Reproducibility assessment of Delaire cephalometric analysis using reconstructions from computed tomography. 2020

A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
Assistance publique - Hôpitaux de Paris, Hôpital Pitié-Salpêtrière, service de chirurgie maxillo-faciale et stomatologie, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Sorbonne Universités, 75013 Paris, France. Electronic address: alexandre.debelmas@hotmail.fr.

BACKGROUND Cephalometry performed on sagittal teleradiographic X-rays is commonly used for the planification of orthognathic procedures. Tomographic imaging techniques (computer tomography or cone-beam computer tomography) are more and more prescribed for the assessment of complex occlusofacial anomalies. In this study, we intended to evaluate if teleradiographic X-rays reconstructed from computer tomography (CT) can be used to trace reliable cephalometric analyses. We assessed the inter- and intra-observer reproducibility of a simplified Delaire analysis (Top 12), one of the numerous common cephalometric analyses, performed with the Delaire Evolution software on three sets of X-rays: (1) conventional cephalometric X-rays, (2) 2D reconstructions obtained from the CT scans of the same patients and (3) 2D reconstructions obtained from CT scans of dry skulls without a cervical spine (anthropological material). Our primary goal was to assess X-rays reconstructed from tomographies as an alternative for conventional cephalometric X-rays. Our secondary goal was to assess whether computerized cephalometric analysis was a reproducible technique, both on clinical and anthropological material. METHODS We included 10 consecutive adult patients admitted for orthodontic assessment who had benefited from both lateral cephalometric X-rays and from CT-scans. We also included 10 CT-scans from adult dry skulls without a cervical spine, from the collections of the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle (Musée de l'Homme, Paris, France). Cephalometric X-rays were reconstructed from CT-scans of both patients and dry skulls using Carestream® (Carestream Health inc., New York, USA). Simplified Delaire analyses (Top12) were conducted by 2 observers using the Delaire Evolution software (JDel, Nantes, France), on the 3 sets of cephalometric X-rays: (1) 10 standard cephalometric X-rays from the orthodontic patients, (2) 10 reconstructed cephalometric X-rays from the CT scans of the orthodontic patients and (3) 10 reconstructed cephalometric X-rays from the CT scans of the dry skulls. A standard statistical assessment of reproducibility was conducted using correlation coefficients. RESULTS We found good inter- and intra-observer reproducibility for standard cephalometric X-rays and reconstructed cephalometric X-rays (Intraclass Correlation Coeficient > 0.75). We did not find any difference for angle measures between the standard cephalometric X-rays and the reconstructed cephalometric X-rays for the group of orthodontic patients (P > 0.05). Delaire cephalometric analysis was not reproducible for cephalometric X-rays without a cervical spine, that is for cephalometric X-rays reconstructed from the CT-scans of dry skulls. CONCLUSIONS Delaire computerized simplified Top12 analysis was reproducible for lateral cephalometric X-rays and for reconstructions obtained from CT scans with similar angle measures for a given patient. This analysis does not seem to be reliable for dry skulls without upper cervical spine. This study uses the example of one particular computerized cephalometric analysis in order to show that cephalometric analyses can be performed on lateral reconstructed cephalometric X-rays obtained from CT scans.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D002508 Cephalometry The measurement of the dimensions of the HEAD. Craniometry
D005602 France A country in western Europe bordered by the Atlantic Ocean, the English Channel, the Mediterranean Sea, and the countries of Belgium, Germany, Italy, Spain, Switzerland, the principalities of Andorra and Monaco, and by the duchy of Luxembourg. Its capital is Paris. Corsica,Saint Pierre and Miquelon,Miquelon and Saint Pierre,Miquelon and St. Pierre,St. Pierre and Miquelon
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D014057 Tomography, X-Ray Computed Tomography using x-ray transmission and a computer algorithm to reconstruct the image. CAT Scan, X-Ray,CT Scan, X-Ray,Cine-CT,Computerized Tomography, X-Ray,Electron Beam Computed Tomography,Tomodensitometry,Tomography, Transmission Computed,X-Ray Tomography, Computed,CAT Scan, X Ray,CT X Ray,Computed Tomography, X-Ray,Computed X Ray Tomography,Computerized Tomography, X Ray,Electron Beam Tomography,Tomography, X Ray Computed,Tomography, X-Ray Computer Assisted,Tomography, X-Ray Computerized,Tomography, X-Ray Computerized Axial,Tomography, Xray Computed,X Ray Computerized Tomography,X Ray Tomography, Computed,X-Ray Computer Assisted Tomography,X-Ray Computerized Axial Tomography,Beam Tomography, Electron,CAT Scans, X-Ray,CT Scan, X Ray,CT Scans, X-Ray,CT X Rays,Cine CT,Computed Tomography, Transmission,Computed Tomography, X Ray,Computed Tomography, Xray,Computed X-Ray Tomography,Scan, X-Ray CAT,Scan, X-Ray CT,Scans, X-Ray CAT,Scans, X-Ray CT,Tomographies, Computed X-Ray,Tomography, Computed X-Ray,Tomography, Electron Beam,Tomography, X Ray Computer Assisted,Tomography, X Ray Computerized,Tomography, X Ray Computerized Axial,Transmission Computed Tomography,X Ray Computer Assisted Tomography,X Ray Computerized Axial Tomography,X Ray, CT,X Rays, CT,X-Ray CAT Scan,X-Ray CAT Scans,X-Ray CT Scan,X-Ray CT Scans,X-Ray Computed Tomography,X-Ray Computerized Tomography,Xray Computed Tomography
D015203 Reproducibility of Results The statistical reproducibility of measurements (often in a clinical context), including the testing of instrumentation or techniques to obtain reproducible results. The concept includes reproducibility of physiological measurements, which may be used to develop rules to assess probability or prognosis, or response to a stimulus; reproducibility of occurrence of a condition; and reproducibility of experimental results. Reliability and Validity,Reliability of Result,Reproducibility Of Result,Reproducibility of Finding,Validity of Result,Validity of Results,Face Validity,Reliability (Epidemiology),Reliability of Results,Reproducibility of Findings,Test-Retest Reliability,Validity (Epidemiology),Finding Reproducibilities,Finding Reproducibility,Of Result, Reproducibility,Of Results, Reproducibility,Reliabilities, Test-Retest,Reliability, Test-Retest,Result Reliabilities,Result Reliability,Result Validities,Result Validity,Result, Reproducibility Of,Results, Reproducibility Of,Test Retest Reliability,Validity and Reliability,Validity, Face
D021621 Imaging, Three-Dimensional The process of generating three-dimensional images by electronic, photographic, or other methods. For example, three-dimensional images can be generated by assembling multiple tomographic images with the aid of a computer, while photographic 3-D images (HOLOGRAPHY) can be made by exposing film to the interference pattern created when two laser light sources shine on an object. Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional Imaging,Imaging, Three-Dimensional, Computer Assisted,3-D Image,3-D Imaging,Computer-Generated 3D Imaging,Three-Dimensional Image,Three-Dimensional Imaging, Computer Generated,3 D Image,3 D Imaging,3-D Images,3-D Imagings,3D Imaging, Computer-Generated,3D Imagings, Computer-Generated,Computer Assisted Three Dimensional Imaging,Computer Generated 3D Imaging,Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional Imagings,Computer-Generated 3D Imagings,Image, 3-D,Image, Three-Dimensional,Images, 3-D,Images, Three-Dimensional,Imaging, 3-D,Imaging, Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional,Imaging, Computer-Generated 3D,Imaging, Three Dimensional,Imagings, 3-D,Imagings, Computer-Assisted Three-Dimensional,Imagings, Computer-Generated 3D,Imagings, Three-Dimensional,Three Dimensional Image,Three Dimensional Imaging, Computer Generated,Three-Dimensional Images,Three-Dimensional Imaging,Three-Dimensional Imaging, Computer-Assisted,Three-Dimensional Imagings,Three-Dimensional Imagings, Computer-Assisted

Related Publications

A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
September 2012, The Angle orthodontist,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
January 1981, Rivista italiana di stomatologia,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
April 2008, Hua xi kou qiang yi xue za zhi = Huaxi kouqiang yixue zazhi = West China journal of stomatology,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
January 2015, Veterinary surgery : VS,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
September 2006, Morphologie : bulletin de l'Association des anatomistes,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
May 2013, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of engineering in medicine,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
March 2011, Annali di stomatologia,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
July 2010, Journal of medical physics,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
April 2010, Journal of cranio-maxillo-facial surgery : official publication of the European Association for Cranio-Maxillo-Facial Surgery,
A Debelmas, and S Ketoff, and S Lanciaux, and P Corre, and M Friess, and R H Khonsari
October 2009, Skeletal radiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!