HYPERTENSION regardless of pharmacological mechanism. Among the antihypertensive agents are DIURETICS; (especially DIURETICS, THIAZIDE); ADRENERGIC BETA-ANTAGONISTS; ADRENERGIC ALPHA-ANTAGONISTS; ANGIOTENSIN-CONVERTING ENZYME INHIBITORS; CALCIUM CHANNEL BLOCKERS; GANGLIONIC BLOCKERS; and VASODILATOR AGENTS. Anti-Hypertensive,Anti-Hypertensive Agent,Anti-Hypertensive Drug,Antihypertensive,Antihypertensive Agent,Antihypertensive Drug,Anti-Hypertensive Agents,Anti-Hypertensive Drugs,Anti-Hypertensives,Antihypertensive Drugs,Antihypertensives,Agent, Anti-Hypertensive,Agent, Antihypertensive,Agents, Anti-Hypertensive,Agents, Antihypertensive,Anti Hypertensive,Anti Hypertensive Agent,Anti Hypertensive Agents,Anti Hypertensive Drug,Anti Hypertensive Drugs,Anti Hypertensives,Drug, Anti-Hypertensive,Drug, Antihypertensive,Drugs, Anti-Hypertensive,Drugs, Antihypertensive
D014662 Vasoconstrictor Agents Drugs used to cause constriction of the blood vessels. Vasoactive Agonist,Vasoactive Agonists,Vasoconstrictor,Vasoconstrictor Agent,Vasoconstrictor Drug,Vasopressor Agent,Vasopressor Agents,Vasoconstrictor Drugs,Vasoconstrictors,Agent, Vasoconstrictor,Agent, Vasopressor,Agents, Vasoconstrictor,Agents, Vasopressor,Agonist, Vasoactive,Agonists, Vasoactive,Drug, Vasoconstrictor,Drugs, Vasoconstrictor
D015282 Octreotide A potent, long-acting synthetic SOMATOSTATIN octapeptide analog that inhibits secretion of GROWTH HORMONE and is used to treat hormone-secreting tumors; DIABETES MELLITUS; HYPOTENSION, ORTHOSTATIC; HYPERINSULINISM; hypergastrinemia; and small bowel fistula. Octreotide Acetate,Compound 201-995,Octreotide Acetate Salt,SAN 201-995,SM 201-995,SMS 201-995,Sandostatin,Sandostatine,Sandoz 201-995,Compound 201 995,Compound 201995,SAN 201 995,SAN 201995,SM 201 995,SM 201995,SMS 201 995,SMS 201995,Sandoz 201 995,Sandoz 201995

Related Publications

Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
September 2012, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
October 2006, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
May 2024, Current opinion in gastroenterology,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
March 2023, The Medical letter on drugs and therapeutics,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
March 2011, The Annals of pharmacotherapy,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
August 2015, Medwave,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
August 2020, Digestive diseases and sciences,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
April 2003, Hepatology (Baltimore, Md.),
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
October 2007, Gastroenterology & hepatology,
Mads Israelsen, and Aleksander Krag, and Andrew S Allegretti, and Manol Jovani, and Alison H Goldin, and Rachel W Winter, and Lise Lotte Gluud
February 2023, The lancet. Gastroenterology & hepatology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!