Interventions for Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis. 2017

Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health & Immunology and Microbiology, Rey Juan Carlos University, Avda. Atenas s/n, Alcorcón, Madrid, Spain, 28922.

Cutaneous leishmaniasis, caused by a parasitic infection, is considered one of the most serious skin diseases in many low- and middle-income countries. Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis (OWCL) is caused by species found in Africa, Asia, the Middle East, the Mediterranean, and India. The most commonly prescribed treatments are antimonials, but other drugs have been used with varying success. As OWCL tends to heal spontaneously, it is necessary to justify the use of systemic and topical treatments. This is an update of a Cochrane Review first published in 2008. To assess the effects of therapeutic interventions for the localised form of Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis. We updated our searches of the following databases to November 2016: the Cochrane Skin Specialised Register, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, and LILACS. We also searched five trials registers and checked the reference lists of included studies for further references to relevant randomised controlled trials (RCTs). We wrote to national programme managers, general co-ordinators, directors, clinicians, WHO-EMRO regional officers of endemic countries, pharmaceutical companies, tropical medicine centres, and authors of relevant papers for further information about relevant unpublished and ongoing trials. We undertook a separate search for adverse effects of interventions for Old World cutaneous leishmaniasis in September 2015 using MEDLINE. Randomised controlled trials of either single or combination treatments in immunocompetent people with OWCL confirmed by smear, histology, culture, or polymerase chain reaction. The comparators were either no treatment, placebo/vehicle, and/or another active compound. Two review authors independently assessed trials for inclusion and risk of bias and extracted data. We only synthesised data when we were able to identify at least two studies investigating similar treatments and reporting data amenable to pooling. We also recorded data about adverse effects from the corresponding search. We included 89 studies (of which 40 were new to this update) in 10,583 people with OWCL. The studies included were conducted mainly in the Far or Middle East at regional hospitals, local healthcare clinics, and skin disease research centres. Women accounted for 41.5% of the participants (range: 23% to 80%). The overall mean age of participants was 25 years (range 12 to 56). Most studies lasted between two to six months, with the longest lasting two years; average duration was four months. Most studies were at unclear or high risk for most bias domains. A lack of blinding and reporting bias were present in almost 40% of studies. Two trials were at low risk of bias for all domains. Trials reported the causative species poorly.Here we provide results for the two main comparisons identified: itraconazole (200 mg for six to eight weeks) versus placebo; and paromomycin ointment (15% plus 10% urea, twice daily for 14 days) versus vehicle.In the comparison of oral itraconazole versus placebo, at 2.5 months' follow up, 85/125 participants in the itraconazole group achieved complete cure compared to 54/119 in the placebo group (RR 3.70, 95% CI 0.35 to 38.99; 3 studies; 244 participants). In one study, microbiological or histopathological cure of skin lesions only occurred in the itraconazole group after a mean follow-up of 2.5 months (RR 17.00, 95% CI 0.47 to 612.21; 20 participants). However, although the analyses favour oral itraconazole for these outcomes, we cannot be confident in the results due to the very low certainty evidence. More side effects of mild abdominal pain and nausea (RR 2.36, 95% CI 0.74 to 7.47; 3 studies; 204 participants) and mild abnormal liver function (RR 3.08, 95% CI 0.53 to 17.98; 3 studies; 84 participants) occurred in the itraconazole group (as well as reports of headaches and dizziness), compared with the placebo group, but again we rated the certainty of evidence as very low so are unsure of the results.When comparing paromomycin with vehicle, there was no difference in the number of participants who achieved complete cure (RR of 1.00, 95% CI 0.86, 1.17; 383 participants, 2 studies) and microbiological or histopathological cure of skin lesions after a mean follow-up of 2.5 months (RR 1.03, CI 0.88 to 1.20; 383 participants, 2 studies), but the paromomycin group had more skin/local reactions (such as inflammation, vesiculation, pain, redness, or itch) (RR 1.42, 95% CI 0.67 to 3.01; 4 studies; 713 participants). For all of these outcomes, the certainty of evidence was very low, meaning we are unsure about these results.Trial authors did not report the percentage of lesions cured after the end of treatment or speed of healing for either of these key comparisons. There was very low-certainty evidence to support the effectiveness of itraconazole and paromomycin ointment for OWCL in terms of cure (i.e. microbiological or histopathological cure and percentage of participants completely cured). Both of these interventions incited more adverse effects, which were mild in nature, than their comparisons, but we could draw no conclusions regarding safety due to the very low certainty of the evidence for this outcome.We downgraded the key outcomes in these two comparisons due to high risk of bias, inconsistency between the results, and imprecision. There is a need for large, well-designed international studies that evaluate long-term effects of current therapies and enable a reliable conclusion about treatments. Future trials should specify the species of leishmaniasis; trials on types caused by Leishmania infantum, L aethiopica, andL donovani are lacking. Research into the effects of treating women of childbearing age, children, people with comorbid conditions, and those who are immunocompromised would also be helpful.It was difficult to evaluate the overall efficacy of any of the numerous treatments due to the variable treatment regimens examined and because RCTs evaluated different Leishmania species and took place in different geographical areas. Some outcomes we looked for but did not find were degree of functional and aesthetic impairment, change in ability to detect Leishmania, quality of life, and emergence of resistance. There were only limited data on prevention of scarring.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007895 Leishmania tropica A parasitic hemoflagellate of the subgenus Leishmania leishmania that infects humans and rodents. This taxonomic complex includes species which cause a disease called Oriental sore which is a form of cutaneous leishmaniasis (LEISHMANIASIS, CUTANEOUS) of the Old World. Leishmania (Leishmania) tropica,Leishmania tropica minor,Leishmania leishmania tropica,Leishmania tropicas
D010303 Paromomycin An aminoglycoside antibacterial and antiprotozoal agent produced by species of STREPTOMYCES. Aminosidine,Catenulin,Estomycin,Hydroxymycin,Neomycin E,Gabbromycin,Humatin,Paramomycin,Paromomycin I,Paromomycin Phosphate,Paromomycin Sulfate,Paromomycin Sulfate (1:1),Paromomycin Sulfate (2:5),Paromomycin, beta-D-Glucopyranosyl-Isomer,Paromomycin, beta D Glucopyranosyl Isomer,beta-D-Glucopyranosyl-Isomer Paromomycin
D010778 Photochemotherapy Therapy using oral or topical photosensitizing agents with subsequent exposure to light. Blue Light Photodynamic Therapy,Photodynamic Therapy,Red Light PDT,Red Light Photodynamic Therapy,Therapy, Photodynamic,Light PDT, Red,PDT, Red Light,Photochemotherapies,Photodynamic Therapies,Therapies, Photodynamic
D006358 Hot Temperature Presence of warmth or heat or a temperature notably higher than an accustomed norm. Heat,Hot Temperatures,Temperature, Hot,Temperatures, Hot
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000529 Complementary Therapies Therapeutic practices which are not currently considered an integral part of conventional allopathic medical practice. They may lack biomedical explanations but as they become better researched some (PHYSICAL THERAPY MODALITIES; DIET; ACUPUNCTURE) become widely accepted whereas others (humors, radium therapy) quietly fade away, yet are important historical footnotes. Therapies are termed as Complementary when used in addition to conventional treatments and as Alternative when used instead of conventional treatment. Alternative Medicine,Complementary Medicine,Medicine, Alternative,Medicine, Complementary,Alternative Therapies,Therapy, Alternative,Therapy, Complementary,Therapies, Alternative,Therapies, Complementary
D000818 Animals Unicellular or multicellular, heterotrophic organisms, that have sensation and the power of voluntary movement. Under the older five kingdom paradigm, Animalia was one of the kingdoms. Under the modern three domain model, Animalia represents one of the many groups in the domain EUKARYOTA. Animal,Metazoa,Animalia
D000890 Anti-Infective Agents Substances that prevent infectious agents or organisms from spreading or kill infectious agents in order to prevent the spread of infection. Anti-Infective Agent,Anti-Microbial Agent,Antimicrobial Agent,Microbicide,Microbicides,Anti-Microbial Agents,Antiinfective Agents,Antimicrobial Agents,Agent, Anti-Infective,Agent, Anti-Microbial,Agent, Antimicrobial,Agents, Anti-Infective,Agents, Anti-Microbial,Agents, Antiinfective,Agents, Antimicrobial,Anti Infective Agent,Anti Infective Agents,Anti Microbial Agent,Anti Microbial Agents
D000981 Antiprotozoal Agents Substances that are destructive to protozoans. Schizonticides,Agents, Antiprotozoal
D016032 Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic Works about clinical trials that involve at least one test treatment and one control treatment, concurrent enrollment and follow-up of the test- and control-treated groups, and in which the treatments to be administered are selected by a random process, such as the use of a random-numbers table. Clinical Trials, Randomized,Controlled Clinical Trials, Randomized,Trials, Randomized Clinical

Related Publications

Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
October 2008, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
March 1997, International journal of dermatology,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
December 2012, Dermatology online journal,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
May 2013, Revue medicale suisse,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
September 1995, Pediatric dermatology,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
November 2013, Drugs,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
November 2017, Deutsches Arzteblatt international,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
February 2003, Skin therapy letter,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
January 1996, Clinics in dermatology,
Julio Heras-Mosteiro, and Begoña Monge-Maillo, and Mariona Pinart, and Patricia Lopez Pereira, and Ludovic Reveiz, and Emely Garcia-Carrasco, and Pedro Campuzano Cuadrado, and Ana Royuela, and Irene Mendez Roman, and Rogelio López-Vélez
June 1988, The British journal of dermatology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!