Ensemble landmarking of 3D facial surface scans. 2018

Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
Department of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, Special Dental Care, and Orthodontics, Erasmus MC University Medical Center Rotterdam, Rotterdam, 3015 CE, The Netherlands.

Landmarking of 3D facial surface scans is an important analysis step in medical and biological applications, such as genome-wide association studies (GWAS). Manual landmarking is often employed with considerable cost and rater dependent variability. Landmarking automatically with minimal training is therefore desirable. We apply statistical ensemble methods to improve automated landmarking of 3D facial surface scans. Base landmarking algorithms using features derived from 3D surface scans are combined using either bagging or stacking. A focus is on low training complexity of maximal 40 training samples with template based landmarking algorithms that have proved successful in such applications. Additionally, we use correlations between landmark coordinates by introducing a search strategy guided by principal components (PCs) of training landmarks. We found that bagging has no useful impact, while stacking strongly improves accuracy to an average error of 1.7 mm across all 21 landmarks in this study, a 22% improvement as compared to a previous, comparable algorithm. Heritability estimates in twin pairs also show improvements when using facial distances from landmarks. Ensemble methods allow improvement of automatic, accurate landmarking of 3D facial images with minimal training which is advantageous in large cohort studies for GWAS and when landmarking needs change or data quality varies.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007091 Image Processing, Computer-Assisted A technique of inputting two-dimensional or three-dimensional images into a computer and then enhancing or analyzing the imagery into a form that is more useful to the human observer. Biomedical Image Processing,Computer-Assisted Image Processing,Digital Image Processing,Image Analysis, Computer-Assisted,Image Reconstruction,Medical Image Processing,Analysis, Computer-Assisted Image,Computer-Assisted Image Analysis,Computer Assisted Image Analysis,Computer Assisted Image Processing,Computer-Assisted Image Analyses,Image Analyses, Computer-Assisted,Image Analysis, Computer Assisted,Image Processing, Biomedical,Image Processing, Computer Assisted,Image Processing, Digital,Image Processing, Medical,Image Processings, Medical,Image Reconstructions,Medical Image Processings,Processing, Biomedical Image,Processing, Digital Image,Processing, Medical Image,Processings, Digital Image,Processings, Medical Image,Reconstruction, Image,Reconstructions, Image
D005145 Face The anterior portion of the head that includes the skin, muscles, and structures of the forehead, eyes, nose, mouth, cheeks, and jaw. Faces
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000465 Algorithms A procedure consisting of a sequence of algebraic formulas and/or logical steps to calculate or determine a given task. Algorithm
D015203 Reproducibility of Results The statistical reproducibility of measurements (often in a clinical context), including the testing of instrumentation or techniques to obtain reproducible results. The concept includes reproducibility of physiological measurements, which may be used to develop rules to assess probability or prognosis, or response to a stimulus; reproducibility of occurrence of a condition; and reproducibility of experimental results. Reliability and Validity,Reliability of Result,Reproducibility Of Result,Reproducibility of Finding,Validity of Result,Validity of Results,Face Validity,Reliability (Epidemiology),Reliability of Results,Reproducibility of Findings,Test-Retest Reliability,Validity (Epidemiology),Finding Reproducibilities,Finding Reproducibility,Of Result, Reproducibility,Of Results, Reproducibility,Reliabilities, Test-Retest,Reliability, Test-Retest,Result Reliabilities,Result Reliability,Result Validities,Result Validity,Result, Reproducibility Of,Results, Reproducibility Of,Test Retest Reliability,Validity and Reliability,Validity, Face
D015415 Biomarkers Measurable and quantifiable biological parameters (e.g., specific enzyme concentration, specific hormone concentration, specific gene phenotype distribution in a population, presence of biological substances) which serve as indices for health- and physiology-related assessments, such as disease risk, psychiatric disorders, ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE and its effects, disease diagnosis; METABOLIC PROCESSES; SUBSTANCE ABUSE; PREGNANCY; cell line development; EPIDEMIOLOGIC STUDIES; etc. Biochemical Markers,Biological Markers,Biomarker,Clinical Markers,Immunologic Markers,Laboratory Markers,Markers, Biochemical,Markers, Biological,Markers, Clinical,Markers, Immunologic,Markers, Laboratory,Markers, Serum,Markers, Surrogate,Markers, Viral,Serum Markers,Surrogate Markers,Viral Markers,Biochemical Marker,Biologic Marker,Biologic Markers,Clinical Marker,Immune Marker,Immune Markers,Immunologic Marker,Laboratory Marker,Marker, Biochemical,Marker, Biological,Marker, Clinical,Marker, Immunologic,Marker, Laboratory,Marker, Serum,Marker, Surrogate,Serum Marker,Surrogate End Point,Surrogate End Points,Surrogate Endpoint,Surrogate Endpoints,Surrogate Marker,Viral Marker,Biological Marker,End Point, Surrogate,End Points, Surrogate,Endpoint, Surrogate,Endpoints, Surrogate,Marker, Biologic,Marker, Immune,Marker, Viral,Markers, Biologic,Markers, Immune
D021621 Imaging, Three-Dimensional The process of generating three-dimensional images by electronic, photographic, or other methods. For example, three-dimensional images can be generated by assembling multiple tomographic images with the aid of a computer, while photographic 3-D images (HOLOGRAPHY) can be made by exposing film to the interference pattern created when two laser light sources shine on an object. Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional Imaging,Imaging, Three-Dimensional, Computer Assisted,3-D Image,3-D Imaging,Computer-Generated 3D Imaging,Three-Dimensional Image,Three-Dimensional Imaging, Computer Generated,3 D Image,3 D Imaging,3-D Images,3-D Imagings,3D Imaging, Computer-Generated,3D Imagings, Computer-Generated,Computer Assisted Three Dimensional Imaging,Computer Generated 3D Imaging,Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional Imagings,Computer-Generated 3D Imagings,Image, 3-D,Image, Three-Dimensional,Images, 3-D,Images, Three-Dimensional,Imaging, 3-D,Imaging, Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional,Imaging, Computer-Generated 3D,Imaging, Three Dimensional,Imagings, 3-D,Imagings, Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional,Imagings, Computer-Generated 3D,Imagings, Three-Dimensional,Three Dimensional Image,Three Dimensional Imaging, Computer Generated,Three-Dimensional Images,Three-Dimensional Imaging,Three-Dimensional Imaging, Computer-Assisted,Three-Dimensional Imagings,Three-Dimensional Imagings, Computer-Assisted

Related Publications

Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
June 2020, Sensors (Basel, Switzerland),
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
April 2017, Journal of anatomy,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
March 2024, Scientific reports,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
January 1997, Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Sklodowska. Sectio D: Medicina,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
February 2012, IEEE transactions on image processing : a publication of the IEEE Signal Processing Society,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
March 2016, Journal of orofacial orthopedics = Fortschritte der Kieferorthopadie : Organ/official journal Deutsche Gesellschaft fur Kieferorthopadie,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
June 2023, 3D printing in medicine,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
August 2020, Pediatric research,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
May 2023, American journal of medical genetics. Part A,
Markus A de Jong, and Pirro Hysi, and Tim Spector, and Wiro Niessen, and Maarten J Koudstaal, and Eppo B Wolvius, and Manfred Kayser, and Stefan Böhringer
January 2017, PloS one,
Copied contents to your clipboard!