Comparison of psychiatric screening Instruments: GHQ-28, BSI and MMPI. 2019

Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
School of Medicine, Ghom University of Medical Sciences, Ghom, Iran.

BACKGROUND Clinical interview comprises a method for of psychiatric disorders diagnosis. Given the cost, time, and expertise required for clinical assessment; alternative tools to accurately substitute clinical interviews are having high value. We conduct this study to compare the screening accuracy of GHQ-28, BSI, and MMPI. METHODS Considering a diagnostic value, this study was conducted on 983 students and 3 psychiatric screening tools; GHQ-28, BSI, and MMPI were completed by students. Among the whole participants, 237 students were interviewed by the clinical psychiatrists on the basis of DSM-IV-IR Criteria. Based on ANOVO and Chi-square, results compare was made. Kappa correlation -coefficient was calculated in a pairwise manner; eventually the diagnostic accuracy of each tool was determined by the means of ROC analysis. RESULTS The diversity of psychiatric disorders by GHQ-28, was about 39.1, on the basis of BST was 44.8% and 44% for MMPI. The sensitivity and specificity of GHQ-28 was 85.9% and 87.8% considering 21.5 as the cut-off point; respectively. Considering 41/5 as the cut-off point for the BSI test, sensitivity and specificity were 81.2% and 90.8%; respectively, and 88.2% and 91.4% for the MMPI test with the cut-off point of 63.5 compared to clinical interview, the MMPI test was associated with the greatest accurate staging, ranging about 90.3%. CONCLUSIONS The results of this study according to clinical assessment reveal that GHQ-28, BSI, and MMPI psychiatric tools have high sensitivity and specificity and MMPI possessed the greatest efficiency compared to other evaluated tools.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
January 2003, Nordic journal of psychiatry,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
January 2011, Journal of physiotherapy,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
September 2008, Journal of behavior therapy and experimental psychiatry,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
January 1987, Journal of personality assessment,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
April 1979, The British journal of psychiatry : the journal of mental science,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
January 2013, Annals of African medicine,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
April 1981, Journal of personality assessment,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
March 2004, Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
March 2018, International journal of population data science,
Jamileh Jahangirian, and Hossein Akbari, and Ehsan Dadgostar
July 2017, Iranian journal of public health,
Copied contents to your clipboard!