Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation at Different Frequencies for Postherpetic Neuralgia: A Double-Blind, Sham-Controlled, Randomized Trial. 2019

Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
Department of Pain Management, Xuanwu Hospital Capital Medical University, Beijing, China; Beijing Jishuitan Hospital, Beijing, China.

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) at 5 Hz and 10 Hz is effective in improving pain, sleep quality, and anxiety among patients with postherpetic neuralgia (PHN). But it has not been reported which frequency is more effective and which frequency is safer. This study aimed to observe the efficacy and safety of rTMS at different high frequencies (5 Hz, 10 Hz) for PHN. The design of the study was a prospective randomized, controlled clinical trial. The research was conducted within a department of pain management at a university hospital in China. Sixty patients with PHN who were treated at the Department of Pain Management at Xuanwu Hospital of Capital Medical University were recruited. Using a computer-created number list, the cases were equally divided into 3 groups (n = 20), namely, the sham rTMS group, 5-Hz rTMS group, and 10-Hz rTMS group. The sham rTMS group received sham stimulation, and the other 2 groups received high-frequency (5-Hz and 10-Hz) rTMS, respectively. The primary motor cortex (M1) on the healthy side was stimulated with an intensity of 80% transcranial magnetic stimulation (RMT). For the 5-Hz rTMS group, each stimulation session consisted of a series of 300 one-second pulses with a frequency of 5 Hz and an interval of 2.5 seconds between each train, giving a total of 1500 pulses per session. For the 10-Hz rTMS group, each stimulation session consisted of a series of 300 0.5-second pulses with a frequency of 10 Hz and an interval of 3 seconds between each train, giving a total of 1500 pulses per session; the total time of stimulations was 17.5 minutes. rTMS was performed once daily for 10 days. The 3 groups received conventional medication therapy. Baseline data (gender, age, course of disease, affected side) were recorded in the 3 groups. At different time points (before treatment, T0; during treatment, T1-T10; 1 month after treatment, T11; and 3 months after treatment, T12), the patients were evaluated on the following scales: Visual Analog Scale (VAS), short-form McGill Pain Questionnaire (SF-MPQ), Quality of Life (QOL) scale, sleep quality (SQ) scale, Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS), Patient Global Impression of Change (PGIC), and incidence of adverse events. Compared with the sham rTMS group, there was a significant reduction in VAS scores in the 5-Hz rTMS group and 10-Hz rTMS group at T2-T12 (P < .05). VAS scores in the 10-Hz rTMS group at T7-T12 were significantly lower compared with the 5-Hz rTMS group (P < .05). The average VAS reduction was significantly different between the 5-Hz and 10-Hz rTMS groups; 28.3% (95% confidence interval [CI],19.48%-49.35%), compared to 39.89% (95% CI, 22.47%-58.64%), with (F = 5.289, P = .022). The 3 groups did not differ significantly in general SF-MPQ, QOL, SQ, SDS, and PGIC scores. However, the QQL, SQ, and PGIC scores of the 5-Hz rTMS group and the 10-HZ rTMS group at T12 were significantly higher than that of the sham rTMS group. The study's follow-up period was limited to 3 months. rTMS at either frequency, 5 Hz or 10 Hz, relieved PHN and improved the patients' quality of life. rTMS at 10 Hz was superior to rTMS at 5 Hz in terms of pain relief, quality of life, and improvement in sleep quality, though the latter had higher safety. rTMS at either 5 Hz or 10 Hz can be used as an adjuvant therapy for PHN. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation, postherpetic neuralgia, pain evaluation.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011446 Prospective Studies Observation of a population for a sufficient number of persons over a sufficient number of years to generate incidence or mortality rates subsequent to the selection of the study group. Prospective Study,Studies, Prospective,Study, Prospective
D011788 Quality of Life A generic concept reflecting concern with the modification and enhancement of life attributes, e.g., physical, political, moral, social environment as well as health and disease. HRQOL,Health-Related Quality Of Life,Life Quality,Health Related Quality Of Life
D002681 China A country spanning from central Asia to the Pacific Ocean. Inner Mongolia,Manchuria,People's Republic of China,Sinkiang,Mainland China
D004311 Double-Blind Method A method of studying a drug or procedure in which both the subjects and investigators are kept unaware of who is actually getting which specific treatment. Double-Masked Study,Double-Blind Study,Double-Masked Method,Double Blind Method,Double Blind Study,Double Masked Method,Double Masked Study,Double-Blind Methods,Double-Blind Studies,Double-Masked Methods,Double-Masked Studies,Method, Double-Blind,Method, Double-Masked,Methods, Double-Blind,Methods, Double-Masked,Studies, Double-Blind,Studies, Double-Masked,Study, Double-Blind,Study, Double-Masked
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D000368 Aged A person 65 years of age or older. For a person older than 79 years, AGED, 80 AND OVER is available. Elderly

Related Publications

Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
January 2022, Basic and clinical neuroscience,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
January 2015, Brain stimulation,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
September 2016, The British journal of psychiatry : the journal of mental science,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
July 2016, Otology & neurotology : official publication of the American Otological Society, American Neurotology Society [and] European Academy of Otology and Neurotology,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
December 2021, Brain : a journal of neurology,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
June 2022, Progress in neuro-psychopharmacology & biological psychiatry,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
October 2021, World psychiatry : official journal of the World Psychiatric Association (WPA),
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
January 2023, Brain stimulation,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
July 2013, Pain,
Qian Pei, and Baishan Wu, and Yuanzhang Tang, and Xiaohui Yang, and Liping Song, and Nan Wang, and Yan Li, and Chenli Sun, and Shumin Ma, and Jiaxiang Ni
January 2020, Alzheimer's & dementia (New York, N. Y.),
Copied contents to your clipboard!