Extensive X-ray absorption fine structure measurements and analysis have been made on azidomet- and methemerythrin and on the native forms of oxy- and deoxyhemerythrin. Due to the availability of models that have been synthesized to mimic the active site of hemerythrin, it was possible to make a thorough assessment of the various errors in the structural parameters determined by the analysis. It is found that the largest source of error is the lack of complete transferability of amplitude and phase between the standards and hemerythrin. This is of particular importance in distinguishing the contributions of the second-shell low-Z atoms and, thus, has a substantial influence on the determination of the iron-iron distance. The internal consistencies of the various checks and a new formulation of error analysis for the structural parameters give us confidence in the structure determined for the active site. The main result is that as O2 is released from oxyhemerythrin, the mu-oxo bridge between the two iron atoms in the active site with an Fe-O distance of 1.8 A converts to a mu-hydroxo bridge in deoxyhemerythrin, expanding the Fe-O distance to 2.0 A. The Fe-Fe distance expands proportionally from 3.24 A in oxyhemerythrin to 3.57 A in deoxyhemerythrin so as to keep the Fe-O-Fe bridging angle approximately constant. These conclusions provide experimental support for the structures of oxy- and deoxyhemerythrin proposed previously on the basis of spectroscopic and preliminary X-ray crystallographic data.